Editorial: Introduction to History, Health, and Hybridity
Health and History · 2006
DOI: 10.1353/hah.2006.0004 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health and History, 2006. Verfasst von Barbara Brookes. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 3-mal zitiert (Crossref).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Editorial: Introductionto History, Health, andHybridity In 2005, a History, Health, and Hybridity:New Zealand and the Pacific ResearchClusterwas formally constitutedat the University of Otago. A key impetus behind the founding of the Clusterwas the recognition that New Zealand is a Pacific nation and has close links with many Pacific communities, from an institutional to an informal nature. Through researchon historicalandcontemporaryhealthpolicies andpractices,the clusterserves to highlight the Pacific dimension of New Zealandsociety and New Zealand links with Island communities. It brings together researchers from a variety of disciplines who are working on aspects of health-related research in New Zealand and the Pacific, including environmentalimpacts,housing, genderandhealth,sustainability,ethics andpolicy formation,and mental health. Otago has a strongtraditionof health-relatedresearchin humanitiesandthis Clusterserves to highlight thatdistinctiveness. It was Charles Darwin who first used the term 'hybridity' in 1837 in reference to his experiments with cross fertilisation in plants. The termthen had a purelybiological dimension and suggested fixed origins andessences. When choosing the theme 'History,Health,andHybridity' for the December 2005 symposium which gave rise to this edition of Health & History, we were seeking to employ a more expansive use of the term hybridity and to examine its salience for the history of medicine. Hybridityhas provedusefiil in recentpostcolonial scholarship because of its potential to suggest the multiple origins of both people and practices. However, it has the danger, as Marwan Kraidy warns, of meaning both everything and nothing, 'when fragmentsof discourse or data are cobbled together and called hybridity in several registershistorical , rhetorical,existential, economic, and so on.' Here we take up Kraidy's challenge 'to situate every analysis of hybridity in a specific context where the conditions thatshape hybridities arediscussed.'1 The point of our symposium was to stimulatediscussion aroundthe ways in which concepts of health and disease, and medical practices, arecomposed of elements from differentculturalcontexts in the Pacific region. The sites of our discussion were various in their geographic location, ethnic composition, and timeframe and gave rise to debate 2 BARBARABROOKES about the way western medicine, often seen as a unified concept, was itself fractured and various in its encounters with other systems of healing. As Annie Stuartwrites in herarticle,hybridity'has the potential to encompass and express the dynamism and multi-layered complexity of interactions and processes across a diverse region. It highlights juxtapositions and the way in which apparently-fixedentities actually comprise contradictory elements, and therefore contain an inherent tension andpotential to re-form in unexpected ways.' Only five of the original symposium papers are represented here but we are grateful to all the participantsfor insights which benefited this collection. Those participantsincluded Jacqui Leckie and Heather Young-Leslie, who addressed very different aspects of health care in the Pacific. Leckie's discussion of madness and pregnancy in Fiji suggested how the western individualised concept of health was at odds with Fijian notions of care while Young-Leslie outlined the intersection between medicine, modernity, and culture apparentin the experiences of early Tongan students at the CentralMedical School. Lorelle Burke discussed the experience of Maori patients at the Auckland Lunatic Asylum who were caredfor andtreated- or ignored- by those who did not share their language. Health education for Maori was the subject of BarbaraBrookes' paper on a 1952 film about tuberculosis. Hans Pols discussed Indonesianphysicians and the importanceof this small group of trained men in the nationalist movement. A new professional class, which defined itself on the basis of education and skill, diagnosed their colonial society as sick and in need of independence as a cure. Finally, Nancy Pollock addressedthe way in which Pacific foods aretheresultof transculturationand thatthe adoption of new dietaryregimes may have unforeseen consequences for health. This volume of Health & History begins with Anne Perez Hattori's analysis of an American-founded maternity hospital in Guam in Micronesia: a place where the local Chamorropeople faced a transition in colonial power from the Spanish to the Americans in 1898. The Susana hospital was a physical space in which native and western notions of maternal health collided. The hospital, Anne Perez Hattori argues,became a contact zone where mothersandmidwives produceda hybridised version of obstetricalcare. Annie Stuart focuses on the Rockefeller Foundation itself- as a hybrid organization through which private wealth was...
Zitieren
APA
Brookes, B. (2006). Editorial: Introduction to History, Health, and Hybridity. Health and History. https://doi.org/10.1353/hah.2006.0004
Vancouver
Brookes B. Editorial: Introduction to History, Health, and Hybridity. Health and History. 2006. doi:10.1353/hah.2006.0004
BibTeX
@article{Brookes2006,
author = {Brookes, Barbara},
title = {Editorial: Introduction to History, Health, and Hybridity},
journal = {Health and History},
year = {2006},
doi = {10.1353/hah.2006.0004}
}
EUVIMED