Sink, source, or equilibrium? Observation length and measurement method shape reported carbon balance in old-growth forests
South-east European forestry · 08.08.2026 · 17 (2) · 1-13
DOI: 10.15177/seefor.26-020 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift South-east European forestry, online erschienen am 08.08.2026. Verfasst von Éva Király und 3 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The carbon balance of old-growth forests remains contested, with studies alternately reporting strong carbon sinks, near-equilibrium states, or net carbon sources. Here, we synthesise peer-reviewed evidence to examine whether reported carbon balance classifications are influenced by observation length and measurement method. We conducted a systematic literature review of 60 publications (51 empirical studies and 9 reviews) addressing net carbon balance in old-growth forests. Each empirical study was classified as reporting a net carbon sink, dynamic equilibrium, or net carbon source. Using generalized linear models applied to study-level classifications, we tested the effects of observation length and measurement method on reported carbon balance outcomes. Longer observation periods were associated with higher odds of classifying old-growth forests as operating near dynamic carbon equilibrium; however, this effect did not reach statistical significance. In contrast, measurement method exerted a statistically significant influence: studies based on eddy covariance measurements had nearly twice the odds of classifying forests toward higher carbon uptake categories compared to field-based inventory approaches. Collectively, these results demonstrate that reported carbon balance states of old-growth forests reflect not only ecological processes, but also observational framing, methodological sensitivity, and temporal scale. Our findings caution against simplified narratives portraying old-growth forests as universal carbon sinks or sources, and highlight the need for long-term, methodologically transparent assessments when evaluating forest-based climate mitigation strategies.
Zitieren
APA
Király, É., Illés, G., Raszipovits-Esztó, K., & Borovics, A. (2026). Sink, source, or equilibrium? Observation length and measurement method shape reported carbon balance in old-growth forests. South-east European forestry, 17(2), 1-13. https://doi.org/10.15177/seefor.26-020
Vancouver
Király É, Illés G, Raszipovits-Esztó K, Borovics A. Sink, source, or equilibrium? Observation length and measurement method shape reported carbon balance in old-growth forests. South-east European forestry. 2026;17(2):1-13. doi:10.15177/seefor.26-020
BibTeX
@article{Kirly2026,
author = {Király, Éva and Illés, Gábor and Raszipovits-Esztó, Kinga and Borovics, Attila},
title = {Sink, source, or equilibrium? Observation length and measurement method shape reported carbon balance in old-growth forests},
journal = {South-east European forestry},
year = {2026},
volume = {17},
number = {2},
pages = {1--13},
doi = {10.15177/seefor.26-020}
}
EUVIMED