Controversy and Conscience: Abiezer Coppe's Return to Orthodoxy
Journal for Early Modern Cultural Studies · 2024-01 · 24 (1-2) · 79-100
DOI: 10.1353/jem.2024.a976204 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal for Early Modern Cultural Studies, 2024-01. Verfasst von Douglas Fitzhenry Jones.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The infamous seventeenth-century radical Abiezer Coppe is too interesting to not be the subject of numerous scholarly treatments. There are today many Coppes: the libertine and practical antinomian, the working-class hero, and, of course, the liar. This article uses Coppe's 1651 petition for release from Newgate prison as a wedge into a broader Puritan worldview involving sanctification by successive bouts of divine annihilation. Drawing on the recent work of cultural historians and historians of emotion, I show that each step toward sanctification entailed, somewhat paradoxically, the recognition of total depravity, a "laying low" of the sinner's previously established identity. I argue that Coppe's 1651 petition was neither entirely honest nor dishonest—the continuum accepted by most modern commentators—but rather a further step in a surprisingly conventional narrative of Protestant atonement. That Coppe was able to capitalize on such a narrative and secure his release is a testament not to his chameleon nature but to the complexities and contradictions of the broader Puritan fabric rippling beneath the clash of radicalism and authoritative belief. Abstract: The infamous seventeenth-century radical Abiezer Coppe is too interesting not to be the subject of numerous scholarly treatments. There are today many Coppes: the libertine and practical antinomian, the working-class hero, and, of course, the liar. This article uses Coppe's 1651 petition for release from Newgate prison as a wedge into a broader Puritan worldview involving sanctification by successive bouts of divine annihilation. Drawing on the recent work of cultural historians and historians of emotion, I show that each step toward sanctification entailed, somewhat paradoxically, the recognition of total depravity, a "laying low" of the sinner's previously established identity. In the process, I argue that Coppe's 1651 petition was neither entirely honest nor dishonest–the continuum accepted by most modern commentators–but rather a further step in a surprisingly conventional narrative of Protestant atonement. That Coppe was able to capitalize on such a narrative and secure his release is a testament not to his chameleon nature but to the complexities and contradictions of the broader Puritan fabric rippling beneath the clash of radicalism and authoritative belief.
Zitieren
APA
Jones, D. F. (2024). Controversy and Conscience: Abiezer Coppe's Return to Orthodoxy. Journal for Early Modern Cultural Studies, 24(1-2), 79-100. https://doi.org/10.1353/jem.2024.a976204
Vancouver
Jones DF. Controversy and Conscience: Abiezer Coppe's Return to Orthodoxy. Journal for Early Modern Cultural Studies. 2024;24(1-2):79-100. doi:10.1353/jem.2024.a976204
BibTeX
@article{Jones2024,
author = {Jones, Douglas Fitzhenry},
title = {Controversy and Conscience: Abiezer Coppe's Return to Orthodoxy},
journal = {Journal for Early Modern Cultural Studies},
year = {2024},
volume = {24},
number = {1-2},
pages = {79--100},
doi = {10.1353/jem.2024.a976204}
}
EUVIMED