HISTORIC RECOGNITION AND THE EROSION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CHICAGO’S WORKING-CLASS NEIGHBORHOODS
Change Over Time · 2026
DOI: 10.1353/cot.0.a1003850 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Change Over Time, 2026. Verfasst von MELISSA ROVNER.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Historic preservation aims to protect neighborhood character and community identity, yet the frameworks through which the designation operates may inadvertently accelerate the loss of the affordable housing that sustained the historically working-class communities whose labor and ingenuity created the neighborhoods now celebrated. This essay examines that tension through city-level analysis and detailed examination of three National Register historic districts in Chicago—Pilsen, East Ravenswood, and Wicker Park—combining longitudinal census tract data, matched-comparison analysis, and building typology evidence to distinguish between population loss, housing dedensification, and racial and economic displacement as separable but interrelated processes. Findings reveal that across all three districts, the share of two-unit and three- to four-unit buildings declined faster within designated boundaries than in matched controls, while larger multifamily structures expanded in both designated and non-designated tracts, indicating a broader market shift that designation accelerated but did not create. Citywide, designated tracts showed statistically significant smaller declines in White population share and larger declines in Black population share than matched controls between 1990 and 2020, even after controlling for 1990 baseline characteristics. National Register frameworks direct federal tax incentives toward architecturally intact structures while leaving the broader building stock unprotected. Local landmark review governs façade appearance but not unit counts. And the interaction of historic district status with RT and RS-3 zoning makes demolition of modest multifamily buildings economically rational in ways that designation cannot counteract. As cities nationwide expand historic districts while grappling with housing crises, this analysis offers a replicable framework and a direct challenge to preservation practice. Until designation is evaluated against housing function alongside architectural form, it will continue to correlate with the erasure of the affordable fabric it claims to protect.
Zitieren
APA
ROVNER, M. (2026). HISTORIC RECOGNITION AND THE EROSION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CHICAGO’S WORKING-CLASS NEIGHBORHOODS. Change Over Time. https://doi.org/10.1353/cot.0.a1003850
Vancouver
ROVNER M. HISTORIC RECOGNITION AND THE EROSION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CHICAGO’S WORKING-CLASS NEIGHBORHOODS. Change Over Time. 2026. doi:10.1353/cot.0.a1003850
BibTeX
@article{ROVNER2026,
author = {ROVNER, MELISSA},
title = {HISTORIC RECOGNITION AND THE EROSION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CHICAGO’S WORKING-CLASS NEIGHBORHOODS},
journal = {Change Over Time},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1353/cot.0.a1003850}
}
EUVIMED