Who Is Right about Being Wrong? Dharmakīrti and Candrakīrti on Reliable Cognition, Memory, and the Warranting of Mistakes
Journal of Buddhist Philosophy · 2026 · 9 (1) · 28-53
DOI: 10.1353/jbp.2026.a997962 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Buddhist Philosophy, 2026. Verfasst von Jacob D. Fisher.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines the contrasting approaches by Dharmakīrti and Candrakīrti to a fundamental problem of epistemology. It addresses the paradox inherent in deceptive experience: if we can remember being deceived, we must have been conscious of the subjective experience, yet this consciousness seemingly contradicts the fact that we were deceived. Through analysis of the two Kīrti’s works and later Tibetan interpretations, the article demonstrates how these philosophers developed distinct methodological approaches to the issues of reliable cognition ( pramāṇa ), memory, and the warrant of mistaken consciousness. While Dharmakīrti employs sophisticated conceptual frameworks involving abstract notions such as reflexive awareness ( svasaṃvedana ), Candrakīrti consistently appeals to non-analytical worldly consensus ( lokasiddha ) and conventional usage ( lokavyavahāra ). The article argues that Candrakīrti’s singular methodology, grounded in verifiable personal experience and common understanding, offers more accessible solutions to these epistemological challenges than Dharmakīrti’s complex theoretical constructs. This analysis not only illuminates an important methodological distinction between these influential Buddhist philosophers but also contributes to broader discussions about the relationship between philosophical theory and lived experience in Buddhist epistemology.
Zitieren
APA
Fisher, J. D. (2026). Who Is Right about Being Wrong? Dharmakīrti and Candrakīrti on Reliable Cognition, Memory, and the Warranting of Mistakes. Journal of Buddhist Philosophy, 9(1), 28-53. https://doi.org/10.1353/jbp.2026.a997962
Vancouver
Fisher JD. Who Is Right about Being Wrong? Dharmakīrti and Candrakīrti on Reliable Cognition, Memory, and the Warranting of Mistakes. Journal of Buddhist Philosophy. 2026;9(1):28-53. doi:10.1353/jbp.2026.a997962
BibTeX
@article{Fisher2026,
author = {Fisher, Jacob D.},
title = {Who Is Right about Being Wrong? Dharmakīrti and Candrakīrti on Reliable Cognition, Memory, and the Warranting of Mistakes},
journal = {Journal of Buddhist Philosophy},
year = {2026},
volume = {9},
number = {1},
pages = {28--53},
doi = {10.1353/jbp.2026.a997962}
}
EUVIMED