The Quad Without Convergence: India, Japan, and the Resilience of Minilateral Cooperation
Asia Policy · 2026-10 · 21 (4) · 139-156
DOI: 10.1353/asp.2026.a1007134 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Asia Policy, 2026-10. Verfasst von Arijit Mazumdar.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
executive summary: By comparing Japan's and India's expectations for the Quad, this essay examines reasons behind why the Quad has struggled to move from diplomatic engagement to deeper cooperation. main argument By 2017, when the Quad minilateral was revitalized by Australia, India, Japan, and the United States, conditions in the international landscape, especially regarding China, had made each member more willing to see strategic coordination as a necessary response. Despite expectations, however, the Quad has often produced frustration among policymakers in its perceived practical utility. The Quad's uneven performance is best explained not by tactical disagreements or differing threat perceptions but by how its members—especially Japan and India—use the platform in different ways. Japan treats the Quad as a tool for building durable cooperation through rules, procedures, and regularized coordination. India sees the Quad as a flexible forum to signal alignment while preserving strategic autonomy and discretion, particularly in situations involving China. These approaches are compatible, but they place clear limits on what the Quad can realistically achieve. policy implications • Given the differing approaches among the Quad members, initiatives that assume shared willingness to accept binding commitments, coordinated crisis responses, or deeper institutionalization are likely to stall. • The Quad's value lies in functioning as a flexible coordination platform that can endure shifts in U.S. policy and varying partner preferences. Policymakers—especially in Washington—should design Quad initiatives around flexibility, opt-in participation, and role differentiation rather than institutional convergence. • Success should be measured by steady coordination, signaling, and capacity-building over time rather than by progress toward formal commitments or crisis-response mechanisms. Misreading the Quad as a convergence mechanism risks repeated frustration and policy miscalculation.
Zitieren
APA
Mazumdar, A. (2026). The Quad Without Convergence: India, Japan, and the Resilience of Minilateral Cooperation. Asia Policy, 21(4), 139-156. https://doi.org/10.1353/asp.2026.a1007134
Vancouver
Mazumdar A. The Quad Without Convergence: India, Japan, and the Resilience of Minilateral Cooperation. Asia Policy. 2026;21(4):139-156. doi:10.1353/asp.2026.a1007134
BibTeX
@article{Mazumdar2026,
author = {Mazumdar, Arijit},
title = {The Quad Without Convergence: India, Japan, and the Resilience of Minilateral Cooperation},
journal = {Asia Policy},
year = {2026},
volume = {21},
number = {4},
pages = {139--156},
doi = {10.1353/asp.2026.a1007134}
}
EUVIMED