EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Not Part of the Public: Non-Indigenous Policies and Practices and the Health of Indigenous South Australians 1836-1973 by Judith Raftery

Kyllie Cripps

Health and History · 2006

DOI: 10.1353/hah.2006.0000 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health and History, 2006. Verfasst von Kyllie Cripps.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Not Part of the Public: Non-Indigenous Policies and Practices and the Health of Indigenous South Australians 1836-1973. By Judith Raftery (Wakefield Press, Kent Town, 2006, ISBN 1-86254-7092 ). 230 pp + Index. Book Reviews Not Part of the Public is an intriguing book that examines how attitude and policy have constructed Indigenous South Australians as apart from, and less than, 'the public' over time. The book is unique in thatit surveys the impact of non-Indigenous interventions on Indigenous health over nearly 150 years in the light of current understandings of what contributes to the health of populations. The book, whilst specifically focused on South Australia, could equally relate to other parts of the country were similar contexts and ramifications were experienced between Indigenous and nonIndigenous people from colonisation to the present day. The book also clearly establishes the origins of Indigenous ill health andhow it is undoubtedly a product of colonisation. Rafteryconducts athoroughcriticalanalysis of non-Indigenous policies and practices over the period 1836-1973. The chapters are segmented into specific periods reflective of the policies of the times and follow a chronological order. Through this type of analysis Raftery is able to successfully illustrate how the ideology of assimilation has maintained its currency over time in both popularperception andpublic policy. Since settlement, Indigenous people have been viewed invariably as deprived, other, subhuman, or unequal: while the names of the policies have changed over time- from 'protectionism' in the nineteenth century to the 'selfdetermination ' of the last thirty years and now the era of shared responsibility- the firm belief amongst non-Indigenous people in their own superiority has continued. It has, as a consequence, promoted the assimilationist ideology that if Indigenous people are to be saved from their pitiful existence, then they must become more like 'us' and thus 'partof the public' Whilst this book details the politics of the time, and the consciousness thatgave rise to such politics, its focus is specifically on how politics affected Indigenous health. When Raftery writes Health&History, 2006.8/2 176 Health& History• 8/2 • 2006 177 abouthealth she is referringto 'well-being,' which she describes as 'a state of being which enables individuals and populations to live a life that is good, according to their values and aspirations' (p. 9). She views health as largely determined by social, historical, and political factors. She argues that political factors are particularly important, as health can be withheld from or undermined in some groups within populations according to 'how power and opportunity are divided and shared and according to which values and aspirations are legitimated and valued and which are not' (p. 10). This is an important observation made by Raftery and the evidence she presents enables one to grasp the essential and important role individual autonomy and empowerment can play and has played in the maintenance of health. Added to this is the realisation thatthe behaviours and choices of both non-Indigenous and Indigenous individuals cannot be separated from their social context. Raftery also argues that health is not simply a matter of material circumstance, but also a direct consequence of equality, empowerment, and control over work-related issues and social connectedness. This broadtheoretical base in public health sets the foundation for Raftery's structural analysis of health and of what makes populations healthy. Raftery critically examines the colonisation of SouthAustralia.As the subtitle of her book implies, her focus is almost exclusively on non-Indigenous materials, which can leave the readerasking where is the Indigenous voice? And what was the Indigenous response to the various policies and practices enforced upon them? It may also leave one frustratedat times as this book appears as yet another portraying Indigenous people as victims and losers. Raftery however, acknowledges this serious limitation in her introduction and notes that 'writing history is about trying to think and act differently towards oneself, towards others, and towards the present more than the past' (p. 16). She furtheradds that as a historian working in the field of public health, it is an analysis that she felt compelled to do as a matter of fundamental justice (p. 17). The honesty with which Rafterycritically reflects on her desire to do this work and...

Zitieren

APA

Cripps, K. (2006). Not Part of the Public: Non-Indigenous Policies and Practices and the Health of Indigenous South Australians 1836-1973 by Judith Raftery. Health and History. https://doi.org/10.1353/hah.2006.0000

Vancouver

Cripps K. Not Part of the Public: Non-Indigenous Policies and Practices and the Health of Indigenous South Australians 1836-1973 by Judith Raftery. Health and History. 2006. doi:10.1353/hah.2006.0000

BibTeX
@article{Cripps2006,
  author = {Cripps, Kyllie},
  title = {Not Part of the Public: Non-Indigenous Policies and Practices and the Health of Indigenous South Australians 1836-1973 by Judith Raftery},
  journal = {Health and History},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1353/hah.2006.0000}
}
Kostenlos starten →