Midwifery/Nursing management of hypoglycaemia in healthy full term neonates
JBI Library of Systematic Reviews · 2003
DOI: 10.11124/jbisrir-2003-651 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift JBI Library of Systematic Reviews, 2003.
Themen: Hebammenwesen und Geburtshilfe
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Centre: The Western Australian Centre for Evidence Based Nursing and Midwifery By: Robin Watts Jeanette Robertson Gaby Haddow with review panel members Background The newborn infant is required at birth to make very significant adaptations from the in-utero environment to the outside world. The most common manifestation of the failure of metabolic adaptation is hypoglycaemia (Hawdon, Ward Platt & Aynsley-Green, 1992). Unrecognised, severe hypoglycaemia can lead to death. In respect to morbidity, the effects of hypoglycaemia on long term mental and neurodevelopmental outcomes are not clear (Kalhan & Peter-Wohl, 2000). This is due to a number of issues, primarily confounding of results by intercurrent problems such as asphyxia; lack of comparability between, or poor design of studies focusing on infant outcomes; and lack of research on outcomes in later childhood. Symptomatic hypoglycaemia in newborns was first discussed in the literature in 1937 (Hartmann & Jaudon, 1937 cited in World Health Organization, 1997). Despite the length of the intervening period (65 years), “normal ranges” of blood glucose values have yet to be decisively defined for various categories of neonates (Cowatt & Loughead, 2002), aspects of management remain controversial and a number of related research questions are still to be addressed. The World Health Organisation (WHO) published a review of the literature on hypoglycaemia in neonates in 1997. This review drew on published studies up to 1996 and comprehensively addressed aspects such as the glucose homeostasis and metabolic adaptation at birth, effects of hypoglycaemia on the central nervous system, definition of hypoglycaemia, screening, prevention and treatment. Based on this review, 18 recommendations were formulated which are now widely accepted as guidelines for the management of hypoglycaemia in newborns. Given the greater problems experienced with hypoglycaemia in pre-term and small for gestational age babies (SGA), the focus of research has been on these groups rather than full term infants. Nonetheless studies on this group have been conducted. The reported incidence of hypoglycaemia in full term newborns (first postnatal week) ranges from 0–8%, approximately half the rate reported in pre-term neonates (Hawdon, Ward-Platt, & Aynsley-Green, 1992). In respect to prevention, factors in both the intrapartum and early postpartum periods need to be taken into account. Although some predisposing factors in the intrapartum period cannot be avoided, others such as excessive maternal glucose infusion, can be avoided. Appropriate care during the early postpartum period focuses on thermal regulation and feeding regimes - timing and type. Based on available studies and related literature, the WHO (1997) does not recommend screening, defined as the scheduled measurement of blood glucose, of healthy full term babies. Two reasons are given for this position. Firstly no diagnostic blood glucose concentration can be set and secondly no reliable cotside methodology is available. With the exception of babies born to diabetic mothers, this recommendation is extended to large for gestational age (LGA) infants. Approach to treatment depends on whether the neonate is asymptomatic or symptomatic i.e. shows clinical signs of hypoglycaemia. While the available evidence indicates poor short and long term outcomes in symptomatic infants, evidence of risk in the former group is inconclusive (WHO, 1997). The management of symptomatic hypoglycaemia requires medical intervention and will not be addressed in this review. In identifying the areas of primary research that need to be undertaken, the WHO (1997) highlighted that only a few studies of breast fed babies had been undertaken up to that time. This research was seen to be of prime importance in both developed and developing countries. Objectives The objectives of this review are to determine from the available evidence: the maintenance of euglycaemia in healthy full term neonates, and the management of asymptomatic hypoglycaemia in otherwise healthy full term neonates. The specific questions being asked are - Does the available evidence support the types and timing of various midwifery/nursing interventions that are commonly used to: prevent hypoglycaemia in healthy full term neonates? manage asymptomatic hypoglycaemia in otherwise healthy full term neonates? Criteria for considering studies for this review Types of studies The review will focus initially on randomised controlled trials reported from 1995* to 2002. If insufficient RCTs are identified then studies using other methods will be reviewed for possible inclusion in a narrative summary. (* 1995 has been selected as the start point as the WHO review only included studies up to 1994.) Types of participants Studies that include healthy full term (37–42 weeks gestation) neonates in the first 72 hours following birth. Exclusions: Preterm or SGA newborns Full term neonates with a diagnosed medical or surgical condition, congenital or otherwise. Babies of diabetic mothers. Neonates with symptomatic hypoglycaemia. LGA neonates (as significant proportion are of diabetic mothers) Types of interventions All interventions that fall within the scope of practice of a midwife/nurse will be included. The interventions of primary interest are those related to: Type (breast or breast milk substitutes), amount and/or timing e.g. initiation of feeding, and frequency Maintenance of body temperature Monitoring (including screening) of both ‘not-at-risk’ and ‘at risk’ * neonates, including blood or plasma glucose levels (bgl/pgl) and other forms of monitoring. *Cornblath et al. (2000) ‘at risk’ categories will be used. Exclusions: Interventions that must be initiated by a medical practitioner. Types of outcome measures Outcomes that are of interest include, but are not confined to: Successful breastfeeding Occurrence of hypoglycaemia Re-establishment and maintenance of bgl/pgl at or