EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Statutory Interpretation “Laced” With a De Minimis Amount of Vanilla - Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Diageo SA (Pty) Ltd [2024] ZASCA 158

Silke De Lange, Monique Malan

Obiter · 10.04.2026 · 47 (1)

DOI: 10.17159/ybfkx751 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Obiter, online erschienen am 10.04.2026. Verfasst von Silke De Lange und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This case note analyses and comments on the Supreme Court of Appeal’s (SCA) judgment of 15 November 2024 in Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Diageo SA (Pty) Ltd [2024] JOL 67602 (SCA) (SCA judgment). The dispute concerns the tariff classification of a locally manufactured liqueur, Cape Velvet Cream Original (CVCO), for purposes of determining the applicable excise duty rate. To promote the labour-intensive wine industry, a lower rate of excise duty was introduced for liqueurs containing only “wine spirits to which other non-alcoholic ingredients have been added.” CVCO is made from wine spirits to which other ingredients, including a flavouring, are added. The flavouring consists of, inter alia, vanilla extract (which has an alcohol content of 0.6%). After the ingredients making the flavouring have been combined in their respective quantities, the flavouring has an alcohol content of 0.002%. The parties disagreed on whether the ingredients added to the wine spirits were non-alcoholic, with Diageo (the taxpayer) contending that they were and the South African Revenue Service (SARS) contending that they were not. The dispute turns on the interpretation of the aforementioned phrase in the legislation. Preceding the appeal to the SCA, the full bench of the high court, taking the relevant provision’s purpose and context into account, held that as the alcohol content contributed by the vanilla was so minute, it could be ignored by virtue of the application of the de minimis non curat lex principle. This decision was, however, overturned on appeal, with the SCA holding that the phrase’s wording is “plain and unambiguous” and that “non-alcoholic” should thus be given its ordinary, grammatical meaning of “containing no alcohol”. The SCA thus concludes that both the vanilla and the flavouring are “alcoholic”. Accordingly, it upheld SARS’s classification and as such, CVCO does not qualify for the lower excise duty rate. The SCA was unwilling to apply the de minimis principle, which we argue is wrong. Furthermore, we highlight some errors and inconsistencies in the SCA judgment and assert that the SCA did not correctly apply the prevailing approach to statutory interpretation laid out by the Constitutional Court. Finally, we offer a word of caution as to the potential broader implications of the interpretative approach as applied by the SCA in this case and appeal to the Constitutional Court to bring sobriety back to the courts’ application of the unitary approach to statutory interpretation.

Zitieren

APA

Lange, S. D., & Malan, M. (2026). Statutory Interpretation “Laced” With a De Minimis Amount of Vanilla - Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Diageo SA (Pty) Ltd [2024] ZASCA 158. Obiter, 47(1). https://doi.org/10.17159/ybfkx751

Vancouver

Lange SD, Malan M. Statutory Interpretation “Laced” With a De Minimis Amount of Vanilla - Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Diageo SA (Pty) Ltd [2024] ZASCA 158. Obiter. 2026;47(1). doi:10.17159/ybfkx751

BibTeX
@article{Lange2026,
  author = {Lange, Silke De and Malan, Monique},
  title = {Statutory Interpretation “Laced” With a De Minimis Amount of Vanilla - Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Diageo SA (Pty) Ltd [2024] ZASCA 158},
  journal = {Obiter},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {47},
  number = {1},
  doi = {10.17159/ybfkx751}
}
Kostenlos starten →