EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The Pink Scar: How Nazi Persecution Shaped the Struggle for LGBTQ+ Rights

Linda Diane Horwitz

Rhetoric and Public Affairs · 01.12.2025 · 28 (3-4) · 189-194

DOI: 10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0189 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Rhetoric and Public Affairs, online erschienen am 01.12.2025. Verfasst von Linda Diane Horwitz.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

In a 2025 blog post, the National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA) condemned the Department of the Interior for removing references to slavery, Native displacement, Japanese American incarceration, and LGBTQ+ history from national park materials. The NPCA called this erasure of “undeniable historical and scientific truths” a violation of federal law, which mandates that national parks “tell the full story of America—from our darkest chapters to our greatest triumphs.”1 This act of historical elimination underscores the current relevance of Thomas R. Dunn's The Pink Scar: How Nazi Persecution Shaped the Struggle for LGBTQ+ Rights. Who, what, and how we remember matters. Dunn argues that LGBTQ+ people found it important to remember Nazi persecution “not as a distant memory to be recalled and discounted, but as a lesson we should live with every day . . . [because a]t their core, the essential message shared by all memories of the Nazi persecution of homosexuals is that, despite these countless horrors, the homosexuals were not snuffed out. They survived” (177). Remembering is an act of survival.Dunn's book makes a significant contribution to Holocaust studies, LGBTQ+ studies, rhetorical studies, and memory studies. He challenges the dominant narrative that US LGBTQ+ activists only began invoking the Holocaust in the 1970s with their use of the pink triangle, the Nazi symbol used to identify homosexual prisoners. Instead, he shows that LGBTQ+ communities in the United States were aware of the Nazi persecution at the time and have drawn upon Holocaust memory since the 1930s in a variety of rhetorical forms. Dunn's work recovers overlooked moments in LGBTQ+ political history and emphasizes the malleability of memory as a potent rhetorical resource. He also enacts and argues for the importance of rhetorical analysis, especially in contexts where persuasive impact takes precedence over historical precision.Dunn begins by outlining his methodological and theoretical framework. He focuses on US LGBTQ+ rhetoric from 1934 to 1981—a period that, he argues, marks the earliest known invocations of Nazi persecution of homosexuals in the US press and culminates in a rhetorical culture that shaped LGBTQ+ responses to the AIDS crisis. Dunn critiques the overemphasis on concentration camps and the pink triangle and broadens the analysis to include victims of Paragraph 175 (a Nazi-era revision of Germany's anti-sodomy law), lesbians, and others persecuted outside the camp system.Each chapter centers on a politically relevant case study. Rather than forcing a uniform template or decade-by-decade approach, Dunn adapts his method to the available archival material and its relationship to broader shifts in LGBTQ+ political history. His agility as both researcher and theorist allows him to construct a complex, layered interpretation of memory work—one that embraces, rather than resolves, historical contradiction and rhetorical inconsistency. For example, Dunn observes that Harvey Milk's invocation of Nazi gas chambers “has numerous factual errors but sets up a powerful, if inaccurate, memory of these events” (146–147).Chapter 1 (1934–1935) analyzes Henry Gerber's September 1934 article “Hitlerism and Homosexuality,” published in Chanticleer, a small US periodical with a significant homosexual readership. Gerber was a founding member of Chicago's Society for Human Rights, which Dunn argues was the first documented US homosexual rights organization, created in 1924 (34). Gerber founded Chanticleer in January 1934, which, according to one of his biographers, “was more of a vanity project, an outlet for ‘self-promulgators’ like Gerber who had strong opinions to share but few illusions about tapping the vein of American public discourse” (43). Gerber promoted the publication using a subscriber list from his pen-pal club, Contacts, which served as a covert network for homosexual correspondence, intimacy, and information-sharing (38). The article, written shortly after the Night of the Long Knives, reimagines the death of Captain Ernst Roehm and other homosexual SA officers as valiant in the fight against fascism by presenting them as virile, honorable warriors. Though historically inaccurate, Dunn argues that this framing served a critical rhetorical purpose: countering growing associations between homosexuality and fascism. Gerber worked to associate homosexuality with Communism instead. This chapter provides compelling evidence that Nazi persecution of LGBTQ+ people was