A Race to the Bottom? China, the United States, and the Environmental Diplomacy of Deep-Sea Mining in the Pacific
Asia Policy · 2026-10 · 21 (4) · 117-138
DOI: 10.1353/asp.2026.a1007133 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Asia Policy, 2026-10. Verfasst von Steven F. Jackson.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
executive summary: This essay examines Chinese and U.S. interests and efforts toward deep-sea mining (DSM) and the governance, reputational, and diplomatic tensions inherent in this emergent field. main argument China and the U.S. are both advocating DSM in the continental shelf/exclusive economic zones (EEZs) of foreign countries and on the high seas to reduce their critical mineral dependencies and bypass chokeholds on foreign terrestrial mining. Yet there is more than just minerals at stake; the U.S. and China are also contesting for legitimacy in international environmental governance, and this is especially important in their relations with the Pacific Island states. China's desire to maintain an image of a responsible environmental player, work within the rule-making process of the International Seabed Authority (ISA), and advance its diplomacy in the Pacific has slowed its DSM quest, although it is pushing the ISA to adopt a mining code that would permit DSM in the high seas. The U.S., which is outside the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) and the ISA, has taken a different, two-pronged strategy. First, like China, it is seeking contracts for DSM exploitation in several Pacific Island countries' EEZs. Second, it announced it will sponsor mining in the high seas spaces that are under the ISA's governance and would be in violation of UNCLOS. While intended to accelerate access to seabed resources, this approach has generated international criticism, strengthened momentum behind ISA rulemaking, and created opportunities for China to portray itself as the more credible defender of a rules-based order. As a result, the U.S.'s actions may undermine its broader diplomatic and strategic objectives in the Pacific and contribute to a race to the bottom. policy implications • The audacity and speed of the U.S. approach have helped China's cause by giving impetus to the drafting of the ISA's own mining code while casting the U.S. in a negative light in terms of rule of law and environmental stewardship. • Pacific Island states are likely to evaluate deep-sea mining proposals not only on economic grounds but also through the lenses of environmental stewardship, sovereignty, and international legitimacy. • The U.S. risks ceding diplomatic influence to China in debates over DSM governance by operating outside the ISA framework and appearing less committed to multilateral rulemaking. The best course for the U.S. to take is to ratify UNCLOS, join the ISA, and adhere to its regulations, though this seems unlikely in the current U.S. administration.
Zitieren
APA
Jackson, S. F. (2026). A Race to the Bottom? China, the United States, and the Environmental Diplomacy of Deep-Sea Mining in the Pacific. Asia Policy, 21(4), 117-138. https://doi.org/10.1353/asp.2026.a1007133
Vancouver
Jackson SF. A Race to the Bottom? China, the United States, and the Environmental Diplomacy of Deep-Sea Mining in the Pacific. Asia Policy. 2026;21(4):117-138. doi:10.1353/asp.2026.a1007133
BibTeX
@article{Jackson2026,
author = {Jackson, Steven F.},
title = {A Race to the Bottom? China, the United States, and the Environmental Diplomacy of Deep-Sea Mining in the Pacific},
journal = {Asia Policy},
year = {2026},
volume = {21},
number = {4},
pages = {117--138},
doi = {10.1353/asp.2026.a1007133}
}
EUVIMED