EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The Origins of the Conflict Dimension in Croatian-Serbian Relations

Saša Mrduljaš

Migration and ethnic themes · 2025

DOI: 10.11567/met.2025.3 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Migration and ethnic themes, 2025. Verfasst von Saša Mrduljaš.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Prior to the Ottoman incursion and subsequent conquest of most of Southeastern Europe, the central South Slavic region – comprising present-day Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, Serbia, and Kosovo – was marked by relatively clear political and religious boundaries. To the west, within the Catholic sphere, were the Kingdoms of Slavonia, Croatia, and Dalmatia, the Kingdom of Bosnia, and the Republic of Dubrovnik. To the east, within the Orthodox sphere, lay the Serbian Despotate and Zeta. The Ottomans swiftly conquered Serbia, Zeta, and a large part of Bosnia, where the majority of the indigenous population remained. In 1463/64,a long-standing Croatian-Bosnian-Hungarian defensive line was established along the Klis–Jajce–Doboj–Janja axis, extending toward the Danube. Over the following 130 years, the Ottomans advanced this line by only 130–150 kilometres westward, reaching the Karlobag–Slunj–Karlovac–Sisak–Đurđevac axis. As they progressed, they almost entirely depopulated the newly conquered territories and repopulated them primarily with Orthodox Serbian settlers speaking the Neo-Shtokavian Ijekavian dialect, originating from eastern Herzegovina and Montenegro. Simultaneously, particularly during the first half of the 16th century, they carried out mass Islamization of the Bosnian – and, to a lesser extent, Herzegovinian – population, laying the foundations for the emergence of a new Muslim Bosniak ethnic community. Alongside destruction, depopulation, and religious conversions, the Ottoman presence inadvertently triggered certain processes that, from the perspective of the modern Croatian nation, may be viewed as positive. It contributed to the unification of the fragmented remnants of former Slavonia and Croatia into a singular kingdom identifiable by the Croatian name, and subsequently stimulated the socio-cultural and political consolidation of the Catholic population across the central South Slavic region, driven by an anti-Ottoman impetus. This created a crucial precondition for the eventual formation of the Croatian nation once favourable circumstances emerged. With the conclusion of the anti-Ottoman liberation wars, spanning from the late 17th to mid-18th century, major migratory movements ceased, and the ethnic landscape – largely preserved until the disintegration of Yugoslavia – was definitively shaped. These wars also played a key role in determining the contemporary border between Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina. Compared to the pre-Ottoman period, the religious and ethnic composition of the region underwent a fundamental transformation. During pre-Ottoman times, Orthodox- Serbian populations were virtually absent from the territory of present-day Croatia, and in Bosnia and Herzegovina, they were concentrated mainly in eastern Herzegovina and parts of the Upper Drina region – altogether covering less than five percent of the combined territory of present-day Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina. By contrast, in the post-Ottoman period, regions predominantly inhabited by Orthodox Serbs roughly accounted for thirty-seven percent of the total area of these two countries. The Catholic-Croatian population remained a majority only in the western, northern, and southern peripheries. Muslims (Bosniaks) constituted the majority in the eastern half of Bosnia and Herzegovina but were significantly interspersed with both Catholic-Croatian and, even more so, Orthodox-Serbian populations. The conflict with the Ottomans resulted not only in the mass extermination of the Catholic-Croatian population, especially in the central territories – many of which were not regained during the anti-Ottoman wars – but also in unfavourable political developments under Habsburg rule. Large parts of Croatia were excluded from the jurisdiction of its national institutions and were instead administered as part of the Military Frontier, directly under the Imperial Court. This arrangement persisted until 1871/81, when these territories were reintegrated into Croatia, which, in the meantime, had been subordinated to Hungarian rule following the Austro- Hungarian Compromise of 1867. Simultaneously, Istria and Dalmatia – having come under Habsburg control after the fall of Venetian and French rule – remained permanently detached from Croatia. Following the Austro-Hungarian occupation of Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1878, a state-sponsored project promoting a distinct