Is vaccine dissent based on science?
Health Education and Care · 2017
DOI: 10.15761/hec.1000129 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health Education and Care, 2017. Verfasst von Vernon LF.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The mere mention of a possible link between vaccines and disorders such as autism will instantly elicit a visceral response from many pediatricians. In most cases the response is to point out that the paper linking the MMR vaccine to autism authored by Dr. Andrew Wakefield and colleagues has been discredited, with Wakefield, vaccine advocates whipping boy losing his license to practice medicine in the UK. The implication being that anti-vaccine groups are relying on flawed or fraudulent data or that this is only study to ever make a connection between vaccines and autism, so the issue has been put to rest. Medicine has a history of exercising its cultural authority to suppress opposition opinion. These include Dr. William Coley, who observed one of his patients began recovering from cancer after he was infected with Streptococcus pyogenes. This led Coley to theorize that post-surgical infections helped defeat cancer by mobilizing the immune system, but almost all his scientific peers rejected the idea, writing it off as “crazy and dangerous”. Coley died in 1936, and with his death his theory and work which were looked down on as “quack medicine” died too. Coley’s theory of immune system stimulation to fight cancer was “surpassed” by “scientific” chemotherapy and radiation. Francis Peyton Rous was a pathologist who discovered that certain viruses were linked to the development of certain cancers was ostracized by his peers and both he and his findings were largely discredited. However, in 1966, over 50 years after his initial findings, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. This paper is not about Wakefield nor is it a defense of him or his research, it is however intended to point out that there has been an organized attempt to silence vaccine opponents, both professionals and parents who, backed with valid research as defined by pro-vaccine’s definition of “real science” have raised legitimate concerns as to the safety and efficacy of certain vaccines. Before latching onto the Wakefield case as the holy grail to prove that vaccine opposition groups rely on fraudulent or weak data to advance their agenda, vaccine advocates need to examine their own science and those who are supplying it. “It is dangerous to be right in matters on which the established authorities are wrong.”
Zitieren
APA
LF, V. (2017). Is vaccine dissent based on science?. Health Education and Care. https://doi.org/10.15761/hec.1000129
Vancouver
LF V. Is vaccine dissent based on science?. Health Education and Care. 2017. doi:10.15761/hec.1000129
BibTeX
@article{LF2017,
author = {LF, Vernon},
title = {Is vaccine dissent based on science?},
journal = {Health Education and Care},
year = {2017},
doi = {10.15761/hec.1000129}
}
EUVIMED