both known and strategically invoked by at least one American voice as early as 1934.Chapter 2 (1949–1965) shifts focus to LGBTQ+-oriented publications, One and Mattachine Review, illustrating how Holocaust memory was strategically employed to galvanize political action amid US legal persecution in the 1950s. These periodicals drew explicit parallels between Nazi tactics and postwar US police surveillance. Dunn reminds readers that the Gestapo “searched German citizens’ mail for evidence of homosexuality” (75). In the early 1950s, “when One and Mattachine Review launched their precarious publishing adventures . . . each publication turned to memories of the Nazi era to help their homosexual audiences . . . demand that ‘something must be done’” (78). Letters to the editors often included first-hand accounts of harassment by the “American Gestapo.” Though these texts did not yet reference the pink triangle or concentration camps, they laid the groundwork for associative memory between Jewish and LGBTQ+ suffering under Nazi rule by remembering the tactics of those in power.Chapter 3 (1966–1969) turns to the genre of “gay Nazi-exploitation” pulp novels, often dismissed for their sensationalism. The term pulp functions metonymically, referring both to the cheap paper on which these novels were printed and to their association with thrilling, escapist stories defined by clear villains and heroes. Dunn argues that these texts played a formative role in shaping a distinctly gay male cultural consciousness. While undeniably marked by fetishization and eroticism, they also conveyed skepticism toward state authority and biomedical science—traits that helped cultivate the oppositional ethos of the Stonewall era. Importantly, Dunn addresses the moral ambiguity within these narratives, including the uncomfortable truth that some homosexuals were Nazi collaborators. These novels, he writes, “showed a willingness to remember Nazi crimes against homosexuals with a complexity that previous texts did not” (104). Only a genre like pulp, he contends, “which can conceal hard truths beneath highly sexual and sometimes campy plotlines” could portray homosexuals as fully human—capable of embracing any ideology, whether noble or reprehensible (107–108). In doing so, these novels allowed contemporary LGBTQ+ readers to recognize that queer or trans identity does not confer inherent moral virtue.Chapter 4 (1970–1977) centers on Reverend Mikhail Itkin, a contentious figure within the LGBTQ+ community. Dunn reports that “he was disliked by many of his contemporaries,” perhaps because Itkin had a “reputation as a radical and a troublemaker” (142). In the post-Stonewall period—defined by the rise of gay pride, coming out, and the pursuit of political power—Itkin emerged as a prominent voice linking Holocaust remembrance with gay liberation. Through close readings of his poetry and prose, Dunn demonstrates how Itkin framed LGBTQ+ Holocaust victims as both martyrs and kin to contemporary LGBTQ+ Americans. This dual metaphor established a moral imperative for LGBTQ+ people to learn their history, engage in commemoration, and participate in political activism. Itkin emphasized coalition politics and intersectionality, framing remembrance as a call to action not only for oppressed LGBTQ+ individuals but for a broader commitment to social justice. This politicized understanding of LGBTQ+ identity proved enduring; when I was enculturated into the community in the late 1980s, it was made clear to me that all LGBTQ+ people were my siblings—whether I liked them personally or not—and that we were united in solidarity with the oppressed.Chapter 5 (1977–1979) continues into the 1970s but offers a contrary use of Holocaust memory. Dunn shows how Supervisor Harvey Milk shifted from viewing LGBTQ+ victims as heroic martyrs to portraying them as passive “lambs to the slaughter”—a metaphor designed to elicit urgent political resistance to the Briggs Initiative and Anita Bryant's anti-gay campaigns. While Milk's earlier rhetoric aligned with Itkin's, Dunn notes a decisive rhetorical turn in 1977, where Holocaust-era Jews and homosexuals were condemned for their behavior instead of revered. “Milk constituted an enthymematic-rich appeal,” Dunn writes, “one that relied significantly on his lesbian and gay audiences to fill in the details . . . and conflate the Jewish and homosexual experiences of the Nazi regime” (155–156). Dunn identifies three strategies of “subtraction”—temporal, geographic, and allusion—that allowed Milk to compare LGBTQ+ oppression to a (mythologized) Jewish and homosexual passivity during the Holocaust. Dunn does not critique the inconsistency or historical inaccuracy; rather, he emphasizes the rhetorical context and strategic utility of such shifts. These shifts present memory not as fixed but as rhetorically malleable. Martyrdom has long been seen as a rhetorically constructed identity; this chapter makes it clear that victimhood is, too.In his conclusion, Dunn returns