EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The clinical effectiveness of conservative management of children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy

JBI Library of Systematic Reviews · 2003

DOI: 10.11124/jbisrir-2003-647 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift JBI Library of Systematic Reviews, 2003.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Centre: Centre for Allied Health Evidence Contact for review / primary reviewer Dr Andrea BIALOCERKOWSKI School of Physiotherapy The University of Melbourne VIC 3010 phone 03 8344 6435 fax 03 8344 41988 email [email protected] Review panel Team leaders Dr Andrea Bialocerkowski - Centre for Allied Health Evidence / The School of Physiotherapy, The University of Melbourne Associate Professor Karen Grimmer - Centre for Allied Health Evidence / The School of Health Sciences, University of South Australia Research assistants × 2 Expert review panel The Obstetric Brachial Plexus Palsy team at the Royal Children's Hospital is committed to increasing the quality of care provided to these children and is striving to produce OBPP research of international standing. As such, the OBPP team supports this application, which is evidenced by all OBPP team members being on the expert review panel. The expert review panel will be based at the Royal Children's Hospital, Victoria, as this venue has the only Obstetric Brachial Plexus Clinic in Australia. Dr Bialocerkowski has recently been appointed as the Clinical Research Coordinator for Brachial Plexus and Hand Research at the Royal Children's Hospital and has established an Obstetric Brachial Plexus team, consisting of allied health and surgical clinicians. Commencement date 04/08/03 Expected completion date 04/08/04 Background This research addresses a distinct lack of synthesis of evidence regarding the effectiveness of conservative management for children, under the age of two years, diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy (OBPP). OBPP, a devastating complication of child-birth, occurs in 1–2 per 1000 live births internationally, which is comparable to the prevalence of other frequently occurring paediatric disorders, such as cerebral palsy and Down's syndrome (Dunham 2003, McNeeley and Drake 2002). The prevalence of OBPP in Australia is similar to international rates (Bates et al in press). Despite the substantial prevalence rate of this condition, the Royal Children's Hospital (situated in Parkville, Victoria) has the only Brachial Plexus Clinic and registry in Australia. At present over 200 children are on the Royal Children's Hospital OBPP registry, with approximately 20 children being diagnosed annually. The presentation of OBPP varies greatly in severity, extent of damage and functional use of the affected upper limb. Severity can range from neuropraxia to root avulsion, with nerve injury varying from one nerve to all roots in the brachial plexus (C5-T1). Moreover, the impact of OBPP ranges from temporary functional loss to a lifelong functional impairment in one arm (van Dijk et al 2001). Most children receive treatment for OBPP, however there is considerable controversy regarding the most appropriate form of management (Grossman et al 1997). In the first months of life, OBPP management usually consists of conservative measures, such as physiotherapy and occupational therapy. The aim of these therapies is to facilitate muscle function in the child's affected upper limb through play, as well as to prevent complications attributed to lack of movement, such as soft tissue contractures (Clarke and Curtis 1995, Dunham 2003). Some children regain the use of their affected upper limb within the first years of life, however the extent of recovery varies between studies due to different definitions of ‘recovery’, various outcome measures used and timing of these assessments. Moreover an appreciation of the natural history of OBPP is confounded by the use of early primary surgical procedures (van Dijk et al 2001). Generally, primary surgical procedures, to repair the brachial plexus, are performed on children who fail to improve, usually within the first two years of life (Waters 1999). However, the optimal timing for surgery is not known. Moreover, the most appropriate surgical technique has not been identified nor the children who would most benefit from surgery (Grossman et al 1997, van Dijk et al 2001). These concepts are evidenced by the results of a recent systematic review, where McNeekly and Drake (2003) found that there was no conclusive evidence showing a benefit of surgery in children with OBPP. Therefore, in order to provide the most effective treatment for children diagnosed with OBPP, there is an urgent need to determine the effectiveness of conservative management for children, under the age of two years, diagnosed with OBPP. No previous systematic reviews have been conducted in this area, as evidenced from searches on the Cochrane, DARE and TRIP, MEDLINE and Current Contents databases as well as the Internet. The results from this systematic review will be used to develop best practice guidelines for the treatment of children with OBPP by determining the characteristics of children who are likely benefit from conservative management. These guidelines will improve clinicians’ knowledge regarding the effectiveness of conservative management of children diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy. This, in turn, will increase the quality of care provided to these children, by optimising the functional ability of the affected upper limb and increasing their quality of life Objectives The objective of this systematic review is to review all available evidence on the effectiveness of conservative management for children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy (OBPP). The following questions will be addressed in this review: What physiotherapy and occupational therapy interventions are used for the conservative management of children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with OBPP? What is the evidence of the effectiveness of these interventions for children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with OBPP, in terms of functional recovery? What are the characteristics of children with OBPP who: improve in functional status following conservative management? fail to improve in functional status following conservative management? Type of studies Studies sourced by the search strategy will be graded according to the National Health and Medical Research Council Levels of Evidence (1999) (Appendix 1). It is expected that no Level I studies (systematic reviews) will be sourced, as evidenced by no systematic reviews sourced from previous searches on the Cochrane, DARE and TRIP, MEDLINE and Current Contents databases and the Internet. Therefore, all other forms of evidence (ranging from level II (randomised controlled trial) to level IV (case series)) will be used for this study. Types of participants Inclusion criteria for participants in each of the sourced studies includes: Age range: