The Public-Law Implications of the Long-Term Repair Allowance System under the Multi-Family Housing Management Act: Focusing on Its Relationship with Management Expenses (Repair and Maintenance Costs)
Construction & Urban Development Law Association · 25.03.2026 · (15) · 67-80
DOI: 10.12972/cudla.2026.15.5 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Construction & Urban Development Law Association, online erschienen am 25.03.2026. Verfasst von Soyeon Kim.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The long-term repair allowance system constitutes a public-law regulatory mechanism established under the Multi-Family Housing Management Act (hereinafter “the Act”). Its purpose is to extend the lifespan of multi-family housing and maintain the quality of residence by ensuring timely repair of common areas before their functions are exhausted. Regarding certain substantial repair works pertaining to major facilities of the common areas of multi-family housing, a long-term repair plan must be formulated. Based on such a plan, the management entity of the relevant multi-family housing is required to collect and accumulate a long-term repair allowance from the owners on a monthly basis, and the accumulated allowance must be expended in accordance with the long-term repair plan. Meanwhile, under the Act, “management expenses” serve as another means of financing the costs required for the management of the common areas of multi-family housing. Management expenses may be imposed on both owners and tenants, and their detailed purposes of use are limited to 10 statutory categories. Among these, the key item pertaining to the long-term repair allowance is “repair and maintenance costs.” Since repair and maintenance costs are defined as “costs incurred for the repair and maintenance of common areas of multi-family housing that are excluded from the long-term repair plan,” the long-term repair allowance and repair and maintenance costs form a mutually exclusive relationship as methods of financing repair costs for common areas. Additionally, repair works subject to the mandatory establishment of a long-term repair plan are, by their nature, substantial acts that enhance the capital value of the relevant facilities. Accordingly, the normative justification for imposing such costs on tenants is relatively weak. Indeed, as the Act provides that long-term repair allowance may be imposed only on owners, the long-term repair allowance system also functions to demarcate, among the costs required for the management of common areas of multi-family housing, those that may be appropriately collected exclusively from owners and those that may also be collected from tenants. In the context of this structural relationship, a proper interpretation of the Act suggests that management expenses may not serve as the financial source in any of the following cases where repair works whose kinds are designated as subject to a long-term repair plan are undertaken, where facilities designated as subject to a long-term repair plan are newly installed, and where such facilities are leased and installed. However, as this conclusion cannot be regarded as definitive based on the statutory text alone, legislative clarification would be desirable.
Zitieren
APA
Kim, S. (2026). The Public-Law Implications of the Long-Term Repair Allowance System under the Multi-Family Housing Management Act: Focusing on Its Relationship with Management Expenses (Repair and Maintenance Costs). Construction & Urban Development Law Association, 67-80. https://doi.org/10.12972/cudla.2026.15.5
Vancouver
Kim S. The Public-Law Implications of the Long-Term Repair Allowance System under the Multi-Family Housing Management Act: Focusing on Its Relationship with Management Expenses (Repair and Maintenance Costs). Construction & Urban Development Law Association. 2026:67-80. doi:10.12972/cudla.2026.15.5
BibTeX
@article{Kim2026,
author = {Kim, Soyeon},
title = {The Public-Law Implications of the Long-Term Repair Allowance System under the Multi-Family Housing Management Act: Focusing on Its Relationship with Management Expenses (Repair and Maintenance Costs)},
journal = {Construction & Urban Development Law Association},
year = {2026},
number = {15},
pages = {67--80},
doi = {10.12972/cudla.2026.15.5}
}
EUVIMED