EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

A Study on the Typology of Perverting the Course of Justice at the Police Investigation Stage: Focusing on Investigators’ Confirmation Bias and Practical Behavioral Patterns

Sunjeong lm, Bo Hack Suh

Kyung Hee Law Journal · 30.06.2026 · 61 (2) · 149-190

DOI: 10.15539/khlj.61.2.4 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Kyung Hee Law Journal, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Sunjeong lm und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This study empirically identifies the manifestations and typologies of law distortion at each stage of police investigations against the backdrop of a historic transformation of Korea’s criminal justice system, marked by the enactment of Article 123-2 (Crime of Law Distortion) of the Criminal Act in March 2026 and the establishment of the Major Crimes Investigation Agency in October 2026. The findings indicate that law distortion in police investigations manifests not primarily through explicit statutory violations or arbitrary interpretations of law, but rather through distortions in the fact-finding process during the early stages of investigation, where premature judgments formed through biased hypothetical reasoning become entrenched and ultimately shape the legal evaluation of the case. The specific typologies of law distortion identified at each stage of the investigative process are as follows. First, the pre-case-registration stage: Investigators exploit procedural blind spots before a case is formally registered in the Criminal Justice Information System (KICS). Typical forms of law distortion include factual distortions by omission, such as intentionally concealing enforcement-related information or key material evidence; deliberately delaying investigations or refraining from formally registering cases by exploiting the “sunset guidelines” governing the closure of long-pending investigations; and administratively closing cases by treating multiple independent criminal charges as a single incident. Second, the active investigation and investigative record-preparation stage: Investigators may intentionally classify cases involving identifiable suspects as administratively unsolved in order to conceal them indefinitely. This stage is characterized by systematic distortions of investigative records, including statement-inducement distortion, selective-documentation distortion, and question-and-answer reconstruction distortion. These practices are accompanied by the overvaluation of inculpatory evidence, the undervaluation of exculpatory evidence, and the exclusion of exculpatory evidence from the investigative record. Third, the case-closing and legal-evaluation stage: Investigators abuse their independent authority to terminate investigations by arbitrarily interpreting the statutory elements of offenses in order to avoid the application of aggravated punishment provisions or to unjustifiably narrow or expand their scope. They may also improperly recharacterize criminal cases as private civil disputes, thereby excluding criminal conduct from the scope of criminal justice intervention. Taken together, law distortion in police investigations does not consist of isolated acts occurring at discrete stages of the investigative process. Rather, it operates through a reciprocal and cyclical structure in which distortions in fact-finding and distortions in the application of law continuously interact, reinforce one another, and ultimately shape investigative outcomes. The typology of law distortion at each stage of police investigations proposed in this study provides objective and practical evaluative criteria for inferring the requisite mens rea under the newly enacted offense of law distortion. Even where an investigator persistently denies such intent, these criteria enable an objective inference of the statutory purpose elements of the offense—namely, the intent to confer an unlawful or unjust benefit upon another person or the intent to infringe upon another person’s rights or interests.

Zitieren

APA

lm, S., & Suh, B. H. (2026). A Study on the Typology of Perverting the Course of Justice at the Police Investigation Stage: Focusing on Investigators’ Confirmation Bias and Practical Behavioral Patterns. Kyung Hee Law Journal, 61(2), 149-190. https://doi.org/10.15539/khlj.61.2.4

Vancouver

lm S, Suh BH. A Study on the Typology of Perverting the Course of Justice at the Police Investigation Stage: Focusing on Investigators’ Confirmation Bias and Practical Behavioral Patterns. Kyung Hee Law Journal. 2026;61(2):149-190. doi:10.15539/khlj.61.2.4

BibTeX
@article{lm2026,
  author = {lm, Sunjeong and Suh, Bo Hack},
  title = {A Study on the Typology of Perverting the Course of Justice at the Police Investigation Stage: Focusing on Investigators’ Confirmation Bias and Practical Behavioral Patterns},
  journal = {Kyung Hee Law Journal},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {61},
  number = {2},
  pages = {149--190},
  doi = {10.15539/khlj.61.2.4}
}
Kostenlos starten →