Rotations, Types, and Points of Theoretical Indeterminacy
Music Theory and Analysis (MTA) · 15.10.2025 · 12 (2) · 190-196
DOI: 10.11116/mta.12.2.3.5 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Music Theory and Analysis (MTA), erschienen am 15.10.2025. Verfasst von Benedict Taylor.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This analytical vignette is part of the colloquy “Sonata Typology in Two Finales by George Onslow.” Clearly standing in a sonata-rondo lineage, the finales of Onslow’s Piano Trio in E minor, Op. 14 No. 1, and his String Quintet in E minor, Op. 19, are exemplary case studies in the complications that may arise when attempting to fit actual musical forms into sonata typology. Both movements omit tonic refrains at the start of the recapitulation, and as a result exhibit close affinity to what sonata theory typology terms the expanded type 1 sonata. However, the absence of any cadence following the completion of the recapitulatory thematic rotation and the subsequent return of the refrain raises the spectre of the reversed recapitulation. This essay argues that in certain situations of analytical indeterminacy, the formal reading depends in large part on the (unsupported) presuppositions of the theoretical method adopted, thereby contending that analytical agnosticism may be the path of greater discretion.
Zitieren
APA
Taylor, B. (2025). Rotations, Types, and Points of Theoretical Indeterminacy. Music Theory and Analysis (MTA), 12(2), 190-196. https://doi.org/10.11116/mta.12.2.3.5
Vancouver
Taylor B. Rotations, Types, and Points of Theoretical Indeterminacy. Music Theory and Analysis (MTA). 2025;12(2):190-196. doi:10.11116/mta.12.2.3.5
BibTeX
@article{Taylor2025,
author = {Taylor, Benedict},
title = {Rotations, Types, and Points of Theoretical Indeterminacy},
journal = {Music Theory and Analysis (MTA)},
year = {2025},
volume = {12},
number = {2},
pages = {190--196},
doi = {10.11116/mta.12.2.3.5}
}
EUVIMED