EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

An Empirical Study on Compensation for 1980s Forced Conscription Victims : Focusing on Compensation Determination Practices for 132 Victims

Dong-Joon Rhee

Kyung Hee Law Journal · 30.06.2026 · 61 (2) · 551-639

DOI: 10.15539/khlj.61.2.13 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Kyung Hee Law Journal, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Dong-Joon Rhee.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This study empirically analyzes the rationality of the standards for determining consolation money (non-pecuniary damages) in state-compensation suits brought by former university-student victims of forced conscription and the “Nokwha (ideological-conversion) Operation” during Korea's authoritarian rule in the 1980s, drawing on a dataset of 18 first-instance and 18 appellate judgments involving 132 plaintiffs. Although the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's decision of November 22, 2022 prompted a series of judgments for these victims of state violence, no systematic analysis had examined how the courts actually assess and quantify the plaintiffs' harm. Combining a 51-variable victim database, a structural analysis of judicial reasoning, and international comparison, the study finds the following. First, average awards range from KRW 45.71 million to 83.33 million across judicial panels, representing an approximately 1.82-fold disparity, or “panel effect” (an upper-bound estimate confounded with the case-group effect). Second, service duration and the award are effectively unrelated (r=0.080). Third, 131 of the 132 plaintiffs receive only an identical, formulaic presumption of mental distress. Fourth, there is a structural disconnect between the description of harm and the reasoning for the award. Fifth, the panel effect persists through appeal (from 1.82- to 1.50-fold), as the appellate courts do not systematically correct the disparity. The three principles adopted by Germany, Chile, and others in compensating victims of state violence—classification of harm types, ex ante setting of baseline amounts, and explicit aggravating and mitigating factors—are not found in the judgments analyzed. The structure in which panel and case-group factors explain about 21% of the variance in awards stands in tension with the principle of equality, and the blanket treatment of mental harm through a presumptive formula does not accord with human dignity's demand for a substantive assessment of individual harm. These findings can serve as a practical basis for future constitutional challenges, including the newly introduced constitutional complaint against court judgments (jaepan sowon). The study identifies the absence of any statutory standard for determining awards and calls for legislative, jurisprudential, and practical reforms to make such standards explicit.

Zitieren

APA

Rhee, D. (2026). An Empirical Study on Compensation for 1980s Forced Conscription Victims : Focusing on Compensation Determination Practices for 132 Victims. Kyung Hee Law Journal, 61(2), 551-639. https://doi.org/10.15539/khlj.61.2.13

Vancouver

Rhee D. An Empirical Study on Compensation for 1980s Forced Conscription Victims : Focusing on Compensation Determination Practices for 132 Victims. Kyung Hee Law Journal. 2026;61(2):551-639. doi:10.15539/khlj.61.2.13

BibTeX
@article{Rhee2026,
  author = {Rhee, Dong-Joon},
  title = {An Empirical Study on Compensation for 1980s Forced Conscription Victims : Focusing on Compensation Determination Practices for 132 Victims},
  journal = {Kyung Hee Law Journal},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {61},
  number = {2},
  pages = {551--639},
  doi = {10.15539/khlj.61.2.13}
}
Kostenlos starten →