EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Minor Troubles: Racial Figurations of Youth Sexuality and Childhood's Queerness

Dylan Rollo

Rhetoric and Public Affairs · 01.12.2025 · 28 (3-4) · 195-201

DOI: 10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0195 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Rhetoric and Public Affairs, online erschienen am 01.12.2025. Verfasst von Dylan Rollo.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

As a teen boy in the mid-00s, whiling away rural Missouri summers at my now-estranged father's house meant hours locked away with a computer on an LGBT youth-oriented community site called Mogenic. There, a stack of canted emo selfies, claustrophobic webcam shots, and stilted Lifetouch portraits from the profiles of young people 13 to 25 stood opposite escalating news stories: 50 Cent saying “rap isn't for gays,”1 a “gay fetus bill” trying to divide the pro-choice crowd,2 Iran's public execution of gay teens Mahmoud Asgari and Ayaz Marhoni,3 and so on. Groping my way through this discomfiting mélange of queer hopes, fears, outrages, and omens just to flirt with boys (and yes, men) clumped together a makeshift gay identity for me, for better and worse.Romantic tragedies of suicidal or slain white boys invited fearful identification while spectacles of homophobia attempted to disentangle sexuality from race in my head. I found precious and troubling accounts of queerness only in my most furtive, lonesome, and guilt-choked moments. With no recognizable sense of sexual agency, innocent anxieties kept my online friendships with peers from advancing any further than flirtatious innuendo. On the other hand, beholding myself the flattered subject of readily available sexual attention from adult Mogenic members validated shameful desires and gorged a need I was not permitted to understand. Cautionary tales made me keep due distance, but I sampled their prologues many times anyway, as I was denied the agency to inhabit my sexuality in any healthier way. Deviant in my shelter, I was “protected” from queerness for the sake of some hypothetical child I would never be.This brief account might suggest why I found Erin J. Rand's Minor Troubles such a gratifying read, but I hope it also adequately stages why it is such an important corrective to both queer studies’ deracialization and the sometimes fumbling, additive attempts at reckoning with queerness's presumptive whiteness. Rand carefully traces the racial figuration of “hetero(non)sexual” childhood across several prominent controversies in recent history to uncover the covert operations of racialized logics in youth gender and sexuality discourse. She makes use of the terminology of “hetero(non)sexuality” to reveal our most self-evident cultural presumption of childhood: always heterosexual yet non-sexual, already hetero-oriented yet innocent of the curiosities, desires, and drives of sexuality—as our strollers full of “lady killers” and “heartbreakers” demonstrate. As the rhetorical figure of the child is used to justify the institutionalization of stifling social control across a variety of contexts, Rand is clear from the beginning that the potency of this instrumentalization lies in its unspoken whiteness (5). This explicit racialization matters because its use in public deliberation “brings cultural ideas about the qualities of childhood into contact with the lives of real children, producing material consequences that are disproportionately harmful to youth of color and queer, trans, and gender-nonconforming youth” (5). This is not an application of a racial lens onto queer studies, but a ground-up theorization of childhood as an immanently raced concept. None of the issues covered in Minor Troubles would make sense without explicit attention to inherent and elemental operations of race; and, as a result we are quite convincingly taught that no debate around childhood sexuality could make sense without it.The organization of Minor Troubles follows the racialized figuration of childhood through criminalized Black girls and vulnerable white boys, demonstrates this figuration's function in public discourse, then turns to how it has been reconfigured for the sake of actual children by KIMBRITIVE, a sex education and wellness program geared toward Black women and girls. The foundational exclusions shaping the figuration of childhood are established in the first two chapters by the production of vulnerability as its essential characteristic.In the first chapter, Rand draws out how dehumanizing and criminalizing Blackness feeds on well-established fears of Black sexual aggression, identifying these racial politics in the case of teen sexting scandal victims Antjuanece Brown and Jolene Jenkins to depict how Black girls are hypersexualized and denied sexual agency. Further, like Black male youths in American culture, they are more often treated as adults when it comes to criminal culpability. Antjuanece was 19 and Jolene 17 when they met and began a relationship, the former just three months and two weeks beyond the legal limit for a relationship straddling the age of consent. As enabled by “clumsy and discriminatory application of child pornography laws to youth sexting, as well as the discrepancies in punishment of racialized and queer youth” (38), Antjuanece was charged with three felonies: sex abuse, creating child pornography, and luring a minor, despite Jolene defending her. Media coverage further cemented the fraught association of