EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Systematische Übersicht

Effectiveness of manipulation and mobilisation for headaches: an evidence-based systematic review

JBI Library of Systematic Reviews · 2004

DOI: 10.11124/jbisrir-2004-665 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Systematische Übersicht in der Zeitschrift JBI Library of Systematic Reviews, 2004. Die Arbeit nennt 1 Literaturangaben.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Centre: Centre for Allied Health Evidence Centre conducting review Name: Centre for Allied Health Evidence, University of South Australia, Adelaide Contact for review Name: Assoc.Prof Karen Grimmer Telephone: (08) 8302 2769 Facsimile: (08) 8302 2766 Email: [email protected] Primary reviewer Name: Thomas Larsen Telephone: 0401 466 343 Facsimile: (08) 8302 2766 Email:[email protected] Review panel: Secondary reviewer Name: Saravana Kumar Telephone: (08) 8302 2085 Facsimile: (08) 8302 2766 E-mail: [email protected] Commencement date February 2004 Expected completion date May 2004 Introduction Background and rationale for assessment Headache is reported as a common debilitating condition experienced by adults in the western world (Waters, 1973). It has been estimated that a headache in some form will be experienced by at least between 70–90 per cent of the population at some stage of their lives (Niere and Robinson 1997, Rasmussen, Jensen, Scholl and Olesen 1991). It is believed that many headache sufferers do not consult health practitioners and prefer to self manage their complaint. In Australia it is proposed that there are up to two million migraine sufferes (10%, Aust pop June 2001, 19.387 mill) and up to seven million tension-type headache sufferers (36% for men and 42% for women) (www.headacheaustralia.org.au). Nearly all migraine sufferers, and 60% of those with tension-type headache experience reductions in social activities and work capacity resulting in a $1 billon per annum direct and indirect cost of migraine alone (www.headacheaustralia.org.au). When headache sufferers do consult health professionals, they are potentially treated using a variety of methods, few of which have a clear evidence of effectiveness (Jull et al 2002). There exists a remarkable consistency in the headache literature contributing to a reasonable body of substantiation of opinion and data that supports the cervical spine as having a role in the aetiology of headache. Headache treatments are mostly non-invasive, generally involving medication and/or physical modalities. Physical modalities include; -Electrotherapy such as Transcutaneous Electrical Stimulation (TENS) -Exercise programs -Manual therapy techniques such massage, manipulation and mobilisation and postural retraining. Definitions of terms used: Manipulation - To examine and treat by moving bones into proper position manually, or “high velocity thrust technique given to a joint in its end range”. Mobilisation - Passive movements, rhythmical in nature, which vary in amplitude, but never, exceed the joint's normal range of motion Neck - The area from the Occiput and the seven cervical vertebrae Headache - Any pain/ache which comprises the head Effect - The result of cause or agent or the result of purpose or intention While there is equivocal literature evidence on the efficacy of manipulation and mobilisation for headaches (varying along the scale of the hierarchy of evidence), to date no systematic review of this literature, based on Joanna Briggs protocol, has been undertaken. Developing ‘clinical guidelines’ for the effectiveness of spinal mobilisation and manipulation in the treatment of headache will mean conducting a systematic review of the current literature within this area. Upon establishing such guidelines it is believed that Physiotherapy clinicians can have greater success in treating headache sufferers and the existing clinical variations in headache treatment will hopefully be minimised. In accordance with the National Health and Medical Research Council (2000), our guidelines will provide a methodology designed to improve the quality of health care in the clinical settings and circumstances by fostering: -Reduction in the number of unnecessary or harmful interventions; -Provision of specific treatment options with maximum benefit; and -Provision of treatments/interventions with minimum risk Objectives of the Systematic Review Assessment objectives The objective of this systematic review is to determine the efficacy of manipulation and mobilisation for headaches. The specific questions to be addressed are: - Is spinal mobilisation and manipulation effective in the treatment of tension- type headache, migraine and cervicogenic headache? - What type mobilisation and or manipulation used in tension-type headache, migraine or cervicogenic headache is the most effective; -in reducing headache and promoting comfort -in reducing headache intensity -in reducing headache frequency -in reducing headache duration Inclusion criteria Type of studies To determine the effectiveness of an intervention Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) would be the method of choice. Efficacy will be the main aim and complications will not be considered. In the absence of RCT, controlled trials will also be considered. Other research designs such as systematic reviews, other experimental trials, observational studies descriptive studies, case studies would also be considered in order to identify and evaluate the overall quality of the published literature. In order to investigate the effect of manipulation and mobilisation publications on technique description, diagnostic tests, outcome reliability, or topics that do not use or describe manual therapy of the cervical spine as an intervention will be excluded. Participants Adult age >18) with headache(s) who are currently receiving or have received manipulation and/or mobilisation as the main part of their treatment. Excluded are participants reporting of: headache due to neurologic compromises headache due