Bosniak national identity was imposed, including upon the Catholic-Croatian population. In sum, Ottoman conquests, depopulation, colonization, religious conversions, and the weakening of Croatian autonomy under Habsburg authority created an adverse context for the emergence of the Croatian nation. Under these conditions, the central aim of Croatian national ideology became the unification of all Croatian lands under Habsburg rule into a single, autonomous or semi-autonomous Kingdom of Croatia. After the Austro-Hungarian occupation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, efforts were made to incorporate these territories as well. In contrast, the Serbs managed to preserve the core of their pre-Ottoman ethnic territories, where, during the decline of Ottoman rule, and in a manner similar to the Romanians, Bulgarians, Montenegrins, and Greeks, they reestablished a Serbian state, internationally recognised in 1878. Furthermore, they succeeded in expanding into the majority-Albanian areas of Kosovo and into Macedonia. During their national consolidation, the idea of a Greater Serbia emerged, aiming to encompass all territories historically inhabited by Serbs, particularly in the West, encompassing much of present-day Croatia and the entirety of Bosnia and Herzegovina, including areas inhabited by Croats and Bosniaks. Consequently, Croatian and Serbian national state-building projects have been in fundamental opposition from their very inception, with overlapping territorial claims. This inherently generated a conflictual dimension in Croatian-Serbian relations. The disparity in national positions further intensified this antagonism, as the Serbian advantages far outweighed those of the Croats. Nevertheless, this conflictual dimension did not predominantly shape Croatian-Serbian relations until the establishment of the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats, and Slovenes in 1918. This delay can be attributed primarily to the influence of foreign powers, which exerted significant pressure on both Croats and Serbs, particularly those in Serbia, thus constraining their political actions. Consequently, efforts were made to transcend existing antagonisms, notably through cooperation based on the idea of Yugoslavism, although this idea was interpreted quite differently in Croatian and Serbian circles. Furthermore, while the general population was becoming increasingly aware of their national identities, it remained largely politically disengaged, living in rural, isolated, and underdeveloped settings. As such, they were ill-equipped to recognise the political nature of Croatian-Serbian relations or to actively shape them. Both of these “buffering” factors would weaken significantly with the formation of the Yugoslav state, in which Croats and Serbs – alongside others – would, for the first time, find themselves “alone with each other.” Therefore, the emergence of the conflictual dimension in Croatian-Serbian relations must be placed within the broader context of nation formation and the pursuit of respective national goals. The Ottomans merely laid the structural groundwork, which would prove enduring, for the eventual emergence of this conflict. Attempts to trace the origin of this antagonism to the proselytising ambitions of the Catholic or Orthodox Church are unsubstantiated, as such efforts were products of ecclesiastical policies sanctioned by state powers with no connection to Croatian or Serbian national interests. Similarly, the conflict cannot be traced to the involvement of parts of the Orthodox-Serbian population in Ottoman conquests or their role in the separationof the Military Frontier. This is primarily because segments of the Catholic-Croatian population also participated in Ottoman campaigns, and the same population, motivated by class interests and forming the majority within the Military Frontier, supported the Habsburg Court in its confrontation with Croatian state institutions. Ultimately, both Orthodox and Catholic frontiersmen, including those in Dalmatia, jointly advocated for the incorporation of their regions into the Kingdom of Croatia during a time when their military significance was waning and national-formative processes had not yet fully gained momentum.

Zitieren

APA

Mrduljaš, S. (2025). The Origins of the Conflict Dimension in Croatian-Serbian Relations. Migration and ethnic themes. https://doi.org/10.11567/met.2025.3

Vancouver

Mrduljaš S. The Origins of the Conflict Dimension in Croatian-Serbian Relations. Migration and ethnic themes. 2025. doi:10.11567/met.2025.3

BibTeX
@article{Mrdulja2025,
  author = {Mrduljaš, Saša},
  title = {The Origins of the Conflict Dimension in Croatian-Serbian Relations},
  journal = {Migration and ethnic themes},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.11567/met.2025.3}
}
Kostenlos starten →