Trademark Infringement and Luxury Goods Refurbishment: Reconstructing the Exhaustion Doctrine and the “Original Trademark Limitation Doctrine” (Supreme Court of Korea, Feb. 26, 2026, 2024Da311181)
Kyung Hee Law Journal · 30.03.2026 · 61 (1) · 271-308
DOI: 10.15539/khlj.61.1.8 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Kyung Hee Law Journal, online erschienen am 30.03.2026. Verfasst von Hyeon Sook Roh.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper examines the legal conflict between a property owner’s right of control under Article 211 of the Civil Act and the exclusive right to use a trademark under Article 89 of the Trademark Act in the context of luxury goods refurbishment. It analyzes the extent to which the burgeoning refurbishment industry can be justified under the exhaustion doctrine or whether it infringes upon the essential function of a trademark as an indicator of source. This study evaluates whether refurbishment activities constitute “processing” (Article 259 of the Civil Act) or “substantial remanufacturing” under the Trademark Act. It critically reviews the lack of clear legal standards in the Supreme Court’s decision (2024Da311181), which denied infringement by characterizing refurbishments for personal use as private services. Furthermore, it argues that the Court’s interpretation adopts an unduly narrow view of post-sale confusion, thereby weakening the protection of the trademark owner’s inherent right of trademark affixation. As an original legal criterion for establishing the boundaries of illegality, this study proposes the “Original Trademark Limitation Doctrine.” This doctrine recognizes that modifying the shape of a product through refurbishment is a legitimate exercise of property rights within the scope of the exhaustion doctrine. However, it establishes an objective standard under which infringement arises only when the aggregate amount of trademark symbols is increased beyond its original level by affixing new trademarks or re-affixing trademarks from other products. In addition, this study proposes prospective guidelines for future judicial practice, including remand proceedings before the Patent Court. These guidelines recommend exempting liability for damages for past acts due to the absence of clear legal standards, while mandating the institutionalization of refurbishment labeling to ensure transparent transactions. Ultimately, this study aims to resolve past uncertainties and achieve a fair balance between trademark protection and consumer sovereignty.
Zitieren
APA
Roh, H. S. (2026). Trademark Infringement and Luxury Goods Refurbishment: Reconstructing the Exhaustion Doctrine and the “Original Trademark Limitation Doctrine” (Supreme Court of Korea, Feb. 26, 2026, 2024Da311181). Kyung Hee Law Journal, 61(1), 271-308. https://doi.org/10.15539/khlj.61.1.8
Vancouver
Roh HS. Trademark Infringement and Luxury Goods Refurbishment: Reconstructing the Exhaustion Doctrine and the “Original Trademark Limitation Doctrine” (Supreme Court of Korea, Feb. 26, 2026, 2024Da311181). Kyung Hee Law Journal. 2026;61(1):271-308. doi:10.15539/khlj.61.1.8
BibTeX
@article{Roh2026,
author = {Roh, Hyeon Sook},
title = {Trademark Infringement and Luxury Goods Refurbishment: Reconstructing the Exhaustion Doctrine and the “Original Trademark Limitation Doctrine” (Supreme Court of Korea, Feb. 26, 2026, 2024Da311181)},
journal = {Kyung Hee Law Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {61},
number = {1},
pages = {271--308},
doi = {10.15539/khlj.61.1.8}
}
EUVIMED