Equal Warrant, Equal Truth? Quine's Deliberative Dilemmas
Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy · 13.08.2026 · 16 (2)
DOI: 10.15173/jhap.v16i2.5716 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy, online erschienen am 13.08.2026. Verfasst von James Andrew Smith.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Suppose we were to encounter an overall scientific theory as equally warranted as the overall theory we believe is true. W. V. Quine thinks that there is a dilemma about whether to believe this additional theory. Whether there is a dilemma in any case, I argue, depends upon how we understand equivalence of warrant in the first-personal context of deliberating about what to believe. On one understanding, equal warrant of two theories implies that I have enough reason to believe one theory if and only if I have enough reason to believe the other. But here, there is no dilemma: I ought to believe both theories given I should believe one. There is more plausibly a dilemma if equal warrant implies that, if I have enough reason to believe one theory, I lack enough reason to reject the other, and vice versa. But I argue that Quine’s views have some awkward consequences if equal warrant is understood in this latter sense. My paper draws on the transcript of a colloquium at Stanford University in 1986 with Quine, Donald Davidson, Burton Dreben, and Dagfinn Føllesdal.
Zitieren
APA
Smith, J. A. (2026). Equal Warrant, Equal Truth? Quine's Deliberative Dilemmas. Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy, 16(2). https://doi.org/10.15173/jhap.v16i2.5716
Vancouver
Smith JA. Equal Warrant, Equal Truth? Quine's Deliberative Dilemmas. Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy. 2026;16(2). doi:10.15173/jhap.v16i2.5716
BibTeX
@article{Smith2026,
author = {Smith, James Andrew},
title = {Equal Warrant, Equal Truth? Quine's Deliberative Dilemmas},
journal = {Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy},
year = {2026},
volume = {16},
number = {2},
doi = {10.15173/jhap.v16i2.5716}
}
EUVIMED