EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The Emergence of Outreach Ambassador Role Identities in Undergraduate Engineering Students

Joanna Garner, Christine Haas, Michael Alley, Avi Kaplan

The Journal of STEM Outreach · 2018

DOI: 10.15695/jstem/v1i1.27 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Journal of STEM Outreach, 2018. Verfasst von Joanna Garner und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 5-mal zitiert (Crossref).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

One common form of outreach by colleges of engineering is the ambassador program, whereby students interact with middle and high school audiences in an effort to promote STEM-related career choices. Although the impact of such programs on K-12 students’ knowledge and attitudes has been examined, less is known about the impact on the ambassadors themselves. In this research study, we use multiple case study methodology to understand the development of the ambassador role and its emergence at an initial workshop in which undergraduate students learn to craft and deliver engineering-related outreach talks. Narrative data from interviews with a purposefully diverse sample of six participants allowed us to analyze emerging ambassador role identities using the Dynamic Systems Model of Role Identity (Kaplan and Garner, 2017). Findings address three questions: (1) How do individuals’ existing role identities inform the motivation to become an ambassador? (2) How did the role of workshop participant shape the development of the ambassador role? (3) Which features of the training workshop promoted the formulation of an engineering ambassador role identity? Analyses revealed that the ambassador role identity originates from and was very much aligned with components of students’ other, pre-existing role identities. Also evident was a bridging sub-role of presenter, which was anchored in the action possibility of high quality technical communication. Theoretical and practical considerations for preparing undergraduate engineering students to take on an ambassador role are considered. INTRODUCTION Pre-college outreach has become an increasingly popular activity for undergraduate students (Orsak, 2003; Moskal and Skokan, 2011). Involvement varies in scope from single events to summer camps and even year-long engineering design competitions (After School Alliance, 2011; Stake and Mares, 2001). Underlying themes for such events include the variety of career opportunities for engineers, the societal benefits of engineering related work, and the need for STEM participation by historically underrepresented groups (Anagnos et al., 2014). Events can educate the public in these and other messages that can help to change local conversations about the appeal of science and engineering (NAE, 2008) and introduce future students to university campuses and degree programs. One particular outreach format is the ambassador program, in which groups of undergraduate students deliver in-class presentations and hands-on activities to middle and high school students in order to illustrate the nature, impact and possibilities of engineering. Such visits can increase the audience’s knowledge, interest and identification with science and engineering as well as awareness of and interest in STEM-related degrees and career options (Nadelson and Callahan, 2011; Molina-Gaudo et al., 2010; Habash and Surtamm, 2010; Sahin, 2013; Smaill, 2010; Wei and Wonch Hill, 2018). However, little is known about the ways in which participation in an ambassador outreach program might act as a professional development vehicle for the undergraduate student. In this article, we build on previous research that has explored students’ motivations for outreach participation and explore the topic of outreach participation from the unique perspective of students’ role identity development as ambassadors. This perspective allows us to examine students’ self-perceptions, goals, beliefs, and possibilities for action in relation to their perceptions of themselves as ambassadors for their chosen field and representatives of a college or university. Relatedly, since ambassadors often go through an initial training period where they learn about specific pro-engineering messages from Changing the Conversation (NAE, 2008) including “engineers help shape the future,” “engineering is essential to our health, happiness and safety,” “engineers make a world of difference,” and “engineers are creative problem solvers”—as well as strategies for presenting information about science and engineering in interesting Emergence of Outreach Role Identities Garner Vol. 1, December 2018 Journal of STEM Outreach 2 and relevant ways for middle and high school audiences— we were also interested in gaining an understanding of the context and conditions in which the ambassador role begins. Insights derived from this research might then be used to design and evaluate ambassador programs and monitor them for the presence of identity-based outcomes as well as the effectiveness of solution-oriented messages that can tackle the problem of misconceptions about the field of engineering. Students’ motivation to participate in engineering outreach. As a first step toward considering how students come to think of themselves as ambassadors for their field, it is important to consider their motivation to participate in a time-consuming activity that typically offers little financial reward. Some researchers have proposed that students may be attracted to organizations because they convey values that align with their personal and professional goals (Bergeson et al., 2014; Lamb, 2010; Serpe and Stryker, 1987). Therefore, messages conveyed by outreach programs such as the application of engineering to solving the world’s problems (UNESCO, 2010), the need for diversity among the STEM workforce (President’s Council, 2010), and the need for creativity and problem solving within engineering (NAE, 2008), may resonate for students who consider these values to be foundational to their motivation for a professional career. For example, in one qualitative study of undergraduate members of the ambassadorial group Engineers without Borders (EWB), Litchfield and Javernick-Will (2015) revealed that members’ professional goals tended to align engineering with social justice, humanitarian work, community development, and environmental sustainability. Similarly, three quarters of the respondents in a survey-based study of undergraduate engineering ambassadors by Anagnos et al. (2014) indicated that ambassador participation was commensurate with students’ personal goals of making a difference in their communities. In contrast, just 20 percent of respondents reported involvment with ambassadorship as a means of doing well in their studies, and only 6 percent expressed interest in the program as a way to explore options for a future career in engineering. Some studies have noted that engineering students who endorse social engagement and social justice within their personal and career goals tend to be diverse in their cultural and racial backgrounds (Litchfield and Javernick-Will, 2015; Tate and Linn, 2005). These students are also more likely to become involved in service and advocacy activities at the university level, perhaps because these activities are aligned with their own personal values and experiences (Lichtinger and Kaplan, 2011). Set within the national context of a need to increase diversity among engineers (President’s Council, 2010), such studies hint at the potential for harnessing a diverse group of students’ pre-existing interests and value commitments in order to engage future generations of STEM professionals. However, little is known about how such commitments intersect with students’ experiences during the context of pre-visit training experiences. A small number of studies have focused on the perceived impact of outreach participation. In a retrospective interview study of 19 engineering students, Bergeson et al. (2014) found that students attributed great meaning to interactions with other professionals and peers throughout the program. Interactions were interpreted as opportunities to observe others as role models and gatekeepers of professional actions, skills and behaviors. Students reported specific gains in their ability to connect engineering concepts with real world topics, and their confidence to communicate with non-expert audiences. They also reported gains in self-perceptions as engineers and purveyors of engineering content, personal value of an anticipated career in engineering, and satisfaction in raising others’ interests in engineering careers. Bergeson and colleagues interpreted these perceived benefits as examples of ways in which outreach participation influences students’ overall self-definitions as engineers and representatives of the field of engineering. Students’ personal affiliation and ascribed value of the field of engineering also suggested that ambassadorial activities impacted their commitment to engineering (Erikson, 1968; Serpe and Stryker, 1987). Taken together, these studies point to ambassadorship as a potential mechanism for satisfying and fostering motivational aspects of students’ early conceptualizations of their professional selves. A theoretical framework for studying outreach ambassadorship. Recently, researchers have focused on understanding the development of science and engineering identities, or perceptions of one’s self as a scientist or engineer, as factors that influence STEM persistence and attrition among historically underrepresented groups of students (Hazari et al., 2013; Papafilippou and Bentley, 2017; Steinke, 2017). Through identity-based perspectives on students’ motivation, such as possible selves (Marcus and Nurius, 1986), researchers have established that one’s sense of who one is and who one can (or cannot) become within a given field of study, career path, or life course, can act as a substantive source of motivated action (Allie et al., 2009; Oyserman et al., 2004; Nino, 2013; Nystrom, 2009). However, few scholars have investigated the potential multiplicity of STEM-related identities that may emerge over the time course of an undergraduate student’s period of enrollment at an institution, and how these may be related to specific experiences or opportunities such as ambassadorship. Moreover, researchers have not examined the cognitive and motivational pr

Zitieren

APA

Garner, J., Haas, C., Alley, M., & Kaplan, A. (2018). The Emergence of Outreach Ambassador Role Identities in Undergraduate Engineering Students. The Journal of STEM Outreach. https://doi.org/10.15695/jstem/v1i1.27

Vancouver

Garner J, Haas C, Alley M, Kaplan A. The Emergence of Outreach Ambassador Role Identities in Undergraduate Engineering Students. The Journal of STEM Outreach. 2018. doi:10.15695/jstem/v1i1.27

BibTeX
@article{Garner2018,
  author = {Garner, Joanna and Haas, Christine and Alley, Michael and Kaplan, Avi},
  title = {The Emergence of Outreach Ambassador Role Identities in Undergraduate Engineering Students},
  journal = {The Journal of STEM Outreach},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.15695/jstem/v1i1.27}
}
Kostenlos starten →