sexting with child pornography, sparking panic among parents around the new technologies of camera phones (39). Through analysis of the surrounding moral panic and other moments of contemporaneous parental anxiety—such as with the threatening sexual implications of Bratz dolls’ race and class presentation—Rand describes how normative fears around raced sexuality exclude Blackness, female sexual agency, and queerness from the category of childhood.With the exclusion of Blackness, female sexual agency, and queerness from the category of childhood comes the specific inclusion of the “wounded white boy,” the embodiment of the “privileges of white weakness and the performativity of contingent masculinity” and the figure by which queer youth are widely understood as inherently and categorically vulnerable, susceptible to bullying and suicide (31). Yet another means by which youth sexual agency is curtailed for the sake of empowering adults, the figure of the wounded white boy sparks a paternalism marked by neoliberal inclusion. A string of suicides of white, cisgender boys in September of 2010 inspired movements like the “It Gets Better” campaign, its media-cultivated coherence of sameness animating a threat of “bullycide” that prompted landmark anti-bullying legislation nation-wide, though Rand shows how the federal guidance characterized queer youth according to the effects of their bullying, making depression, anxiety, low self-esteem, etc. inherent to being a queer youth rather than a result of a heteronormative environment (87). “Constructed as a social group through the dissemination and institutionalization of the news about bullying and suicide,” queer youth became newly intelligible in mainstream discourses as predisposed to vulnerability (76). Protection of the wounded white boy is also an act of privileging, aligning his inclusion with co-optation of the material precarities of more vulnerable subjectivities (77) and the inherent contingency of manhood as a “social status that is hard won, easily lost, and requires continued public performance” (81). As a result, under the guise of guardianship, the responsibility for gay teen suicides is shifted away from systemic issues and onto the fragility of the white cisgender gay boy, and supportive adults cast themselves as saviors and protectors of a generation of gay youth.Misplaced saviorism continues apace in the third chapter, where meetings of a Virginia county school board hosted passionate, self-righteous, and often confused parents attempting to defend their children from the imagined dangers of sharing a public-school bathroom with transgender peer Gavin Grimm. From Rand's examination of the board meeting transcripts, we see how concerned parents treat transgender identity as a deviance from a normative timeline of childhood development; his age is inflated from that of the “chrononormative” cisgender child, as he threatened “advanced and improper knowledge, which young children ‘shouldn't have to understand’” (125). Accused of deviating in much the same way Black girls do, his case reveals the intersectional function of chrononormativity as a disciplinary standard (125). From those attempting to protect Gavin's right to use facilities suiting his gender identity, on the other hand, Rand notes rhetorical moves that conjure the “ghostly Blackness” through civil rights discourse (109)—calling Gavin “the Rosa Parks of the trans bathroom debate,” for instance (114)—a gambit that would later prove successful. As Rand writes, “his legibility as a trans subject is indebted to the extraction of value from racialized bodies” (116); thus, whether by demonizing transgender children as aberrations from an imaginary chrononormativity or by instrumentalizing the straightforward rights of necessarily absent Blackness, trans bathroom discourse invokes and supplants Blackness to defend what is really at stake: “the binary gender system, developmental temporality, and unmarked whiteness in the figuration of childhood so central to the politics of sexual morality and youth” (110). Meanwhile, Rand contrasts the clean intelligibility of Gavin's case with the apparently threatening inscrutability of 15-year-old Larry/Latisha King, whose overtly queer sexuality, biracial Blackness, and gender-nonconformance would be used to justify their murder by a straight, white, cisgender classmate who would not be charged with a hate crime, having shot an unaware Larry/Latisha in the back of the head because he was left with “no way out.”Finally, Rand's fourth chapter seeks hope in KIMBRITIVE, a sexual wellness program empowering Black girls and women with sexual agency and the knowledge necessary for more comprehensive bodily autonomy in the contexts of American sex education programs founded in eugenicist white supremacy and cisheteropatriarchy. As she writes, “It is not merely that [Black girls] are excluded or overlooked, but that—because the disavowal of Blackness founds the category of vulnerability—the whole civilizing and nationalizing pedagogical project of hetero(non)sexual sex education depends upon the vilification of Black female sexuality” (156). Rand sets up the potential of KIMBRITIVE to offer radical, intergenerational alternatives to the contemporary racial figurations of childhood that animate the previous chapters through comprehensive study of abstinence-based sex education programs and how they secured their prominence starting in the early twentieth century. Reticence and restraint characterize