Jaipreet Virdi, Echoes of Care: Deafness in Modern Britain
Social History of Medicine · 06.11.2026 · 39 (4) · 1022-1024
DOI: 10.1093/shm/hkaf088 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Social History of Medicine, online erschienen am 23.10.2025. Verfasst von Graeme Gooday.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Medical practitioners’ engagement with human deafness has never been a comfortable topic, as powerfully demonstrated in Jaipreet Virdi’s previous publications in disability history. While covering familiar territory (especially the notorious John Harrison Curtis) this book provides a useful guide to the uncomfortable relationships between physicians and deaf people in 19th century Britain. More concerned with medical attempts to cure or eliminate deafness than to offer care for it, Echoes of Care is framed within a traditional historiography of medicalisation which presumes that deafness was inexorably brought ever more completely under medical jurisdiction. Allusions to Michael Brown’s research on surgeons’ emotional lives primes us, however, not to see the succession of aurists, otologists and ENT surgeons as uncaring power-seekers of the kind that filled the pages of critical medical histories a generation ago.1 Virdi focuses on the minority of 19th century British and Irish physicians who sought to ‘cure’ or alleviate (usually unsuccessfully) the challenges of lifelong or acquired deafness. As typical of medicalisation approaches, the focus is not on the views, experiences, or agency of such deaf ‘patients’. Fortunately, between most chapters Virdi offers counterbalancing autobiographical cameos of those who identified as deaf, albeit unconnected to foregoing stories of physicians’ practice. For example, Mary Briggs, (p.130) records that she was ‘cured’ of deafness, but there is no discussion of the electro-therapy involved in her treatment. Could a quite different book on disability history have thus been written starting from such deafened subjects’ diverse experiences?
Zitieren
APA
Gooday, G. (2026). Jaipreet Virdi, Echoes of Care: Deafness in Modern Britain. Social History of Medicine, 39(4), 1022-1024. https://doi.org/10.1093/shm/hkaf088
Vancouver
Gooday G. Jaipreet Virdi, Echoes of Care: Deafness in Modern Britain. Social History of Medicine. 2026;39(4):1022-1024. doi:10.1093/shm/hkaf088
BibTeX
@article{Gooday2026,
author = {Gooday, Graeme},
title = {Jaipreet Virdi, Echoes of Care: Deafness in Modern Britain},
journal = {Social History of Medicine},
year = {2026},
volume = {39},
number = {4},
pages = {1022--1024},
doi = {10.1093/shm/hkaf088}
}
EUVIMED