Education and supervision have potential to make nursery school teachers and primary health nurses to valuable resources in the identification of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities
Acta Paediatrica · 2024
DOI: 10.1111/apa.17044 ↗Kurz gefasst
Editorial in der Zeitschrift Acta Paediatrica, 2024. Verfasst von Mats Cederlund. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Sahlgrenska Academy, Neurology and Physiology, Gothenburg University, Gothenburg, Sweden. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Schools, Nursery, School Teachers. Die Arbeit nennt 10 Literaturangaben.
Themen: Kinderkrankenpflege
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The identification and diagnosing of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities, in general, and autism in particular has received increasing attention all over the world over the last decades. The increasing awareness and need concerning children with neurodevelopmental disabilities have forced health providers to develop systems for the primary identification of these children within the national welfare systems. In many countries, the primary care of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities is managed by primary health nurses (PHNs) at childcare centres or equivalent, where health- and developmental check-ups are performed to identify children, who do not follow the typical developmental path. These children are then referred for further assessment, for example, to a speech- and language therapist, psychologist or a paediatrician/child neurologist. The nursery school is another institution, which has potential to play an important part in the identification of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities, since most children attend these. The nursery school teachers (NSTs) meet children at different developmental levels often for long periods of time and could hence be a valuable resource in the assessment of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities, albeit these teachers are often, for different reasons, reluctant to assess ‘their’ children's abilities. To identify children with developmental difficulties, quite a few questionnaires/ screening instruments have been developed over the last decades as tools to facilitate the collecting of information needed to lay the diagnostic ‘puzzle’. The Early Symptomatic Syndromes Eliciting Neurodevelopmental Clinical Examinations (ESSENCE) concept was invented by Christopher Gillberg, to direct focus on 12 areas within which children with neurodevelopmental disabilities often present difficulties.1, 2 The ESSENCE concept was developed into the ESSENCE-Questionnaire (ESSENCE-Q), a level-one screening instrument (i.e., developed for the general [unselected] population), with the aim to identify children with neurodevelopmental difficulties in need of further assessment.3 The ESSENCE-Q enquires about concerns in the areas included in contrast to other questionnaires, which focus on the presence of a particular symptom or behaviour. This more neutral way of approaching the child might assist in reducing the psychological resistance to score the shortcomings of the child in question, whether it is the parents or an NST/PHN, who is asked to assess the child. Previous research concerning the ESSENCE-Q has identified a similar cut-off level in which further assessment is to be considered.4-6 One previous study has argued that neurodevelopmental problems in young children can be identified effectively by involving experienced NSTs in the primary evaluation.7 However, in contrast, other studies came to the conclusion that NSTs often use the ‘wait and see approach’ to guide families, simply because they do not understand and master early childhood development well enough. The consequence of this is that the identification and thus the diagnosing of the child's disabilities is delayed, with the result that these children are denied assessment, support and care.8, 9 In this study by Kitazoe et al.,10 the aim was to explore whether repeated education and supervision of community PHNs and NSTs by a Speech and Language Pathologist (SLP), familiar with the ESSENCE concept, would increase the ESSENCE-Q scores, and reduce the score discrepancies, as was the supposed hypothesis. A PHN, two NSTs and a SLP, independently assessed children, collapsed into two groups, during indoor/outdoor play, art activities, physical activities and meals, as well as their interaction with the NSTs and peers. The change in score discrepancies was analysed for ESSENCE-Q cut-off scores, and total ESSENCE-Q scores across the PHNs and the NSTs, with the SLP scores used as a reference to evaluate sensitivity and specificity. The difference across the PHN/NSTs scores and the score of the SLP on the ESSENCE-Q was significantly smaller in the second group, in which the PHNs and the NSTs have had a longer duration of repeated education and supervision. This confirmed the supposed hypothesis and made the researchers suggest that repeated education and supervision by a specialist may improve the competence of PHNs/NSTs in assessing children by using the ESSENCE-Q. As suggested by the authors, further research in a larger cohort is needed to establish the role of repeated education and supervision in improving the competence of personnel such as PHNs and NSTs in the assessment of children with neurodevelopmental difficulties using the ESSENCE-Q. However, this study has shown that PHN/NSTs could play a part in the primary assessment of children not following the expected developmental path, given that they receive proper education and supervision from a specialist familiar with normal childhood development in general and for neurodevelopmental disabilities in particular. This study also emphasises the importance of different specialists cooperating for early detection, diagnosing and assistance to children with neurodevelopmental disabilities to help minimise their disabilities, and hence make their future life as good as it possibly can be. The ESSENCE-Q has previously been used by the assessing psychologist or physician at the child's assessment, and is a quite time-consuming process. By allowing NSTs and PHNs from childcare centres to perform the primary step of the assessment of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities the process could be simplified. In addition, by taking part in the assessment of these children the PHNs and NSTs involved might also be more aware of appropriate ways to work with these children, and more confident in how to discuss the children's difficulties with their caregivers including when to recommend referral to the appropriate professionals than was previously the case. However, for this to be successful over time, it is crucial to continuously educate and supervise NSTs and PHNs concerning the assessment of children with neurodevelopmental difficulties with the ESSENCE-Q or any chosen questionnaire. Mats Cederlund: Conceptualization. None.
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Sahlgrenska Academy, Neurology and Physiology, Gothenburg University, Gothenburg, Sweden.
ORCID-Profile: Mats Cederlund
Zitieren
APA
Cederlund, M. (2024). Education and supervision have potential to make nursery school teachers and primary health nurses to valuable resources in the identification of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities. Acta Paediatrica. https://doi.org/10.1111/apa.17044
Vancouver
Cederlund M. Education and supervision have potential to make nursery school teachers and primary health nurses to valuable resources in the identification of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities. Acta Paediatrica. 2024. doi:10.1111/apa.17044
BibTeX
@article{Cederlund2024,
author = {Cederlund, Mats},
title = {Education and supervision have potential to make nursery school teachers and primary health nurses to valuable resources in the identification of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities},
journal = {Acta Paediatrica},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.1111/apa.17044}
}
EUVIMED