Modeling dynamical function: sparsely synchronized frameworks for deep brain stimulation?
Journal of Medicine and Therapeutics · 2018
DOI: 10.15761/jmt.1000124 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Medicine and Therapeutics, 2018. Verfasst von Denis Larrivee. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 2-mal zitiert (Crossref).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
High frequency electrical stimulation of deep brain structures, known as deep brain stimulation (DBS), has been successfully used to treat a number of refractory neurological, movement, and psychiatric related, disorders; yet its mechanism of action is largely unknown. Employed for most movement neuropathologies, the expanding number of therapeutic applications suggests a mechanism of action mimicking basic brain operation, oscillatory activity. A general hypothesis for its effectiveness is that DBS ameliorates cognitive dysfunction through a generalized disruption of aberrant oscillations, such as the heightened β oscillations seen in Parkinson’s Disease (PD). Existing evidence suggests, however, that its mechanism of operation is likely to be more complex and may be better framed as an interaction with sparsely synchronized frameworks for neural transmission. . Correspondence to: Denis Larrivee, Loyola University Chicago, USA and Mind and Brain Institute, University of Navarra, Pamplona, Spain, E-mail: sallar1@ aol.com Received: March 15, 2018; Accepted: March 29, 2018; Published: March 31,2018 Introduction High frequency electrical stimulation of deep brain structures, known as deep brain stimulation (DBS), has been successfully used to treat a number of refractory neurological, movement and psychiatric related, disorders, yet its mechanism of action is largely unknown. In movement disorders DBS is therapeutic for tremors, dystonia, and dyskinesia, yielding a 50% improvement in PD on the Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale [1]. In psychiatric diseases DBS shows promise for treatment of obsessive compulsive disorder and Gilles de la Tourette syndrome, and has a limited impact on major depressive syndrome. Historically, high frequency electrical stimulation came into practice as a therapeutic intervention to replace ablative surgery for Parkinson’s in the mid-20th century, although electric stimulation had been used in treatment of nervous system disorders for centuries before [2]. Thalamotomies and pallidotomies successfully abolished the tremors, but their permanent effects were deemed unsuitable when it was observed that the effects of DBS were not only similar to those introduced by surgery but were also reversible; potentially adverse side effects of DBS, thus, were removed when the stimulus was terminated. From its initial use for Parkinson’s the spectrum of therapeutic interventions has since greatly broadened, and now includes most movement neuropathologies as well as an increasing number of psychiatric diseases. The expanding number of therapeutic applications for which DBS is employed suggests that its mechanism of action likely involves basic operational features used by the brain. Because the form of stimulation is rhythmic there is the implicit likelihood that these corresponding neural mechanisms are similarly rhythmic; increasingly, these are proposed to be oscillatory [3]. Rhythmic activity, notably, is a ubiquitous feature of brain operation, and has been observed at the single neuron level, with varying spiking patterns [4], as well as at network levels, with variable inhibitory and excitatory feedback configurations [5]. Its elicitation and propagation appear to be due to such factors as subthreshold currents, originating from post synaptic potentials and rhythmic firing of synchronized neural groups [6], as well as physical properties like anatomical configuration and noise contributions [7], that together yield a complex resonating architecture. The significance of oscillatory activity in brain function was first made apparent through its ability to address a cardinal difficulty of the hierarchical abstractive model, proposed by Wiesel and Hubel [8], and used to explain how information was processed in the visual cortex. In this model input from the retinal ganglion cells was integrated through successive neuronal layers to assimilate an increasingly complex and abstract portrait of sensory information. Cortical motion detector cells, for example, determined stimulus speed by summating inputs from sequentially stimulated, retinal photoreceptors, and orientation cells then integrated the summated inputs to ascertain the stimulus’ direction. The hypothesized abstraction, however, had the conceptual consequence of progressively restricting the numbers of neurons that participated in the abstraction, eventually limiting them to a small population of cardinal neurons stated to contain the salient sensory information. Oscillators, by contrast, can combine in virtually any combination to recreate encoded feature representations. Hence, in the oscillation model there is no numerical neural restriction with information regress and so, potentially, an infinite number of combinatorial variants can be generated [6,9]. How DBS may ameliorate disease conditions thus plausibly entails modulation of oscillatory activity, presumably by modifying intrinsic features of oscillations, like maintenance, synchronization and desynchronization. Indeed, current thinking favours etiological disease models where aberrant oscillatory