Defining Schism in the External Forum (c. 751)
The Jurist: Studies in Church Law and Ministry · 2026 · 82 (1) · 91-123
DOI: 10.1353/jur.2026.a994944 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Jurist: Studies in Church Law and Ministry, 2026. Verfasst von David P. Long.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Drawing on canon 751, this article proposes a practical external forum framework for identifying the delict of schism. It argues that schism is constituted by an externally manifested refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff or of communion with those subject to him, and that criticism or even grave disobedience does not suffice unless it stabilizes into such a refusal. The study operationalizes the elements using a decision grid (external manifestation, object, imputability). It situates the analysis within the theology of communion and the general norms on penal responsibility, competence, and procedure, including the post-2021 Book VI context and the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith's reserved competence for delicts against the faith. Two classic illustrations (the Old Catholic rupture after Vatican I and the Lefebvre/SSPX crisis) demonstrate the framework's portability. Four recent practice examples—the DDF's administrative penal process in the Viganò case, governance measures culminating in suppression of the Arlington Carmel, the Belorado decrees declaring incurrence of excommunication, and the administrative removal of Bishop Joseph Strickland as a boundary case—show how differing procedural postures can yield proportionate remedies. The comparison clarifies the line between schism and lesser violations, highlights the medicinal and communicative purposes of censures, and notes the ecumenical importance of distinguishing objective separation from personal culpability. The article concludes with brief reflections on the code's classification of schism as a delict against faith and unity, without proposing legislative reform.
Zitieren
APA
Long, D. P. (2026). Defining Schism in the External Forum (c. 751). The Jurist: Studies in Church Law and Ministry, 82(1), 91-123. https://doi.org/10.1353/jur.2026.a994944
Vancouver
Long DP. Defining Schism in the External Forum (c. 751). The Jurist: Studies in Church Law and Ministry. 2026;82(1):91-123. doi:10.1353/jur.2026.a994944
BibTeX
@article{Long2026,
author = {Long, David P.},
title = {Defining Schism in the External Forum (c. 751)},
journal = {The Jurist: Studies in Church Law and Ministry},
year = {2026},
volume = {82},
number = {1},
pages = {91--123},
doi = {10.1353/jur.2026.a994944}
}
EUVIMED