Investment contracts and the quest for economic equilibrium: why UPICC? Reconciling the dichotomy between commercial contracts and state contracts
Uniform Law Review · 27.07.2026
DOI: 10.1093/ulr/unag026 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Uniform Law Review, online erschienen am 27.07.2026. Verfasst von Mohamed A M Ismail.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
A well-developed legal framework governing International Investment Contracts (IICs) is essential to fostering increased inflows of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) into host States. Such a framework also constitutes a significant instrument for advancing socio-economic development, insofar as it facilitates economic activity, promotes job creation, and contributes to the improvement of living standards. In particular, the expansion of investment through IICs may contribute to reducing unemployment, a factor frequently associated with heightened levels of social instability and, in certain contexts, criminal activity, including terrorist crime. IICs further play an important role in bridging traditional divergences between common law and civil law systems. They contribute to mitigating the traditional distinction between administrative contracts (contrats administratifs), which in some jurisdictions are characterized by the inclusion of exorbitant clauses, and the substantive principles governing international commercial contracts. A central issue in disputes arising from IICs concerns the disruption of the contract’s economic equilibrium. Given the long-term nature of such agreements, the preservation and, where necessary, restoration of their economic balance constitute a fundamental legal and economic challenge at the international level. In a long-term agreement, it is important to differentiate between contract price and contract value. Contract price, generally, has nowadays become a dynamic process rather than a static process (as it was in the past due to the traditional theory of administrative contracts). It is suggested that a review should occur on a regular basis in order to update the value of payments with the same contract price and to accommodate the rapid changes in the cost of raw materials. Following an introduction, the article is structured into four substantive parts. The second section examines the concept of force majeure in both commercial and administrative contracts, with particular reference to the relevant provisions of the UPICC and the ICC Model Clauses. The third section addresses hardship, analyzing its treatment under the UPICC and the ICC Model Hardship Clause, as well as its application in PPPs contracts within the MENA region. The fourth section provides an in-depth analysis of stabilization clauses, focusing on their conceptual foundations, legal nature, and types. It further considers the circumstances in which the operation of such clauses may be limited or excluded, particularly in light of public interest considerations or obligations arising under international law. The article concludes with a set of recommendations, emphasizing the critical role of the UPICC in international practice against the persistent lack of coherent and uniform standards governing economic equilibrium mechanisms and the award of compensation in the restoration of the economic equilibrium of IICs. It further highlights that the considerable discretion afforded to arbitral tribunals in selecting valuation methodologies has resulted in divergent approaches and inconsistent outcomes in the quantification of compensation. Accordingly, the article contends that the development of uniform and standardized framework governing economic equilibrium mechanisms, as well as the calculation of compensation, is essential for the effective and predictable operation of IICs at the global level.
Zitieren
APA
Ismail, M. A. M. (2026). Investment contracts and the quest for economic equilibrium: why UPICC? Reconciling the dichotomy between commercial contracts and state contracts. Uniform Law Review. https://doi.org/10.1093/ulr/unag026
Vancouver
Ismail MAM. Investment contracts and the quest for economic equilibrium: why UPICC? Reconciling the dichotomy between commercial contracts and state contracts. Uniform Law Review. 2026. doi:10.1093/ulr/unag026
BibTeX
@article{Ismail2026,
author = {Ismail, Mohamed A M},
title = {Investment contracts and the quest for economic equilibrium: why UPICC? Reconciling the dichotomy between commercial contracts and state contracts},
journal = {Uniform Law Review},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1093/ulr/unag026}
}
EUVIMED