An Essay on an Indian Community of Persian Descent: Reflections on Caste and Colonial Schizophrenia1
Scottish Educational Review · 16.06.2026 · 58 (1) · 9-46
DOI: 10.1163/27730840-bja10037 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Scottish Educational Review, erschienen am 16.06.2026. Verfasst von Murzban Jal. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The question of caste is both an important issue grounded in the Indic variation of the Asiatic mode of production as well as a ticklish issue for the political elites in India who stay blind to this issue or if opening their eyes transform this to the discourse of liberal democracy where caste is removed from history and political economy and transfigured as the question of “social justice” and “identity politics” that they by and large borrowed from the Orientalists. Now according to Orientalism, caste was understood as constituted in the colonial idea of “paganism” and the realm of the anti-Christ and thus as mere “manners and customs” of the anti-Christ bathed, as if, in the sorrows of biblical Original Sin. In fact what we know as “caste” today has less to do with reality and more to do with liberal democratic understanding that is grounded in the colonialist manufacturing of this system as one of the anti-Christ, a genealogy that emerges from discourses of the Anglican missionaries Charles Grant, William Wilberforce, the Macaulay duo: father Zachary, son Thomas and John Wilson not to forget the Orientalist William Jones and the reactionary French Jesuit Abbe Dubois who fathered this idea which then was made a reality by Herbert Risley and his eugenic racist understanding of Indian society. According to the liberal democratic understanding grounded in Orientalist discourse, the caste question must be addressed not by its annihilation, but through liberal democratic reform. This essay firstly makes a distinction between caste that one derives from the discourse of the colonialists and calls this “mere caste” that is either related to “manners and customs of the pagans” which then was transformed as the discourse of “social justice” (by liberalism) and what I call the “caste-clan system” that was articulated by Karl Marx and B.R. Ambedkar. After making this distinction this essay then involves a terrain shift and moves into the understanding of the Parsis, the descendents of the ancient Persians who through a colonial legal judgment in 1908 were also classified as a “caste”. This essay provides a counterpoint to the colonial imposition of categories and broadens the arena of operation from the discourses of nation state caged in colonialism to a different understanding of South and West Asia, especially on India and Iran.
Zitieren
APA
Jal, M. (2026). An Essay on an Indian Community of Persian Descent: Reflections on Caste and Colonial Schizophrenia1. Scottish Educational Review, 58(1), 9-46. https://doi.org/10.1163/27730840-bja10037
Vancouver
Jal M. An Essay on an Indian Community of Persian Descent: Reflections on Caste and Colonial Schizophrenia1. Scottish Educational Review. 2026;58(1):9-46. doi:10.1163/27730840-bja10037
BibTeX
@article{Jal2026,
author = {Jal, Murzban},
title = {An Essay on an Indian Community of Persian Descent: Reflections on Caste and Colonial Schizophrenia1},
journal = {Scottish Educational Review},
year = {2026},
volume = {58},
number = {1},
pages = {9--46},
doi = {10.1163/27730840-bja10037}
}
EUVIMED