Beyond the Kelsenian Frame: The Ghost of Subjectivity in Judicial Decisions
Law, Culture and the Humanities · 06.05.2026
DOI: 10.1177/17438721261433422 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Law, Culture and the Humanities, online erschienen am 06.05.2026. Verfasst von Jaqueline Campos.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article investigates the influence of judicial subjectivity on legal decisions, establishing an interdisciplinary dialogue between legal theory and cognitive psychology. While legal positivism, particularly Hans Kelsen’s “Pure Theory of Law,” identifies the norm as a “frame” that offers multiple possibilities for application, it fails to detail the internal mechanisms that lead a judge to select one option over others. Utilizing the Empirical Zetetic Methodology, the study deconstructs the dogma of “prudent discretion” by demonstrating that judicial acts of will are not random but conditioned by predictable cognitive processes, such as heuristics and biases. Through an analysis of case law from the São Paulo Court of Justice (TJSP) regarding non-pecuniary damages (moral damages), the research reveals significant disparities in compensation for identical facts. These variations suggest that open-ended concepts like “reasonableness” and “proportionality” are often permeated by cognitive filters—such as anchoring, availability, and representativeness—that shape the magistrate’s understanding of fair compensation. The article concludes that improving the justice system requires moving beyond the reform of norms toward a multidisciplinary training approach that fosters self-critical awareness in judges regarding their own thought processes.
Zitieren
APA
Campos, J. (2026). Beyond the Kelsenian Frame: The Ghost of Subjectivity in Judicial Decisions. Law, Culture and the Humanities. https://doi.org/10.1177/17438721261433422
Vancouver
Campos J. Beyond the Kelsenian Frame: The Ghost of Subjectivity in Judicial Decisions. Law, Culture and the Humanities. 2026. doi:10.1177/17438721261433422
BibTeX
@article{Campos2026,
author = {Campos, Jaqueline},
title = {Beyond the Kelsenian Frame: The Ghost of Subjectivity in Judicial Decisions},
journal = {Law, Culture and the Humanities},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1177/17438721261433422}
}
EUVIMED