EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

MEDICATION INCIDENTS (ERRORS) RELATED TO THE PRESCRIBING, DISPENSING AND ADMINISTRATION OF MEDICINES TO THE OLDER PERSON

JBI Library of Systematic Reviews · 2004

DOI: 10.11124/jbisrir-2004-666 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift JBI Library of Systematic Reviews, 2004.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

PROTOCOL Australian Centre for Evidence Based Aged Care (ACEBAC) A collaborating centre of the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) La Trobe University Bundoora, Victoria 3083 Contact: Dr. Susan Koch Tel: 61 3 9495 3209 Fax: 61 3 9495 3154 Email: [email protected] Primary reviewer: TO BE COMPLETED **** Secondary reviewer: TO BE COMPLETED **** Review Panel membership: Dr Susan Koch (Chair) ACEBAC Deputy Director Ms Karen O'Keefe (Director of Nursing) Caulfield General Medical Centre Dr Michael Murray (Geriatrician) St George's Health Service Dr Michael Whishaw (Geriatrician) Melbourne Extended Care & Rehabilitation Service Dr Kwang Lim (Geriatrician) Broadmeadows Health Service Professor Kenn Raymond (Professor of Pharmacology) La Trobe University Bendigo Ms Susan Hunt, Nurse Consultant & Educator Mr David Cooper, Aged Care Standards & Accreditation Agency Mr Dipak Sanghvi (Pharmacist) The Pharmacy Guild of Australia Ms Cathie Edgar (Nurse Educator) Bundoora Extended Care Centre (BECC) Mrs Mandy Heather (Director of Nursing) Bundoora Extended Care Centre (BECC) Ms Helen Baker (Professor of Nursing) Victoria University Mrs Lisa Derndorfer (ACEBAC administrator)

Background

Medication use increases with age. In Australia, around 59% of the general population uses medication. This number increases to about 86% in those aged 65 and over, with 83% of the population over 85 using two or more medications simultaneously (AIHW 2002). It would appear that the greater the number of medications administered, the greater the risk of an incident (error) occurring (Osbourne et al 1999). Therefore it is not surprising that medication related problems are commonly reported in the older person. Roark (2004) found that in the US in 1993, one in 854 inpatient hospital deaths was due to a medication incident (error) of some type. The administration of medication is only one part of a larger process that involves the prescribing and dispensing of the medication. In the acute care sector, the greatest number of incidents (errors) occurred at the physician ordering (39%) and the nurse administering (38%) stages (Leape et al 1995). Leape et al (1995) based their work on the concept that although it was the individuals that make errors, it was the characteristics of the system in which they work that make errors more likely, and also more difficult to detect and correct. Furthermore, by focussing on the systems failures rather than on the individual, more errors would be eliminated. Focussing on the individual who is likely to be punished for his or her actions has been reported as one of the factors for the under reporting of medication incidents (errors) (Osbourne et al, 1999), along with incident (error) being ‘redefined’ in light of no harm coming to the patient (Baker, 1997; Osbourne et al, 1999). A number of writers have identified causes of medication incidents (errors) which have included inadequate knowledge (Leape et al, 1995; Furqua and Stevens (1988) cited in Osbourne et al, 1999; O'Shea, 1999), failure to comply with hospital policies and procedures (Furqua and Stevens (1988) cited in Osbourne et al, 1999; O'Shea, 1999; Baker, 1997), quality of prescription (Wolf as cited in Osbourne et al, 1999; Osbourne, 1999; O'Shea, 1999), environmental distractions (Wolf as cited in Osbourne et al, 1999; Osbourne, 1999; Sholz, 1990, as cited in O'Shea, 1999), calculation errors (O'Shea, 1999; Wolf as cited in Osbourne et al, 1999) and medication with names that sound alike and/or have look alike packaging (Leape et al, 1995). Furthermore, a study by McGillis Hall et al (2004) found that a high level of medication error was associated with the proportion of professional nurses in the staff skill mix. This was similar to the findings of Leape et al (1995) and Roseman and Booker (1995, as cited in O'Shea, 1999).

