Disrupting Power Dynamics and Promoting Equitable Participation in Disaster Risk Reduction: Freirean Approach to Participatory Action Research in Jacksonville, Florida
Journal of Disaster Studies · 2026 · 3 (1) · 28-58
DOI: 10.1353/jds.2026.a997614 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Disaster Studies, 2026. Verfasst von Haleh Mehdipour und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The unequal effects of climate change and disasters on racialized, marginalized, and dispossessed communities necessitate linking disaster risk reduction (DRR) efforts to broader justice and liberation efforts. While participatory action research (PAR) has been widely promoted as a promising approach for empowering communities and building their capacity to manage risk, its implementation in disaster studies often lacks attention to its theoretical foundations in participatory democracy, social justice, and critical inquiry. This article seeks to contribute to the use of PAR in DRR, highlighting the value of a Freirean approach (inspired by renowned Brazilian educator and theorist Paulo Freire). We contend that democratic and equitable participation is fundamental to effective DRR research and argue for a community-led approach to reducing risk and preventing its re-creation. Drawing on the theoretical underpinnings of PAR, we highlight the significance of understanding the problem in its context, integrating value-based knowledge into the research process, and balancing initiatives through dialogic praxis. In this sense, to foster democratic and equitable participation in DRR research, it is crucial to challenge prevailing power dynamics, focus on the most pertinent key issues, and instill a sense of belonging in DRR research design, engagement, and intervention strategies. By weaving Freirean principles into PAR applications, DRR can transcend mere technical solutions, address deeper systemic challenges, and promote a more inclusive, democratic, and human-centric approach to disaster studies. This work attempts to serve as a guide for researchers aiming to use PAR in disaster studies, advocating for a more equitable and liberatory approach that resonates with the lived experiences and aspirations of affected communities. We illustrate these principles through a case study in Jacksonville, Florida, where Freirean-inspired PAR was used to co-develop disaster risk strategies with communities historically affected by spatial and environmental injustice. Through participatory workshops, shared storytelling, and youth-led action, the project fostered local agency, recentered community narratives in disaster planning, and catalyzed policy-oriented outcomes rooted in collective visioning and liberation. Resumen: Los impactos desiguales del cambio climático y los desastres sobre las comunidades racializadas, marginadas y desposeídas hacen necesario vincular los esfuerzos de Reducción del Riesgo de Desastres (RRD) con esfuerzos más amplios de justicia y liberación. Aunque la Investigación Acción Participativa (IAP) ha sido ampliamente promovida como un enfoque prometedor para empoderar a las comunidades y fortalecer su capacidad para gestionar el riesgo, su implementación en los estudios de desastres a menudo carece de atención a sus fundamentos teóricos en la democracia participativa, la justicia social y la indagación crítica. En este artículo, buscamos contribuir al uso de la IAP en la RRD, resaltando el valor de un enfoque freireano (es decir, inspirado en el reconocido educador y teórico brasileño Paulo Freire). Sostenemos que la participación democrática y equitativa es fundamental para una investigación en RRD eficaz y abogamos por un enfoque comunitario para reducir el riesgo y prevenir su recreación. Basándonos en los fundamentos teóricos de la IAP, destacamos la importancia de comprender el problema en su contexto, integrar conocimientos basados en valores en el proceso de investigación y equilibrar las iniciativas mediante una praxis dialógica. En este sentido, para fomentar una participación democrática y equitativa en la investigación en RRD, es crucial cuestionar las dinámicas de poder predominantes, centrarse en los temas clave más pertinentes e inculcar un sentido de pertenencia en el diseño de la investigación en RRD, así como en las estrategias de involucramiento e intervención. Al entretejer los principios freireanos en las aplicaciones de la IAP, la RRD puede trascender las meras soluciones técnicas, abordar desafíos sistémicos más profundos y promover un enfoque más incluyente, democrático y centrado en lo humano en los estudios de desastres. Este trabajo intenta servir como guía para investigadores que buscan emplear la IAP en los estudios de desastres, abogando por un enfoque más equitativo y liberador que resuene con las experiencias vividas y las aspiraciones de las comunidades afectadas. 초록: 인종화되고 주변화되며 박탈당한 지역사회에 기후변화와 재난이 미치는 불평등한 영향은 재난위험경감 (DRR) 노력을 보다 광범위한 정의와 해방 노력과 연계할 필요성을 제기한다. 참여형 행동연구 (PAR) 가 지역사회 역량 강화 및 위험 관리 능력 구축을 위한 유망한 접근법으로 널리 권장되어 왔음에도 불구하고, 재난 연구에서의 그 실행은 참여 민주주의, 사회 정의, 비판적 탐구라는 이론적 토대에 대한 관심을 충분히 기울이지 못한다. 본 논문은 (저명한 브라질 교육자이자 이론가인 파울루 프레이리에게서 영감을 얻은) 파울루 프레이리의 접근법의 가치를 강조함으로써, DRR 에서 PAR 활용에 기여하고자 한다. 우리는 민주적이고 평등한 참여가 효과적인 DRR 연구의 기초라고 주장하며, 위험을 줄이고 재발을 방지하기 위한 지역사회 주도적 접근을 제안한다. PAR의 이론적 토대를 바탕으로, 문제의 맥락적 이해, 가치 기반 지식의 연구 과정 통합, 실천적 대화를 통한 균형 잡힌 접근의 중요성을 강조한다. 이러한 맥락에서, DRR 연구에 민주적이고 공평한 참여를 촉진하기 위해서는 지배적인 권력 역학에 도전하고, 가장 핵심적인 문제에 집중하며, DRR 연구 설계, 참여 및 개입 전략에 소속감을 심어주는 것이 중요하다. 프레이리 접근법을 참여형 행동연구 (PAR) 적용에 접목함으로써, 재난위험감소 (DRR) 는 단순한 기술적 해결책을 넘어 더 깊은 체계적 과제를 다루고, 재난 연구에 있어 보다 포용적이고 민주적이며 인간 중심적인 접근을 도모할 수 있다. 본 연구는 재난 연구에 참여형 행동연구를 활용하려는 연구자들을 위한 지침서 역할을 목표로 하며, 피해 지역사회의 실제 경험과 열망에 공감하는 보다 공평하고 해방적인 접근법을 주창한다.
Zitieren
APA
Mehdipour, H., & Meding, J. V. (2026). Disrupting Power Dynamics and Promoting Equitable Participation in Disaster Risk Reduction: Freirean Approach to Participatory Action Research in Jacksonville, Florida. Journal of Disaster Studies, 3(1), 28-58. https://doi.org/10.1353/jds.2026.a997614
Vancouver
Mehdipour H, Meding JV. Disrupting Power Dynamics and Promoting Equitable Participation in Disaster Risk Reduction: Freirean Approach to Participatory Action Research in Jacksonville, Florida. Journal of Disaster Studies. 2026;3(1):28-58. doi:10.1353/jds.2026.a997614
BibTeX
@article{Mehdipour2026,
author = {Mehdipour, Haleh and Meding, Jason von},
title = {Disrupting Power Dynamics and Promoting Equitable Participation in Disaster Risk Reduction: Freirean Approach to Participatory Action Research in Jacksonville, Florida},
journal = {Journal of Disaster Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {3},
number = {1},
pages = {28--58},
doi = {10.1353/jds.2026.a997614}
}
EUVIMED