EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The problem of ritual piety in the works of Kazan theological academy professor P. V. Znamensky

Tatiana Nekhorosheva

St. Tikhons' University Review · 30.06.2026 · 130 · 83-97

DOI: 10.15382/sturii2026130.83-97 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift St. Tikhons' University Review, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Tatiana Nekhorosheva.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This article analyzes how the issue of ritual piety was explored by the historian of the Russian Church, P.V. Znamensky. The author examines the causes, consequences, and methods for combating this phenomenon from the perspective of the Kazan professor. It is shown that the historian identified the causes of "blind adherence to rituals" as a lack of education, a reluctance to work on one's spiritual life, and an unwillingness to confront sinful inclinations. P. V. Znamensky believed that the consequences of "excessive reliance on rituals" included a lack of restraints on cruelty, immorality, and blasphemy. A proper understanding of Christian doctrine could have softened morals, but the "ritualistic approach" was incapable of this. The professor also considered ritual religiosity as the reason for the emergence of priests perceived exclusively as performers of rituals, and as a consequence, one of the sources of the isolation of the clergy. Furthermore, the historian noted that excessive emphasis on rituals could also cause problems in interethnic interactions, as the important (religious doctrine) was confused with the secondary (everyday and cultural differences). At the same time, P. V. Znamensky did not single out any particular historical period for which the "ritualistic trend" was most characteristic, believing that this problem manifested itself to varying degrees throughout Russian history and was characteristic not only of the laity but also of some clergy. While speaking extensively about holiness in the history of the Russian Church, the historian nevertheless did not consider it possible to ignore problems in the religious life of the people; he also proposed solutions. The professor saw education as the most effective way to combat "blind adherence to ritual," leading his readers to the conclusion that the Christian mission among the peoples of the empire should have been built on the educational system of N. I. Ilminsky, which would have avoided the dangers of the ritualistic trend. P. V. Znamensky's interest in this topic was likely based, on one hand, on episodes from his own biography, and on the other, on the need to defend N. I. Ilminsky's system.

Zitieren

APA

Nekhorosheva, T. (2026). The problem of ritual piety in the works of Kazan theological academy professor P. V. Znamensky. St. Tikhons' University Review, 130, 83-97. https://doi.org/10.15382/sturii2026130.83-97

Vancouver

Nekhorosheva T. The problem of ritual piety in the works of Kazan theological academy professor P. V. Znamensky. St. Tikhons' University Review. 2026;130:83-97. doi:10.15382/sturii2026130.83-97

BibTeX
@article{Nekhorosheva2026,
  author = {Nekhorosheva, Tatiana},
  title = {The problem of ritual piety in the works of Kazan theological academy professor P. V. Znamensky},
  journal = {St. Tikhons' University Review},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {130},
  pages = {83--97},
  doi = {10.15382/sturii2026130.83-97}
}
Kostenlos starten →