Efficiency over Equity: Why the Speed of Digital Investigation Extinguishes Defence Rights
Malta Journal of Legal Studies · 16.03.2026 · 1 (1-2) · 182-189
DOI: 10.1163/30508762-00000008 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Malta Journal of Legal Studies, erschienen am 16.03.2026. Verfasst von Stefano Filletti. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The confluence of sophisticated digital tools, artificial intelligence, and the principle of mutual recognition – as embodied by instruments like the European Investigation Order ( EIO ) and the European Public Prosecutor’s Office ( EPPO ) – has fundamentally reshaped the landscape of criminal justice. This article reviews the immediate and profound challenges this data-driven environment poses to the fundamental rights of the defence, arguing that the speed of digital investigation is catastrophically outpacing the essential deliberation required by due process. The resulting structural imbalance manifests in the procedural annihilation of defence rights, notably the right to prepare a defence and the principle of equality of arms. Drawing on the stark procedural paradox illustrated by the Bharwani case in Malta, the article examines how “total data” seizure destroys the confidentiality inherent in Legal Professional Privilege and how the volume of data itself acts as a new barrier to disclosure. The solution lies not in abandoning technological progress, but in architecting the safeguards directly into the system. Four concrete, structural remedies are proposed: the establishment of a Digital Habeas Corpus, the creation of an Independent Digital Magistrate to manage privilege, the redefinition of Equality of Digital Arms through state-funded forensic resources, and the enforcement of a robust Digital Exclusionary Rule. This is a call of procedural urgency to ensure that in the future, justice is not merely swift, but unequivocally fair.
Zitieren
APA
Filletti, S. (2026). Efficiency over Equity: Why the Speed of Digital Investigation Extinguishes Defence Rights. Malta Journal of Legal Studies, 1(1-2), 182-189. https://doi.org/10.1163/30508762-00000008
Vancouver
Filletti S. Efficiency over Equity: Why the Speed of Digital Investigation Extinguishes Defence Rights. Malta Journal of Legal Studies. 2026;1(1-2):182-189. doi:10.1163/30508762-00000008
BibTeX
@article{Filletti2026,
author = {Filletti, Stefano},
title = {Efficiency over Equity: Why the Speed of Digital Investigation Extinguishes Defence Rights},
journal = {Malta Journal of Legal Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {1-2},
pages = {182--189},
doi = {10.1163/30508762-00000008}
}
EUVIMED