to medical conditions headache caused by other factors such as tumours Interventions Any type of cervical spine mobilisation and manipulation with a specific physiotherapy background Excluded interventions are: Chiropractic intervention acupuncture craniosacral therapy Osteopathy These interventions are not physiotherapy specific and require specialised skills by the practitioner and hence will be excluded. Comparators The most appropriate comparator would be no manipulation or mobilisation for headaches or other alternative treatment strategies. Outcomes Primary outcome measures: Subjective changes in headache reporting (headache diary) Secondary outcome measures: Other clinical findings which are often reported in combination with headache such as altered range of motion, associated pain symptoms, changes to cervical musculature etc Language Searches will include all English and foreign language publications. Assessment for inclusion of foreign language publication will be based on the English language abstract, where available. Search strategy Literature sources In an initial search, all years available in each database will be covered to evaluate the amount of research done in this area, as well as to indicate any trends or changes over the years. Bibliographic Databases -CINAHL (1982-December week 2 2003) -Current content (1993 week 27-week 2 2004) -MEDLINE (1966-November week 2 2003) -AMED (1985- 2004) -AMI (2001–13/1 2004 ) -Cochrane Library (Start - 7/1 2004) * Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (CDSR) * Database of Abstracts of Reviews of effectiveness (DARE) * The Cochrane Controlled Trials Registers (CCTR) -AUSThealth (1966-Present) -Academic Search Elite (1985- Present) -PubMed (1966-Present) -PEDro - EMBASE (1988 to 2004 Week 11) -Digital Dissertations -CSP outcome measures database Internet www.dogpile.com www.eurekster.com www.vivisimo.com www.kartoo.com www.babieca.com www.yahoo.com www.google.com Pearling All included articles will have their reference lists searched for additional relevant material. Hand searching In order to avoid publication bias, hand searching will also be undertaken in journals which are not listed on databases and that are known to contain literature in this field. (eg: Chiropractic report, Headache, Cephalalgia) Content experts Content experts would also be contacted in order to provide other alternatives for securing relevant literature. Unpublished literature To further limit publication bias, postgraduate and doctoral dissertations would be identified and searched for further literature. Search strategies The following search strategy has been developed for MEDLINE (only incorporated one of the management key words). Similar strategies will be implemented for the different databases, with the same key words. Truncation symbols will be utilised accordingly. Headache: -Headache$ -Migrain$ -Cervical headache -Cervicogenic headache -Tension headache -Tension-type headache -Head pain Management: -Management -Physiotherapy -Physical Therapy -Manual Therapy -Mobilisation -Mobilization -Manipulation -Treatment Validity Assessment Level of EvidenceTable 1: Designations of levels of evidence for assessing intervention studiesQuality of evidence To evaluate the quality of evidence, each study will be critically appraised by two independent reviewers. The appraisal tool used will be the Law tool, which was developed by the McMaster University Occupational Therapy Evidence-Based Practice Research Group (Law et al 1998) (seeAppendix 1). This appraisal tool is a critical review form for quantitative studies considering eight main points such as study purpose, literature, study design, sample, outcomes, intervention, results, conclusions and clinical implications. Data Collection and Storage All included articles will be kept in a data storage sheet giving the information about title, author, source, location and which database they were retrieved from (seeAppendix 2). Data Extraction and Analysis Data will be extracted in a separate extraction sheet (adapted from Joanna Briggs Institute), providing a profile of each study, whereby following data will be collected (seeAppendix 3): demographic information about the subjects in the study study method descriptions of the intervention (s) description of the outcome measure(s) results of data analysis Data Synthesis If two or more comparable studies are identified, data will be pooled in a meta-analysis, using Review Manager, to determine the effectiveness of the particular intervention. Studies will be considered comparable if they have drawn subjects from comparable populations, used similar interventions and had comparable outcome measures. Double data entry will be used to minimise the risk of data entry errors. Heterogeneity between comparable studies will be assessed using Chi Square and visual inspection of the graphic presentation of the results. The meta-analysis approach used will be determined by the type of data. An odds ratio will be used as the summary measure of effect for dichotomous data. Either weighted mean difference or standardised mean differences will be used for continuous data as appropriate. Confidence intervals (95%) will be calculated for all data. If statistical pooling of results is not appropriate the findings will be summarised in a narrative form.

Zitieren

APA

(2004). Effectiveness of manipulation and mobilisation for headaches: an evidence-based systematic review. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. https://doi.org/10.11124/jbisrir-2004-665

Vancouver

Effectiveness of manipulation and mobilisation for headaches: an evidence-based systematic review. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. 2004. doi:10.11124/jbisrir-2004-665

BibTeX
@article{euvimed2004,
  title = {Effectiveness of manipulation and mobilisation for headaches: an evidence-based systematic review},
  journal = {JBI Library of Systematic Reviews},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.11124/jbisrir-2004-665}
}
Kostenlos starten →