Objectives

To present the best available evidence related to the identification and management of medication incidents (errors) associated with the prescribing, dispensing and administration of medicines in the older person in the acute, subacute, and residential care settings. The specific review questions to be addressed are: ✓What types of medication incidents (errors) have been identified in the acute, subacute and residential care settings? ✓What causes of medication incidents (errors) have been identified in the acute, subacute and residential care settings? ✓What strategies/interventions are most effective in reducing the incidence of medication incidents (errors) in the acute, subacute and residential care settings? Criteria for considering studies for this review Types of studies This review will consider any randomised controlled trials (RCT) that evaluate strategies to identify and manage medication incidents. However in the absence of any RCTs, other research methods such as non-randomised controlled trials, longitudinal studies, cohort or case control studies, or descriptive studies, will be used to evaluate appropriateness and feasibility of medication management. Qualitative studies such as cohort or case studies, grounded theory and ethnographic studies will also be included. These will be included in a narrative summary. Only studies written in the English language will be included in the review. For the purposes of the review, medication will refer to medication which has been prescribed by a medical practitioner, not over-the-counter or herbal or vitamin preparations. In the absence of articles relating the older person specifically to medication incidents (errors) in the acute, subacute or residential care settings, articles will be reviewed which do not specify the age of the client/patient, using the same criteria as described previously. Types of participants Those people who are involved in the prescribing, dispensing or administering of medication to the older person (aged 65 years and older) in the acute, sub acute or residential care settings will be included in the review, namely: Registered nurses Enrolled nurses (or equivalent eg. LPN) Pharmacists Physicians/medical practitioners (or equivalents) Personal care attendants/ancillary staff (or equivalent) Types of interventions All studies reviewing the following will be included in the review: Identification of different types of medication incidents (errors)in the acute, sub-acute and residential settings 2. preventable incidents (errors) in prescribing of medication (dose, route, time, patient, legibility, known allergies) incidents (errors) in dispensing of medication (packaging, labelling) incidents (errors) in method of administration of a drug (drug, dose, route, time, patient, known allergies) non-preventable Strategies to prevent medication incidents (errors) in the acute, sub-acute and residential settings Types of outcome measures The outcome measures of interest to be considered will include: Identification of the causes of medication incident (error) Strategies that reduce the number and type of medication incident (error) Search strategy for identification of studies The Cochrane Collaboration and Joanna Briggs Institute did not identify any activity on this subject therefore a search strategy will be developed to guide the systematic review. All published and unpublished studies in the English language between 1986 and 2004 will be identified using a three step approach. The initial phase will consist of a limited search of the databases CINAHL (1982–2001) and MEDLINE (1966–2002) to identify keywords contained in the title and abstract and relevant MeSH headings and descriptor terms. Key words to be used in the initial search include: medication error, medication incident, elderly, older person, aged, prescribing, dispensing, administration A second more extensive search will be performed using the appropriate keywords for each of the following data bases: CINAHL, PsycINFO, Ageline, Cochrane Library, Embase, APAIS Health, Current Contents, Dare, Dissertation Abstracts, DRUG, MEDLINE, Social Science Index, International Pharmaceuticals Abstracts The third stage will involve hand searching reference lists and bibliographies of articles retrieved. Seminal works older than ten years referred to in the literature will also be included in the review. All studies identified during the database search will be assessed for relevance to the review based on the information contained in the title, abstract and descriptor/ MeSH heading. Methods of the review Assessment of methodological quality All identified studies that meet the inclusion criteria will be assessed for methodological quality by two independent reviewers. Quantitative studies will be critically appraised using the critical appraisal tool developed by the Joanna Briggs Institute (Appendix 1). If necessary, revision of this data extraction tool will occur once the full literature search has been conducted. Critical appraisal will focus on sources of bias in the studies, including those found in selection, performance, attrition and detection. Studies will be categorised based on the level of evidence that they offer, using the categories developed by the NH&MRC, as outlined in Table 1.Table 1: Designation of levels of evidence for assessing intervention studiesQualitative studies (e.g. case reports, focus groups, interviews, ethnographic studies, questionnaire/survey) will be assessed using the critical appraisal tool incorporated in Qualitative Assessment and Review Instrument (QARI) developed by the Joanna Briggs Institute (Appendix 2). Studies will be categorised based on the level of evidence that they offer, using the categories incorporated into QARI, as outlined in Table 2.Table 2: Designations of levels of evidence for assessing appropriateness and meaningfulness studiesWhere there is disagreement about inclusion or level of evidence, a third reviewer will give consensus. Data Extraction Details of eligible studies will be extracted and summarised independently by two reviewers. Data from quantitative data will be extracted using the instrument developed by the Joanna Briggs Institute (Appendix 3). Data from qualitative studies (e.g. case reports, focus groups, interviews, ethnographic studies, questionnaire/survey) will be extracted using the extraction tool incorporated in QARI (Appendix 4). Where there is disagreement between reviewers, a third reviewer will be consulted. Data Synthesis Should two or more comparable RCTs be identified, the results will be pooled in a meta-analysis using Review Manager (version 4.1) to determine the effectiveness of the intervention. Comparability of the studies will be defined by the population, interventions and outcome measures. Heterogeneity will be assessed using Chi square and visual interpretation of graphs. Significant heterogeneity will be assigned when the p value is less than 0.05. The type of data collected will determine the type of analytical approach used during synthesis. For example, odds ratio will be used to summarise effect for dichotomous data, while standard mean deviation will be used for continuous data. Meta-synthesis of qualitative data will be conducted using the respective components incorporated in QARI. This allows for the synthesis of findings into categories, which are then further collapsed into syntheses. Qualitative studies will be summarised in narrative form. Text which is not derived from research (e.g. opinion papers, discussion papers) will not be included in the systematic review, however may be referred to in the discussion section. Potential Conflict of Interest Nil identified to date

Zitieren

APA

(2004). MEDICATION INCIDENTS (ERRORS) RELATED TO THE PRESCRIBING, DISPENSING AND ADMINISTRATION OF MEDICINES TO THE OLDER PERSON. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. https://doi.org/10.11124/jbisrir-2004-666

Vancouver

MEDICATION INCIDENTS (ERRORS) RELATED TO THE PRESCRIBING, DISPENSING AND ADMINISTRATION OF MEDICINES TO THE OLDER PERSON. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. 2004. doi:10.11124/jbisrir-2004-666

BibTeX
@article{euvimed2004,
  title = {MEDICATION INCIDENTS (ERRORS) RELATED TO THE PRESCRIBING, DISPENSING AND ADMINISTRATION OF MEDICINES TO THE OLDER PERSON},
  journal = {JBI Library of Systematic Reviews},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.11124/jbisrir-2004-666}
}
Kostenlos starten →