Comparing the benefits of a metacognitive reading strategy instruction programme between CLIL and EFL primary school students
Elia · 2017 · (17) · 71-92
DOI: 10.12795/elia.2017.i17.04 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Elia, 2017. Verfasst von Alba Gutiérrez Martínez und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 4-mal zitiert (Crossref).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
espanolLa instruccion estrategica es una parte fundamental del curriculo de lenguas extranjeras. Varios estudios (Wenden & Rubin, 1987; O’Malley & Chamot, 1990; Chamot & O’Malley, 1994; Cohen & Macaro, 2007; Chamot, 2008; Cohen, 2011, entre otros) han demostrado que el uso de las estrategias de aprendizaje produce un efecto positivo en el exito de los hablantes aunque este campo no ha estado exento de controversia (Rees-Miller, 1993; Dornyei y Skehan, 2003; Dornyei, 2005; Manchon, 2008; Macaro, 2006, 2007, 2010). Este estudio investiga el efecto de un entrenamiento estrategico de lectura en ingles en dos contextos educativos: AICLE (Aprendizaje integrado de contenido y lengua) e ILE (Ingles lengua extranjera) y reflexiona sobre como los aprendices de lenguas pueden beneficiarse de esta aproximacion didactica. Los participantes (N = 145) provienen de seis clases de dos colegios de Santander, Cantabria, una comunidad del norte de Espana. Una de los colegios seguia una metodologia AICLE y, el otro, no. Los grupos experimentales en ambos colegios siguieron un entrenamiento metacognitivo de estrategias de lectura disenado siguiendo el modelo de Macaro (2001) que se centra en la conciencia metacognitiva. Los grupos controles continuaron con las clases normales. Todos los grupos realizaron pre-tests y post-tests. Los resultados demuestran que aquellos alumnos (AICLE e ILE) que siguieron el entrenamiento estrategico obtuvieron mejores resultados en la prueba metacognitva. Sin embargo, aunque el grupo experimental AICLE supero al grupo experimental ILE, no se encontraron diferencias significativas entre ellos lo que nos lleva a concluir que este tipo de entrenamiento es efectivo en ambos contextos educativos y resalta la importancia de la aproximacion metacognitiva para la mejora de la comprension lectora en la clase de lenguas extranjeras EnglishStrategy instruction is a fundamental part of the language learning curriculum. Several studies (Wenden & Rubin, 1987; O’Malley & Chamot, 1990; Chamot & O’Malley, 1994; Cohen & Macaro, 2007; Chamot, 2008; Cohen, 2011, among others) have shown that the use of learning strategies produces a positive effect on learners’ achievement, although the field has not been without controversy (Rees-Miller, 1993; Dornyei y Skehan, 2003; Dornyei, 2005; Manchon, 2008; Macaro, 2006, 2007, 2010). Thus, the aim of this study is to investigate the effects of a metacognitive reading strategy training in two educational contexts, CLIL and EFL, and reflect on how learners can benefit from this learning approach. Participants (N = 145) came from six intact classes from two different schools in Santander, Cantabria, a community in the north of Spain. One of the schools followed a CLIL methodology and the other did not. The experimental groups in both schools underwent a seven-week metacognitive reading training programme developed by the research team, following the model proposed by Macaro (2001) that focuses on metacognitive awareness. Control groups continued with regular classes. Pre-tests and post-tests were carried out for both control and experimental groups. As hypothesized, results indicate that those students (CLIL and EFL) that followed the strategic training obtained better scores on the metacognitive reading task than their control groups, but with no significant differences between both educational approaches (CLIL and EFL) even though the experimental CLIL group outperform the experimental EFL group. This leads us to the conclusion that this type of training is effective in both educational contexts and highlights the importance of the metacognitive teaching approach to improve reading comprehension in second language classes
Zitieren
APA
Martínez, A. G., & Zarobe, Y. R. D. (2017). Comparing the benefits of a metacognitive reading strategy instruction programme between CLIL and EFL primary school students. Elia, 71-92. https://doi.org/10.12795/elia.2017.i17.04
Vancouver
Martínez AG, Zarobe YRD. Comparing the benefits of a metacognitive reading strategy instruction programme between CLIL and EFL primary school students. Elia. 2017:71-92. doi:10.12795/elia.2017.i17.04
BibTeX
@article{Martnez2017,
author = {Martínez, Alba Gutiérrez and Zarobe, Yolanda Ruiz de},
title = {Comparing the benefits of a metacognitive reading strategy instruction programme between CLIL and EFL primary school students},
journal = {Elia},
year = {2017},
number = {17},
pages = {71--92},
doi = {10.12795/elia.2017.i17.04}
}
EUVIMED