above set threshold (as defined in a particular study) Developmental outcomes. Search strategy A number of electronic databases will be searched to locate relevant studies in this subject area. Databases to be searched will include: CINAHL Cochrane Library NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination databases (DARE etc.) TRIP database MEDLINE/PubMed Australian Medical Index Current Contents Health and Medical Complete (Proquest 5000) Science Direct Ingenta Expanded Academic Index The search terms used to locate studies for the review will be drawn from the natural language terms of the topic and the controlled language indexing terms used by different databases, as applicable. Individual search strategies will be developed for each index, adopting the different terminology of index thesauri. In addition, since it has been established that difficulties can arise when using the MeSH terms from MEDLINE to locate clinical trials (Dickersin, Scherer, & Lefebvre, 1994), all databases will also be searched using the keywords of the topic. Efforts will be made to locate any relevant unpublished materials, such as conference papers, research reports, and dissertations. The sources searched to locate unpublished studies will include: Dissertation Abstracts conference proceedings research and clinical trials registers WWW sites of relevant associations direct communication with neonatal and midwifery organisations, and neonatal nurse or midwife researchers. Journals relevant to the topic and accessible in Western Australian libraries or online will be hand-searched to ensure useful studies that have not been listed in the major indexing services are located. For highly relevant journals hand-searches will be conducted for all available issues for 2001–2002. Reference lists of all studies and review papers will be examined to identify additional research studies. Full text versions of the studies located will be used for the initial assessment against the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Where abstracts in English exist for articles in Spanish, Italian or German, these will be reviewed (translation resources only being available in these languages). Two reviewers will conduct this assessment independently. Bibliographic details of the studies located will be organised using the Endnote software program. Methods of the review Critical appraisal All studies that meet the inclusion criteria will be assessed for methodological quality. Randomised controlled trials (RCT) will be assessed using a checklist (see attached) with accompanying notes to guide the review panel on aspects of quality. The checklist was initially based on the work of the Cochrane Collaboration (Oxman, 1994) and the Centre for Reviews and Dissemination at the University of York (NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, 2001) but has been further developed using quality assessment tools (eg. Downs & Black, 1998; Harbour & Miller, 2001; Reisch, Tyson, & Mize, 1989) recommended in the report Systems to Rate the Strength of Evidence (West et al., 2002). Reviewers will be asked to pilot the checklist and suggested modifications will be made to ensure clarity. The discussion arising from the piloting of the checklist contributes to the reviewers’ training. A quality assessment tool with accompanying notes has also been developed (from the same sources) for non-RCT studies and will be piloted and used if required. Two reviewers will independently assess all studies included in the review and disagreements between reviewers will be resolved by discussion with a third reviewer. Assessment of quality will commence with experimental studies (randomised and quasi-randomised controlled trials) and will be extended to include research using other methodologies in the absence of sufficient experimental studies. Data extraction Data will be extracted independently by two reviewers using a data extraction tool. A third reviewer will be asked to adjudicate if the initial reviewers disagree. The data extraction tool will be developed and pilot tested before use. This tool will include information such as type of design, details of randomisation (if used), study population, operational thresholds of bgl/pgl, intervention(s), outcomes as listed above, and quality of study assessment. When necessary, the principal primary researcher of a study will be contacted to obtain missing information. Data synthesis Heterogeneity between comparable studies will be tested using the standard chi-square test. Where possible, odds ratios and 95% confidence limits will be calculated for each included study. Significant heterogeneity will be considered present when the p-value is less than 0.05. When two or more comparable RCTs are identified the results will be pooled in a meta-analysis to determine the effectiveness of the intervention. The software program RevMan 4.1 will be used to perform the meta-analysis with double data entry utilised to minimise the risk of error during data input. The type of data collected will determine the approach used during the metaanalysis. For dichotomous data odds ratios will be calculated to measure effect. For continuous data measured using the same scale, the weighted mean difference will be used as a summary statistic. Standardised mean difference will be the summary statistic calculated for continuous data from different scales. In studies where statistical pooling of results is inappropriate, the findings will be considered for inclusion in a narrative summary. Guidelines Based on the findings of this systematic review a ‘Best Practice Guideline’, in the format designed by the Joanna Briggs Institute, will be developed.
Zitieren
APA
(2003). Midwifery/Nursing management of hypoglycaemia in healthy full term neonates. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. https://doi.org/10.11124/jbisrir-2003-651
Vancouver
Midwifery/Nursing management of hypoglycaemia in healthy full term neonates. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. 2003. doi:10.11124/jbisrir-2003-651
BibTeX
@article{euvimed2003,
title = {Midwifery/Nursing management of hypoglycaemia in healthy full term neonates},
journal = {JBI Library of Systematic Reviews},
year = {2003},
doi = {10.11124/jbisrir-2003-651}
}
EUVIMED