normative, white supremacist sex education programs, as “indirection, euphemism, and metaphor” serve to obscure sexual desire and anything exceeding heteronormative reproduction (165), using a zoological framing of “the birds and the bees” to quash sexual curiosity with facile and misleading substitutions (170). Encoded by these mystifications are racist imaginings of white sexuality as controlled by the civilized mental fortitude of chastity (166), Black sexuality as comparatively undisciplined and naturally prone to venereal infection (166), and female sexual desire, pleasure, and agency as utterly nonexistent (169). A range of Black feminist, queer, and intersectional scholarship helps Rand articulate the “black feminist love-politics” of self-care as deploying an “affirming and abundant rhetorical style of speech about sex” to “talk back” to these traditions, refiguring childhood away from whiteness and hetero(non)sexuality (157).Rand concludes her book with gestures toward what youthful sexual agency might look like, finding inspiration and controversy in the 2020 French drama Cuties about tween girls attempting to negotiate their developing sexuality through dance. As one might expect, the film received great backlash for allegedly sexualizing underage girls. But, as Rand writes, “the film makes adults uncomfortable not because it sexualizes children . . . but because it reveals the sexuality of children—not just as it is imposed by external cultural forces but also how it emerges within and is negotiated by young people themselves” (196). In other words, it is the imposed sexuality and, most of all, the sexual agency of children themselves that disturbs them, a violation of “the pure, sexually naïve figuration of the white child against which adulthood and adult sexual normalcy is defined” (196). Such recognitions of burgeoning sexual agency imperil white supremacist and chrononormative cis-heterosexuality, and so Rand helps us to see childhood's queerness as a rhetorical resource for countering the persistent racial figuration working by design to sacrifice the safety of real, marginalized young people everywhere.Delicate subject matter is handled with characteristic care in Minor Troubles, and the cohesiveness of Rand's work is particularly valuable as a nuanced, sometimes understated piece of intersectional rhetorical scholarship. Indeed, at the very least the book is a remarkably successful argument for the inherent intersectionality of any study of sexuality, the fraught and politically volatile landscape of childhood queerness proving particularly productive of crucial insights in the right hands. At points readers can find the more incisive claims inconspicuously nestled among contextualization, a considered strategy that rewards close reading. On impressively rare occasions, given the anxieties around childhood's proximity to sexuality that Rand examines, readers may find themselves conjuring slippery slopes or parades of horribles never even implied in the book. Analysis of the teen sexting scandal of Antjuanece Brown and Jolene Jenkins raises questions of when gaps in age might also imply an unacceptable power imbalance, for instance, or whether the legal age of consent suitably matches our collectively imagined age when a person is first (suddenly?) capable of consenting to sexual contact at all. That the book does not wantonly or even measuredly toss out some hypothetical numbers to answer these questions is part of the point. And no doubt, for reasons Rand details at length, the imagined age would shift awkwardly based on the genders involved: girls being virgins unless made whores, boys being boys (not even men), and queer sexual contact being inherently less innocent, more advanced. Beyond exemplifying the tenacity of the racial figuration of childhood and performatively confirming Rand's argument, defensive compulsions to project straw people are calls for self-reflexive reading practices many may find instructive. There is far more work to be done to debate the critical vulnerability she advocates in her conclusion and how it can best foster childhood sexual agency toward safer and more ethically queer futures. But, to approximate borrowed language, those must be our arguments to make (28).Minor Troubles is an invaluable resource for studying the fundamental intersectionality of sexuality, the troubling queerness of childhood, and the costly sacrifices made when protecting rhetorical figurations in place of real, endangered young people. Scrupulously written and expertly argued, Rand's latest book is endlessly generative of sorely needed provocations and profoundly consequential insights.

Zitieren

APA

Rollo, D. (2025). Minor Troubles: Racial Figurations of Youth Sexuality and Childhood's Queerness. Rhetoric and Public Affairs, 28(3-4), 195-201. https://doi.org/10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0195

Vancouver

Rollo D. Minor Troubles: Racial Figurations of Youth Sexuality and Childhood's Queerness. Rhetoric and Public Affairs. 2025;28(3-4):195-201. doi:10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0195

BibTeX
@article{Rollo2025,
  author = {Rollo, Dylan},
  title = {Minor Troubles: Racial Figurations of Youth Sexuality and Childhood's Queerness},
  journal = {Rhetoric and Public Affairs},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {28},
  number = {3-4},
  pages = {195--201},
  doi = {10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0195}
}
Kostenlos starten →