Alcoholism in America by Sarah W. Tracy
Health and History · 2006
DOI: 10.1353/hah.2006.0001 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health and History, 2006. Verfasst von Caroline Clark.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
180 BOOKREVIEWS their position in nineteenth-century Britain. Nineteenth-century doctors were beginning to gain status but for many their incomes and reputations depended on patronage. Further,they were of the growing and diverse middle class and theirviews would have been as varied as theireducational backgrounds.Therearetoday medical procedures for which there is no evidence; history has shown that medicine is and will be errorridden. Darby did convince me that doctors played a role in the rise of circumcision but I am sure other social, economic, and political factors also played significant parts. MERRILYN WALTON UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY Alcoholism in America. By Sarah W. Tracy (John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore & London, 2005, hb, ISBN 0-80188119 -6), 357 pp. During the nineteenth century, drinking in America changed. Industrialisationrequireda reliable workforce andmade workplace drinking a thing of the past; urbanisation led to overcrowded living and working conditions; and mass immigration (especially of Irish Catholics) fed anxiety about urban disorder and public drunkenness. The late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries saw the first attempts to medicalise habitual drunkenness. This was not a simple exercise of medical power, as it was driven by others besides physicians: the alcoholic 'rounders' who repeatedly ended up in prisons and hospitals were a majorproblem; there was considerable social utility in a disease diagnosis, especially one that separated drinkers from the insane; and for drinkersthemselves it was a means of reducing stigma. Medicalisation of inebriety was a response to the problem of alcohol; a response that was an alternative to temperance, and one that drew on the cachet of science, fitted the growing mental hygiene movement, and was modelled on the medicalisation of insanity. Between 1870 and 1920 over two hundred private and public institutions were established across the United States. Some patients were voluntary, most committed by the courts. Physicians preferred the 'hopeful' cases; but too often the public institutions Health& History• 8/2 • 2006 18 1 were filled with 'incorrigibles,' resulting in overcrowding which led to increasingly punitive and authoritariantreatment.Treatment success- measured primarily by sobriety but also by social functioning, in particularthe ability to work- was vital to ensure ongoing popularand state supportfor public institutions. However, most institutions were privately run, so despite regular calls for public inebriate institutions as a measure to relieve overcrowding in jails and insane asylums, that situation remained unchanged in most places. The introduction of national Prohibition cut short efforts to treatalcoholism medically: if no one drank,there would be no alcoholics (not that it turnedout that way of course). The construction, experience, and treatment of alcoholism varied according to gender and class. Alcoholism in women was variously attributedto their peculiar physiology, their occupation (middle-class women had too little to do, working class women too much, in addition to the influence of the unsavoury elements they had to mix with), the changing role of women (the influence of the 'New Woman'), and consumption of proprietarymedicines which notoriously contained large amounts of alcohol. A poorly-run home was a cause of men's drinking problems; and treatment for women was based on cultivating domestic and maternal instincts. As bearers of morality, women inebriates were more deviant than men, and as bearers of the nation's children, female alcoholics were implicated in broader concerns about 'race suicide.' Women drinkers thus signified a raft of social problems, identification of which was used to drive reforms- although not to benefit women themselves, as most institutions only treatedmen. Formen, drinkingwas anopportunitytoasserttheirmasculinity, but alcoholism also stripped it from them; male alcoholism was an expression of a crisis of masculinity, linked to the threat from the 'New Woman.' Almost universally, recovery from alcoholism was for men the recovery of their manhood. Class mattered too, not just in terms of access to treatment, but in how patients were accommodated- preferably separated according to social standing. Middle-class women were more likely to be diagnosed as dipsomaniacs, whereas working-class women remained drunks. Alcoholism in America is the first comprehensive work on alcoholism that examines its medical, social, and cultural history during this early period of medicalisation. It explores ideas about, practices in relation to, and experiences of alcoholism and its treatment; Sarah Tracy's aim is to capture...
Zitieren
APA
Clark, C. (2006). Alcoholism in America by Sarah W. Tracy. Health and History. https://doi.org/10.1353/hah.2006.0001
Vancouver
Clark C. Alcoholism in America by Sarah W. Tracy. Health and History. 2006. doi:10.1353/hah.2006.0001
BibTeX
@article{Clark2006,
author = {Clark, Caroline},
title = {Alcoholism in America by Sarah W. Tracy},
journal = {Health and History},
year = {2006},
doi = {10.1353/hah.2006.0001}
}
EUVIMED