The Strict Account of Intention and Vital Conflict Cases
The Journal of Natural Law · 2025 · 1 (1) · 7-28
DOI: 10.1353/jnl.2025.a984910 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Journal of Natural Law, 2025. Verfasst von Christopher Tollefsen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The question of what is encompassed within an agent's intention, and what is accepted as a side effect only, is central to the resolution of "vital conflict" abortion cases, in which a mother's life is saved by actions which directly impinge upon the child's body. "Strict" accounts of intention return generally permissive answers to these kinds of cases. In this essay, I undertake three tasks. The first is a response to three recent essays by Steven Jensen critiquing the strict account. Second, I look at a description of an actual maternal life-saving intervention, described by a pro-life physician in 2022. I argue that while this procedure need not have involved intentional killing or harming of the fetus, Jensen's account must condemn it, as including a lethal intention. Finally, I turn to a recent statement of the American Association of Pro-Life Gynecologists on "Concluding Pregnancy Ethically." There is a tension in that statement over what may be done when a pregnancy is in distress in the absence of modern technology. I argue that considerations of fairness show that vital conflict cases are reasonably resolved in very different ways where modern medical technology is available and where it is not.
Zitieren
APA
Tollefsen, C. (2025). The Strict Account of Intention and Vital Conflict Cases. The Journal of Natural Law, 1(1), 7-28. https://doi.org/10.1353/jnl.2025.a984910
Vancouver
Tollefsen C. The Strict Account of Intention and Vital Conflict Cases. The Journal of Natural Law. 2025;1(1):7-28. doi:10.1353/jnl.2025.a984910
BibTeX
@article{Tollefsen2025,
author = {Tollefsen, Christopher},
title = {The Strict Account of Intention and Vital Conflict Cases},
journal = {The Journal of Natural Law},
year = {2025},
volume = {1},
number = {1},
pages = {7--28},
doi = {10.1353/jnl.2025.a984910}
}
EUVIMED