An Argument for Completely General Facts
Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy · 25.08.2021 · 9 (7)
DOI: 10.15173/jhap.v9i7.4439 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy, online erschienen am 25.08.2021. Verfasst von Landon D. C. Elkind. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 3-mal zitiert (Crossref).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In his 1918 logical atomism lectures, Russell argued that there are no molecular facts. But he posed a problem for anyone wanting to avoid molecular facts: we need truth-makers for generalizations of molecular formulas, but such truth-makers seem to be both unavoidable and to have an abominably molecular character. Call this the problem of generalized molecular formulas. I clarify the problem here by distinguishing two kinds of generalized molecular formula: incompletely generalized molecular formulas and completely generalized molecular formulas. I next argue that, if empty worlds are logically possible, then the model-theoretic and truth-functional considerations that are usually given address the problem posed by the first kind of formula, but not the problem posed by the second kind. I then show that Russell’s commitments in 1918 provide an answer to the problem of completely generalized molecular formulas: some truth-makers will be non-atomic facts that have no constituents. This shows that the neo-logical atomist goal of defending the principle of atomicity—the principle that only atomic facts are truth-makers—is not realizable.
Zitieren
APA
Elkind, L. D. C. (2021). An Argument for Completely General Facts. Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy, 9(7). https://doi.org/10.15173/jhap.v9i7.4439
Vancouver
Elkind LDC. An Argument for Completely General Facts. Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy. 2021;9(7). doi:10.15173/jhap.v9i7.4439
BibTeX
@article{Elkind2021,
author = {Elkind, Landon D. C.},
title = {An Argument for Completely General Facts},
journal = {Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy},
year = {2021},
volume = {9},
number = {7},
doi = {10.15173/jhap.v9i7.4439}
}
EUVIMED