EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Framework of Flesh: Builders' Labourers Battle for Health & Safety by Humphrey McQueen (review)

Chris White

International Union Rights · 2009

DOI: 10.1353/iur.2009.0006 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Union Rights, 2009. Verfasst von Chris White.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

REVIEW□ Framework of Flesh: Builders' Labourers Battle for Health & Safety by HumphreyMcQueen (2009) GinninderraPress 340pp, ISBN 978 1 74027 545 3, Paperback, AUD $30.00 Review by Chris White Humphrey torian Inrespect author McQueen ofhis of latest numerous is a publication labour books. hisI Humphrey torian author of numerous books. Inrespect ofhislatest publication I agreewithProfessor LindaClarke, from the EuropeanInstitute of Construction Labour Research, whowrote that: 'The geniusof Humphrey McQueen has brought to lifethetremendous and sometimes fatal efforts madebybuilding labourers in constructing thebuiltenvironmentof Australia.I hope that Framework of Flesh is read by every building worker andbyallthosewithan interest inoccupational health andsafety, andinconstruction labourworldwide.' 'Framework ofFlesh'takesup a 1920s challenge froma militant Australian labourer, CharlieSullivan, to focuson workers' own stories: 'feweverthink of thegreat andhumble army whosesweat and blood are mingled in theconcrete andbricks as surely as ifthewallswere built overa framework ofhuman flesh.' McQueenuses labourers' own words to retell their battles aroundscaffolding and shithouses, forthesaferemoval of asbestos, prompt andadequatecompensation , anda decentburial. The stories start in Australian convict times andcoverthesixStates ofAustralia up to current battles, suchas theprosecution oflabourer ArkTribeforrefusing torat onhisworkmates under Australia's severeanti-union legislation keptbythe RuddLaborgovernment (see,www.right sonsite.org.au). By tracking on-the-job experiencesof demolishers, dog-men, hod-carriers and navvies, McQueenconfirms theconviction ofan early official of theBLF,BenMulvogue 1915: 'The betterment of the conditions of the workershas been broughtabout through organisation. A unionconstitutes a schoolfortheworking class,wherein they learnself-reliance; learntheir rights, privileges, opportunities, as wellas their possibilities. The unioninstills thoughtfulness in its membership, and broadensthe mental horizon,therebybringinghope and cheertothehopelessandcheerless. Theunionimbuesitsmembers witha longing for a better andbrighter future by increasing wages and diminishing the hoursoftoil. Theunionhasmadepossibleprogress not onlyforthe workingpeople, but advancement inmanyother directions morally , socially, andintellectually - and istraceable totheexistence oftheorganisation of the workers. Every new demandforbetter physical protection of theworkers ensures a greatidealdevelopmentfora future generation'. This study payshomagetothis hope.Itbrings togethernarratives about battlingfor health andsafety withan investigation of whyresistance bythecapitalists hasbeen relentless. It rangesacross200 yearsof Australian OHS but is relevant forall countries,as we all share struggles betweencapitalandwage-labour. HereOHS isanchored tothelawsgoverning theaccumulation of capital.The hazards,like the claimsforcompensation ,are experienced within thepower relationsbetween MessrsConstruction Capitaland theworkers who mustsell their capacities in orderto exist.In that system, speed-upsareas relevant to the rateofexploitation as they aretothelevels ofinjury. As a result, worker control hasbeencrucial toimproving OHS. McQueentakethesideoftheworkers as a class.Thebookis infour parts: PartOne begins with 19thCentury sketches ofthedeath-traps ofan industry unregulated by the state and largely unchecked byorganised labour. Then1900-50 documents therateand rangeof injuries, the employers' resistancetoScaffolding Actsandtoadequate inspection, and the effortby the Australian Builders' Labourers' Federation to overcomeboth while educatinga membership withhighlevelsofchurn at a time whenreinforced concrete presented newhazards. Then from 1950 to 2000 injuries boomed along with the economyon high-rises and miningprojects.In the 1970sthelabourers' assaulton managerial prerogatives over on-sitesafety and conditions istraced. Therearethehistoric greenbans.Thatsurgeofworker control led to theABLF'sderegistration in 1974. By1990,allStates hadrevised their OHS Actstoplacea nominal responsibility on employers toensuresafeworkplaces. 'Intothe21stCentury' examinesOHS intheon-going effort todestroy thenow Construction Division of the Construction,Forestry,Mining and EnergyUnion. This is by former PM Howard's anti-union 2002-3 Royal Commission that led to specific lawstargeting buildingworkers'strikesand granting Stasi-like policepowerscomparableto those againstterrorists. Those laws deprive officials'rights-of-entry while injurylevels remain2-3 times greater thanamongtherestoftheworkforce .To understand whythe building tradehas been the cause of so many deathsand so much disablement, the chapter on 'hazardous knacks'examines theminute-by-minute experiences ofcategories oflabourers. Therearesnapshots ofthreehazardous forms oflabouring by demolishers, hod-carriers and dogmen .PartTwo dealswith'Dirt, disease, anddiscontent.' Forevery labourer killed onsites, ninemorediefrom work-related diseases - silicosis,asbestosis, poisons, dermatitis, hearing lossandskeletal damage . Provisions for inclement weather andthedilemma ofdirt money aredebated . Thenmorestories of struggles over lavatories tohotlunches tobetter amenities .PartThreelooksat waysin which labourershave supportedeach other against theconsequences ofharms inflicted atwork- relief funds, funeral benefits andprovisions forinfirm workers. The history of earlyreforms to compensation forinjured workers is traced. Unionpressure was tilting theonus of proof fromworkerto capitalist. The labourers fought to improve compensationforthe injuries culminating in the 1970swith thewinning ofaverage weekly earnings paid as soon as a labourer wentoff work.Itrecounts theresistance byMessrs Construction Capital topaying fortheirpounds of flesh,abettedby lawyers andinsurers. NextMcQueenexplains 'howtheillogic thatcompelscapitalto expand also makesitinjure humancapacities.' InPart Fourthetitle 'Killing nomurder' is taken fromemployers...

Zitieren

APA

White, C. (2009). Framework of Flesh: Builders' Labourers Battle for Health & Safety by Humphrey McQueen (review). International Union Rights. https://doi.org/10.1353/iur.2009.0006

Vancouver

White C. Framework of Flesh: Builders' Labourers Battle for Health & Safety by Humphrey McQueen (review). International Union Rights. 2009. doi:10.1353/iur.2009.0006

BibTeX
@article{White2009,
  author = {White, Chris},
  title = {Framework of Flesh: Builders' Labourers Battle for Health & Safety by Humphrey McQueen (review)},
  journal = {International Union Rights},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1353/iur.2009.0006}
}
Kostenlos starten →