Comparing the characteristics of good clinical teachers in anesthesiology and surgery from the perspective of medical students at a Canadian university: A qualitative descriptive study.
McMaster University Medical Journal · 26.07.2026 · 22 (2) · 22
DOI: 10.15173/mumj.v22i2.4147 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift McMaster University Medical Journal, online erschienen am 26.07.2026. Verfasst von Ashlyn Chou und 2 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Optimization of clinical teaching requires recognition of specialty-specific differences. Although prior studies have independently assessed effective teaching in anesthesia and surgery, none have compared these findings within the same learner cohort, and few focus on medical students. Our study addresses these gaps by describing what constitutes good clinical teachers in anesthesia and surgery from the perspectives of medical students at the same institution, thereby minimizing heterogeneity in learner factors while informing specialty-specific teaching strategies.
Objective
We analyzed McMaster medical students’ written comments about anesthesia and surgery teachers to identify characteristics valued in each specialty and similarities and differences between them.
Methods
We obtained anonymized teacher evaluations from students who completed anesthesia and surgery clerkship rotations in 2023–2024. Using inductive content analysis, we generated codes (keywords/phrases capturing 1-2 thoughts) describing positive teaching qualities, and iteratively grouped these into categories and themes. We maintained methodological rigor through credibility, transferability, dependability, confirmability, reflexivity, and adherence to COREQ guidelines.
Results
Five themes emerged: 1) “Teacher’s individual characteristics” (e.g., kindness, empathy for patients); 2) “Characteristics that prioritize learner-centeredness” (e.g., tailoring teaching to learners’ level); 3) “Characteristics that optimize the learning environment” (e.g., framing mistakes as learning opportunities); 4) “Characteristics that advance theoretical knowledge” (e.g., simple explanations, evidence-based teaching); 5) “Characteristics that advance practical skills” (e.g., hands-on opportunities, real-time feedback).
Conclusions
Across both specialties, students valued teachers who tailored explanations and tasks to their experience levels, enabling deeper understanding and clinical engagement. A judgment-free environment was important for participation and learning from mistakes. Hands-on opportunities promoted self-esteem and sense of belonging. Specialty-specific differences also emerged: surgical teachers were valued for empathetic patient communication, and anesthesia teachers for prioritizing patient safety. As an admitting service, efficient system management was emphasized in surgery, as it preserved teaching time while allowing students to work in well-coordinated teams.
Zitieren
APA
Chou, A., Cordovani, D., & Cordovani, L. (2026). Comparing the characteristics of good clinical teachers in anesthesiology and surgery from the perspective of medical students at a Canadian university: A qualitative descriptive study. McMaster University Medical Journal, 22(2), 22. https://doi.org/10.15173/mumj.v22i2.4147
Vancouver
Chou A, Cordovani D, Cordovani L. Comparing the characteristics of good clinical teachers in anesthesiology and surgery from the perspective of medical students at a Canadian university: A qualitative descriptive study. McMaster University Medical Journal. 2026;22(2):22. doi:10.15173/mumj.v22i2.4147
BibTeX
@article{Chou2026,
author = {Chou, Ashlyn and Cordovani, Daniel and Cordovani, Ligia},
title = {Comparing the characteristics of good clinical teachers in anesthesiology and surgery from the perspective of medical students at a Canadian university: A qualitative descriptive study},
journal = {McMaster University Medical Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {22},
number = {2},
pages = {22},
doi = {10.15173/mumj.v22i2.4147}
}
EUVIMED