The Devil's Doctor: Paracelsus and the World of Renaissance Magic and Science by Philip Ball
Health and History · 2006
DOI: 10.1353/hah.2006.0002 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health and History, 2006. Verfasst von Hugh Crone.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
TheDevil 'sDoctor.Paracelsus and the WorldofRenaissance Magic and Science. By Philip Ball (William Heinemann, London,2006, hb, ISBN 0-434-01134-7) xi + 435pp. Health& History• 8/1 • 2006 123 This is the second recent book on Paracelsus (see a review of Paracelsus. The man who defied medicine in Health and History 6, no. 2, 2004). Both works draw on the same resources but with a different outlook. Ball has produced a well researchedand fully referenced review of the English literature on Paracelsus (Theophrastus von Hohenheim, 1493-1541) and of the philosophy of his time. He extends this to a shortbutuseful summaryof the legacy of Paracelsus and his influence on medicine and chemistrythroughto the time of Lavoisier. Ball does not, however, address the main problem of commentatorson Paracelsus,thatis, distinguishinghistorical fact from the myths and legends thathave grown up aroundthe man. This is despite the statement on the cover flap which proclaims that '[m]yths abouthim ... have proved far more lasting than his actual story.9Ball is in danger of perpetuatingthis problem. It is compounded by the vague and often ambiguous writings of the sage himself. The difficulty is apparentimmediatelyupon opening the book, forthe fly papersshow the extensive supposedtravelsof Paracelsusas basedon the dubiousresearchof Basilio de Telepnef. To give some credit to Ball, however, althoughthe map is baldly titled Travelsof Paracelsus, the surroundingtext does have some reservations.Theterms,'probably 'and'generallybelieved'areused to qualify many of his statementson these travels.Also, the text, which is mostly well supportedby references, is bare of citations in describing these travels except for assertions by Paracelsus himself. During his early travels, for example, Paracelsus is said to have acted as a surgeon with the various armies involved in the numerous wars around Europe. However, the evidence for this is scanty.One of the argumentsused to supportthis claim in Ball's book is Paracelsus' authorshipof the Great SurgeryBook. This book describes the author's philosophy of the treatment and healing of wounds but is very short of practical advice and technical directions. By contrast, the Field Book of Surgery by Hans von Gersdorff,who was a militarysurgeon,is full of details 124 BOOK REVIEWS andmethods. One wonders if Paracelsushad a real backgroundin militarysurgery.Ball's book certainlywould have benefitedfrom an explorationof such a question. Ball relies very much on the statements and comments of others on his subject without going to Paracelsus' own writings andapplyinga criticalanalysisto test his statements.Similarly,the readeris not given any details, culled from Paracelsus'writings, as to the specifics of his medical treatments or his alchemical experiments. Because of this, we are provided with little more than a rather surface perspective. There is no mention of the recentforensic work which suggests thatParacelsussufferedfrom congenital adrenalhyperplasia, a disease that would explain his physical appearance,his lack of sexual drive andconsequentlyhis erraticemotional state. The supposed transmutationof base metals to gold and the Philosophers'Stoneareextensively covered, butI believe thatBall could have better representedParacelsus' beliefs on the general topic. He was usingthepurificationof variousmaterialsas a means of advancingtowardsthe core secretof matter.Thusthe distillation of volatile essences from plants or the recovery of metals from ores were bothexamples of movementtowardsthe ultimatepurity, atwhich pointthe universewould be explicable. The factthatgold might be producedwas a useful side issue for Paracelsus,distinct fromthe goals of the more worldly seekers of wealth. Ball doesaverygoodjob indescribingthegeneralphilosophical environment concerning medicine at the time of Paracelsus. He discusses the various conflicting ideas widely, justifying the subtitle of his book. He is a clear and fluent author,providing a text thatis easy to readandengaging for the reader. The title of the book is quite extraordinarilyinappropriate. Paracelsus was never the devil's doctor; his whole philosophy is suffused with his individualisticversion of Christianity.Certainly he believed in magic, as did everyone else in his time, but it was white, not black, magic. In his text, Ball never indicates an involvement of his subjectin devilish practicesexcept for quoting the comments of Erastus and his followers in their attempts to blackguardParacelsus. In fact, he states how 'Paracelsus sought to embed this "new"medicine within a comprehensive system of (devoutly Christian)naturalphilosophy' (p. 7). Ball also quotes from the doctor's writings such phrases as: Tor Holy Scripture representsthe beginning of all...
Zitieren
APA
Crone, H. (2006). The Devil's Doctor: Paracelsus and the World of Renaissance Magic and Science by Philip Ball. Health and History. https://doi.org/10.1353/hah.2006.0002
Vancouver
Crone H. The Devil's Doctor: Paracelsus and the World of Renaissance Magic and Science by Philip Ball. Health and History. 2006. doi:10.1353/hah.2006.0002
BibTeX
@article{Crone2006,
author = {Crone, Hugh},
title = {The Devil's Doctor: Paracelsus and the World of Renaissance Magic and Science by Philip Ball},
journal = {Health and History},
year = {2006},
doi = {10.1353/hah.2006.0002}
}
EUVIMED