EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

A Study on Estimated Taxation and the Burden of Proof in Tax Law : Focused on the Supreme Court Decision 2024Du49469 dated December 12, 2024

Hyun-Hee Lee

Kyung Hee Law Journal · 30.03.2026 · 61 (1) · 159-198

DOI: 10.15539/khlj.61.1.5 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Kyung Hee Law Journal, online erschienen am 30.03.2026. Verfasst von Hyun-Hee Lee.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

The imposition of taxes, which restricts the property rights of citizens, must be grounded in law in accordance with the constitutional principle of statutory reservation. In the case of national taxes, which constitute the majority of taxation, the calculation of taxable income should, pursuant to the Framework Act on National Taxes, conform to substantive reality. Such substantive reality is, in principle, verified based on accounting books and related evidentiary materials prepared in fulfillment of the taxpayer’s duty to cooperate. However, it is unrealistic to assume that all taxpayers will faithfully comply with such obligations. Accordingly, individual tax statutes provide for estimated taxation as a supplementary mechanism to substantive taxation in order to prevent gaps in taxation even under exceptional circumstances. The estimated taxation system is thus justified in terms of ensuring tax equity and preventing the loss of tax revenue. Nevertheless, while the current legal framework prescribes the requirements and methods of estimated taxation, it does not clearly regulate key legal issues such as its application, procedural aspects, or the allocation of the burden of proof. As a result, the relevant legal principles have largely been developed through judicial precedents and administrative interpretations. In this context, the Supreme Court decision of December 12, 2024 (2024Du49469) held that the tax authority’s method of calculating taxable income constituted an impermissible mixture of direct investigation and estimated assessment, and thus was unlawful. This decision raises two significant issues: first, the distinction between direct investigation and estimated assessment; and second, the allocation of the burden of proof, which is a decisive factor in tax litigation. Based on this problem awareness, this study first examines the general theory of the burden of proof developed in civil litigation, and then analyzes the structure of burden allocation across different types of litigation. It further explores, through case law, the allocation of the burden of proof in tax litigation, and examines the requirements and methods of estimated taxation under the Corporate Tax Act. Ultimately, this study aims to clarify the legal significance and limitations of the subject decision and to contribute to a proper understanding of the legal principles governing the application of estimated assessment.

Zitieren

APA

Lee, H. (2026). A Study on Estimated Taxation and the Burden of Proof in Tax Law : Focused on the Supreme Court Decision 2024Du49469 dated December 12, 2024. Kyung Hee Law Journal, 61(1), 159-198. https://doi.org/10.15539/khlj.61.1.5

Vancouver

Lee H. A Study on Estimated Taxation and the Burden of Proof in Tax Law : Focused on the Supreme Court Decision 2024Du49469 dated December 12, 2024. Kyung Hee Law Journal. 2026;61(1):159-198. doi:10.15539/khlj.61.1.5

BibTeX
@article{Lee2026,
  author = {Lee, Hyun-Hee},
  title = {A Study on Estimated Taxation and the Burden of Proof in Tax Law : Focused on the Supreme Court Decision 2024Du49469 dated December 12, 2024},
  journal = {Kyung Hee Law Journal},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {61},
  number = {1},
  pages = {159--198},
  doi = {10.15539/khlj.61.1.5}
}
Kostenlos starten →