functioning is directly linked to the observed symptoms and where DBS could intervene by modifying Larrivee D (2018) Modeling dynamical function: sparsely synchronized frameworks for deep brain stimulation? J Med Therap, 2018 doi: 10.15761/JMT.1000124 Volume 2(1): 2-5 oscillation rhythms. Among the prevailing hypotheses on how DBS ameliorates cognitive dysfunctions is through a generalized disruption of aberrant oscillations [10,11] like those that are symptomatic of Parkinson’s. Classically, however, DBS effectiveness in Parkinson’s has been premised on the mimicking of ablative surgery of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) [3,12]. The overactivity of the STN and its target, the globus pallidus, which was postulated to underlie the motor symptoms of Parkinson’s, as well as its clinical inactivation by surgery and loss of symptoms, led to the suggestion that DBS suppressed STN output through a modulation of STN firing rates. This view has been challenged by Carlson et al. [10] who find no change in STN firing but, rather, the elicitation of random nerve patterning of STN neurons during stimulation. Based on these contraindications DBS is proposed to suppress abnormal oscillations by randomizing or otherwise interrupting disease induced patterns. Whether this explanation is broadly consilient with current findings and what mechanism, if any, may be invoked for DBS is here discussed in regard to two frequently invoked theoretical models of oscillatory behaviour, the Theory of Weakly Coupled Oscillation (TWCO) [13] and the sparse network model for synchronized communication [5,14]. It is proposed that DBS development may better invoke theoretical models of oscillatory activity in therapeutic strategy. DBS and oscillatory features Synchronization and desynchronization Intuitively, invoking a single mechanism of action for DBS is appealing, since the technical implementation is not confounded by complex technical outcomes, that is, technical devices yield output more clocklike than biological [5], and the proposed creation of competing interferences to reduce oscillatory power is consilent with physical principal. Yet, whether DBS evokes such extensive disassociation, and the part that may be played by disassociation in ameliorating aberrant oscillations, remains unsettled. Tremors in Parkinson’s, for example, persist in the waking state, when motions are most frequent, but which has traditionally been characterized as disassociated a circumstance likely designed to promote maximal information transfer in neural coding and are reduced, or at least apparently so, in sleep, when large amplitude slow oscillations are evident [7]. These observations, rather, seem to indicate a more complex influence of DBS on oscillatory behaviour. The complexity of this influence is seen in the several now known features of neural oscillations and how these underwrite brain operation. Aberrations, introduced, by definition, by disease, can alter these features, modifying oscillatory behaviour and changing the sort of interaction that DBS structures with oscillators in order to relieve the diseased state. Their intrinsic ability to combine, for example, is achieved by the synchronization of their frequencies, that is, they mutually adapt their rhythms, a physical observation made centuries ago by Huygens [13]. Although the mechanisms by which neural synchronization occurs are not precisely known, spike timing appears to be an important factor, though a complex one [5]. Oscillations enhance neuronal spike probability by defining, through repetitive cycles, periods of higher excitability, where neurons are sensitive and more responsive to incoming trains, and periods of reduced sensitivity, where spike occurrence is less. This means that there exist intrinsic tendencies toward synchrony where oscillators can properly align, and their frequencies then resonate in unison. Due to their ubiquity throughout the nervous system they are capable of extraordinary combinatorial variety, including interareal as well as interlevel combination. Neural synchronization in the gamma frequency range, notably, has been reported in cortical and subcortical structures [12]. Their regulation, while unknown in details, is thus undoubtedly multifaceted and likely to be multiply impacted by DBS. Resonating in unison, termed phase locking, has the important effect of enhancing information transfer (Pierce, 1981), hence of facilitating communication between brain domains. However, in the brain, rigid or full phase locking is, in fact, rarely if ever achieved [13]. Some insight into why oscillation resonance is less than perfectly attained can be ascertained from the role played by oscillators in yielding functionally salient outcomes, not solely through a unimodal synchrony but also through recombination. The basic need to reform multiple
Zitieren
APA
Larrivee, D. (2018). Modeling dynamical function: sparsely synchronized frameworks for deep brain stimulation?. Journal of Medicine and Therapeutics. https://doi.org/10.15761/jmt.1000124
Vancouver
Larrivee D. Modeling dynamical function: sparsely synchronized frameworks for deep brain stimulation?. Journal of Medicine and Therapeutics. 2018. doi:10.15761/jmt.1000124
BibTeX
@article{Larrivee2018,
author = {Larrivee, Denis},
title = {Modeling dynamical function: sparsely synchronized frameworks for deep brain stimulation?},
journal = {Journal of Medicine and Therapeutics},
year = {2018},
doi = {10.15761/jmt.1000124}
}
EUVIMED