Children ranging from newborn babies to those who are two years of age Diagnosis: Diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy by clinical assessment and or diagnostic imaging (Birch 1996) Studies were excluded if they were conducted on children who had undergone surgery for obstetric brachial plexus palsy. Two years was used as the upper age limit for this systematic review, as most children who require brachial plexus surgery receive this treatment within the first two years of their life (Clarke and Curtis 1995, Waters 1999). Types of interventions Receiving any physiotherapy or occupational therapy for the treatment of obstetric brachial plexus palsy. Interventions could include facilitation of active movement of the upper limb, by gently tapping over the affected muscle, and by play, passive stretches of the affected musculature and splinting Types of outcome measures To answer the second question of this study, regarding the effectiveness of conservative management, function will be measured in relation to: whole upper limb, using the Toronto scale (Curtis et al 2002), the Mallet scale (Clarke and Curtis 1995); or shoulder, using the Gilbert scale (Gilbert 1993 cited in Bisinella and Birch 2003); or elbow using the Gilbert and Raimondi scale (Gilbert and Raimondi 1996 cited in Bisinella and Birch 2003); or hand, using the Raimondi scale (Raimondi 1993, cited in Bisinella and Birch 2003). These outcome measures are considered the gold standard for assessment of children, under the age of two years, with obstetric brachial plexus palsy (Clarke and Curtis 1995, Curtis et al 2002, Bisinella and Birch 2003). Search strategy Databases A number of databases will be used to source published research on the conservative treatment of children diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy. These include the Cochrane library, DARE, TRIP, MEDLINE, Current Contents, CINAHL, AMED, Web of Science, Proquest 5000, Austhealth, Evidence Based Medicine Reviews, Expanded Academic ASAP, Meditext, Science Direct, Proquest Digital Dissertations, OAIster and the Australian Digital Theses Program. The search will be limited to research reports published in English, over the last decade (July 1992 to June 2003) in order to source the most relevant, high quality and up to date literature (Maher et al 2001). Moreover, Reference lists from sourced papers will be examined to identify other relevant papers. Search terms A variety of terms have been used to describe obstetric brachial plexus palsy (OBPP), such as Erb's palsy and Klumpke's palsy. We found after reviewing 10 papers and their reference lists, that over thirty phrases describing OBPP are used in the literature. We consequently mapped these phrases to MeSH terms and found three consistently used MeSH terms: “brachial plexus neuropathies”, “birth injuries” and “paralysis, obstetric”. A similar problem existed for physiotherapy and occupational therapy interventions. However, we found five common MeSH terms: “treatment outcome”, “physiotherapy techniques”, “exercise therapy”, “occupational therapy” and “physical therapy techniques”. Therefore the following search strategy will be used for MeSH indexing databases: “brachial plexus neuropathies” OR “birth injuries” OR “paralysis, obstetric”. “treatment outcome” OR “physiotherapy techniques” OR “exercise therapy” OR “occupational therapy” OR “physical therapy techniques”. 1 and 2 For databases that do not use MeSH indexing, a simplified search strategy was devised, as there is limited ability to combine phrases or terms. General terms will be used, such as obstetric brachial plexus palsy, obstetrical palsy, congenital brachial plexus injury and Erb's palsy, as these terms were most frequently used to describe OBPP in our preliminary work. Other sources of literature Experts in the field will be contacted and requested to contribute relevant literature to this topic. Screening of papers Two reviewers will read the title and abstract of all papers sourced in order to determine each paper's suitability for inclusion into the study, based on the participant, intervention and outcome measures criteria. Where consensus is not reached, the full text version of the paper will be retrieved. The two reviewers will then assess and discuss the relevant aspects of this paper until a decision regarding its appropriateness for this review is achieved. All papers that meet the participant, intervention and outcome measures inclusion criteria will be included for quality assessment in this systematic review. Methods of review Assessment of methodological quality All studies that meet the inclusion criteria review will be assessed for methodological quality using the Critical Review Form - Quantitative Studies by Law et al (1998). This validated review form, which address all of the quality criteria recommended by Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (2002), consists of elements which address the study purpose, literature review, design of the study, study sample, outcomes, intervention, results, conclusions and clinical implications for all types of quantitative studies. This critical review form can be accessed on: http:www.fhs.mcmaster.ca/canchild/publications/quantform.pdf Data extraction Data will be extracted independently by two members of the research team using the data collection sheet contained in Appendix 2. This sheet will be set up in MS Excel, in order to efficiently manage the data and to reduce the chance of data entry errors when transferring information from paper-based data collection sheets to computer software. In any case of disagreement between reviewers, consensus will be reach by discussion. Data Synthesis If sufficient number of randomised controlled trials are located which use comparable outcome measures, meta-analysis will be undertaken. However, it is anticipated that due to heterogeneity in studies (such as the type of outcome measure used and the age of the child) a meta-analysis cannot be undertaken. In this case, data will be synthesised using a narrative format. It is envisaged that data will be synthesised using a narrative format, due to most evidence being level III and IV on the hierarchy of evidence. Moreover, different outcome measures used and time periods of assessment may preclude metaanalysis. Potential conflict of interest None

Zitieren

APA

(2003). The clinical effectiveness of conservative management of children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. https://doi.org/10.11124/jbisrir-2003-647

Vancouver

The clinical effectiveness of conservative management of children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy. JBI Library of Systematic Reviews. 2003. doi:10.11124/jbisrir-2003-647

BibTeX
@article{euvimed2003,
  title = {The clinical effectiveness of conservative management of children (under the age of two years) diagnosed with obstetric brachial plexus palsy},
  journal = {JBI Library of Systematic Reviews},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.11124/jbisrir-2003-647}
}
Kostenlos starten →