Turin-Rome-Tripoli-The Hague: Italy’s failure to cooperate with the International Criminal Court in the Elmasry Case
The Italian Yearbook of International Law Online · 18.11.2026 · 35 (1) · 283-305
DOI: 10.1163/22116133-03501014 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Italian Yearbook of International Law Online, erschienen am 18.11.2026. Verfasst von Luca Poltronieri Rossetti.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines the case concerning the arrest, release, and repatriation by Italian authorities in January 2025 of Osama Elmasry Njeem, a Libyan citizen against whom the International Criminal Court issued a warrant of arrest for crimes against humanity and war crimes, allegedly committed at the Mitiga Prison in Tripoli. This was the first time that the Court requested Italy’s cooperation in the arrest and surrender of a suspect. The unconvincing interpretation of Law No. 237/2012 on cooperation with the Court put forward by the Minister of Justice and by domestic judicial bodies, leading to the suspect’s release and rushed repatriation, exposed serious deficiencies in Italy’s will-ingness and capacity to fully cooperate with the Court. On 17 October 2025 the Pre-Trial Chamber found Italy’s conduct in breach of its obligation to cooperate with the Court. By a separate decision, issued on 26 January 2026, the Chamber referred Italy’s non-com-pliance to the Assembly of States Parties. In October 2025, the Corte d’Appello di Roma raised questions of constitutionality concerning several provisions of Law No. 237/2012. The article critically analyzes the conduct of Italian authorities, the non-cooperation decisions of the Court, and the decisions of the Corte d’Appello di Roma on the mat-ter. It contends that the domestic legal framework on cooperation, despite its structural shortcomings, could – and should – have been interpreted consistently with the Statute to allow full cooperation with the Court, and that a decision by the Corte Costituzionale may not resolve all underlying operational issues relating to judicial cooperation with the International Criminal Court. It concludes that Italy’s behavior in the case does not live up to the country’s long-standing commitment to international criminal justice. This is, unfortunately, part of a more general trend whereby States’ posture in cooperation matters remains seriously influenced by considerations of political opportunity.
Zitieren
APA
Rossetti, L. P. (2026). Turin-Rome-Tripoli-The Hague: Italy’s failure to cooperate with the International Criminal Court in the Elmasry Case. The Italian Yearbook of International Law Online, 35(1), 283-305. https://doi.org/10.1163/22116133-03501014
Vancouver
Rossetti LP. Turin-Rome-Tripoli-The Hague: Italy’s failure to cooperate with the International Criminal Court in the Elmasry Case. The Italian Yearbook of International Law Online. 2026;35(1):283-305. doi:10.1163/22116133-03501014
BibTeX
@article{Rossetti2026,
author = {Rossetti, Luca Poltronieri},
title = {Turin-Rome-Tripoli-The Hague: Italy’s failure to cooperate with the International Criminal Court in the Elmasry Case},
journal = {The Italian Yearbook of International Law Online},
year = {2026},
volume = {35},
number = {1},
pages = {283--305},
doi = {10.1163/22116133-03501014}
}
EUVIMED