to the early 1980s and the iconic ACT UP “Silence = Death” campaign, which repurposed the pink triangle to signify both historical victimization and urgent resistance during the AIDS crisis. Dunn uses this example to reinforce his central theoretical claim: rhetorical memory derives its power not from consistency, but from adaptability. Reflecting on the origins of the Silence = Death campaign, he writes, “is a useful reminder of how central human needs are to the force of rhetorical memory—and just how malleable the past is when we need it to be” (13). Here Dunn clarifies his key theoretical concept of malleability, arguing that rhetorical scholars should value memory for its flexibility rather than its fidelity. Historical events like the Holocaust, he suggests, are marked by gaps and ambiguities that make them particularly fertile ground for rhetorical appropriation across time.Dunn's approach models how rhetoric can productively engage memory studies. He contrasts his work with that of historian Erik N. Jensen, who claims that Nazi persecution of LGBTQ+ people was not known in the US until the 1970s. Dunn frames this as a “disciplinary distinction” (164). Rhetorical scholarship allows for different types of sources, questions, and interpretive flexibility. Historians may not be comfortable with a single source or a source that makes inconsistent claims; rhetoricians are interested in how and why those texts were expected to be persuasive within their specific context. Dunn's inclusive archival scope, expansive understanding of the Holocaust, attention to language, focus on context, and organic critical approach foreground the power of rhetoric to shape public memory.Crucially, Dunn enacts that distinction in his own work. His book exemplifies rhetorical criticism as public engagement, taking a normative stance rather than maintaining academic neutrality. Dunn concludes with a provocative call for contemporary LGBTQ+ activists to return to a rhetoric of survival over pride and to adopt a more ideologically driven remembrance politics—akin to some European LGBTQ+ movements that foreground political prisoners and communists over Jewish victims. Unfortunately, Dunn offers no concrete examples to support this proposal, basing his argument instead on current events: “the atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7, 2023, and the inhumane prosecution of the war in Gaza by Benjamin Netanyahu's Israeli government in response have now scrambled the once nearly sacrosanct sense of morality implicated by remembering the Holocaust” (13).As a Jewish lesbian, I found this argument both provocative and difficult to read. While I recognize that the post-October 7 conflict in Gaza has reshaped the moral terrain surrounding Holocaust remembrance, seeing this shift named so explicitly in print was jarring. What is the lesson of the Holocaust when the descendants of the survivors are seen as villains? Dunn's suggestion that we move from identity politics to ideological politics is persuasive given his reminder that as an LGBTQ+ person I should see all oppressed people as my siblings. As a rhetorician, I admire Dunn's willingness to embody his theoretical commitments, showing how rhetorical memory can evolve in response to shifting political exigencies. The good news, assuming Dunn is right, is that memories are malleable—and while things are shifting, humans direct the shift with discourse.Ultimately, The Pink Scar is a rigorous, politically engaged, and methodologically innovative work that challenges simplified narratives of LGBTQ+ history and Holocaust memory. Dunn makes a compelling case for rethinking how Holocaust memory has shaped—and can continue to shape—LGBTQ+ activism in the United States. His refusal to sanitize the past, as seen in his analysis of Gerber's reimagining of Ernst Roehm as an anti-fascist hero, allows him to recover a long-standing tradition of LGBTQ+ rhetorical resistance—one far more complex and dynamic than previously acknowledged. This is a vital contribution to both rhetorical scholarship and LGBTQ+ memory work—one that insists memory is not a static record of the past but a living, rhetorical resource for justice.

Zitieren

APA

Horwitz, L. D. (2025). The Pink Scar: How Nazi Persecution Shaped the Struggle for LGBTQ+ Rights. Rhetoric and Public Affairs, 28(3-4), 189-194. https://doi.org/10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0189

Vancouver

Horwitz LD. The Pink Scar: How Nazi Persecution Shaped the Struggle for LGBTQ+ Rights. Rhetoric and Public Affairs. 2025;28(3-4):189-194. doi:10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0189

BibTeX
@article{Horwitz2025,
  author = {Horwitz, Linda Diane},
  title = {The Pink Scar: How Nazi Persecution Shaped the Struggle for LGBTQ+ Rights},
  journal = {Rhetoric and Public Affairs},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {28},
  number = {3-4},
  pages = {189--194},
  doi = {10.14321/rhetpublaffa.28.3-4.0189}
}
Kostenlos starten →