Defending a Dissertation on Medieval Studies During the War: M. D. Bushmakin’s PhD Thesis (1942)
Izvestia of the Ural federal university. Series 2. Humanities and Arts · 17.08.2026 · 28 (2) · 101–116
DOI: 10.15826/izv2.2026.28.2.024 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Izvestia of the Ural federal university. Series 2. Humanities and Arts, online erschienen am 17.08.2026. Verfasst von Artyom M. Skvortsov. Die Arbeit nennt 7 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines the history of the preparation and defence, in March 1942, of The Foreign Policy of Henry IV, the PhD thesis by the Kazan-based medievalist M. D. Bushmakin, which sheds light on certain aspects of the culture of doctoral research during the war years. In addition to the thesis itself, this study draws upon Bushmakin’s academic works, his personal correspondence, the memoirs of his contemporaries, legislative and regulatory acts, and administrative records from Kazan University. The article traces the author’s path to obtaining his academic degree and highlights the role played by the Moscow medievalists N. P. Gratsiansky and S. D. Skazkin in helping Bushmakin determine the topic of his research. Close attention is paid to analysing the structure of the dissertation, the sources used, the candidate’s methodology for studying historical documents, and the style of the thesis. The author of the article concludes that Bushmakin’s theoretical framework is eclectic: his thesis mechanically combines pre-revolutionary traditions of historiography, a class-based approach and the candidate’s extensive experience as a lecturer. Only one section of the thesis (on the so-called ‘Grand Design’ of Henry IV) was presented as a solution to a scholarly problem, whilst the remaining sections were characterised by a journalistic style. An analysis of the text reveals the author’s tendency to follow the models of nineteenth-century historiography, while his endeavour to frame the historical material within the Marxist paradigm led to a loss of narrative coherence. The absence of a comparative analysis of sources and an uncritical approach to them led to the idealisation of Henry IV. The thesis was highly praised by the external reviewers (E. V. Tarle and B. F. Porshnev) and approved by the Academic Council of Kazan University. However, after the war, when the standards for doctoral theses were raised, Bushmakin’s desire to become a Doctor Habilitatus came up against his actual inability to write a thesis that met academic criteria.
Zitieren
APA
Skvortsov, A. M. (2026). Defending a Dissertation on Medieval Studies During the War: M. D. Bushmakin’s PhD Thesis (1942). Izvestia of the Ural federal university. Series 2. Humanities and Arts, 28(2), 101–116. https://doi.org/10.15826/izv2.2026.28.2.024
Vancouver
Skvortsov AM. Defending a Dissertation on Medieval Studies During the War: M. D. Bushmakin’s PhD Thesis (1942). Izvestia of the Ural federal university. Series 2. Humanities and Arts. 2026;28(2):101–116. doi:10.15826/izv2.2026.28.2.024
BibTeX
@article{Skvortsov2026,
author = {Skvortsov, Artyom M.},
title = {Defending a Dissertation on Medieval Studies During the War: M. D. Bushmakin’s PhD Thesis (1942)},
journal = {Izvestia of the Ural federal university. Series 2. Humanities and Arts},
year = {2026},
volume = {28},
number = {2},
pages = {101–116},
doi = {10.15826/izv2.2026.28.2.024}
}
EUVIMED