O-05 - WHEN TEST POSITIVITY MISLEADS: USE OF THE GOLDSTEIN INDEX AS A MEASURE OF RESPIRATORY PATHOGEN INTENSITY IN PRIMARY CARE IN SCOTLAND
Journal of Public Health · 09.07.2026 · 48 (Supplement_1) · i3-i3
DOI: 10.1093/pubmed/fdag046.005 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Public Health, online erschienen am 09.07.2026. Verfasst von Dr Josie Evans und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Since October 2022, the nationally-representative CARI sentinel surveillance system in >100 GP practices in Scotland has used test-positivity (TP) to monitor 10 pathogens among patients presenting with acute respiratory infection (ARI). TP reflects relative pathogen prevalence among those tested but does not account for substantial variation in background ARI prevalence. The Goldstein index (GI), which combines TP with population-based ARI rates, may be a more valid measure of pathogen intensity.
Objectives
To compare GI and TP for selected infectious respiratory pathogens in Scotland.
Methods
GI, calculated as the product of CARI TP and Scotland-level ARI rates, was compared with TP for selected seasonal and non-seasonal pathogens. ARI rates are derived from GP consultation rates and are well-validated.
Results
COVID-19 showed a distinct temporal pattern compared with typical seasonal respiratory pathogens, with activity peaking during summer months when background ARI rates were low. Consequently, high TP did not translate into high population burden. During summer COVID-19 peaks, GI values were moderate: in July 2024, TP reached 22.3% (95%CI:19.0–26.0) with a GI of 28.8/100,000, while in August 2025 TP reached 20.5% (95%CI:15.9–25.9) with a GI of 20.0/100,000. In contrast, winter-peaking respiratory pathogens exhibited lower TP but higher GI, due to higher ARI rates. Seasonal coronavirus TP peaked at 14.2% (95%CI:12.1-16.7) in February 2024, but reached GI of 34.4/100,000, substantially higher than summer COVID-19 GI. Influenza showed a similar winter pattern, with peaks in TP coinciding with high ARI rates and consequently high GI.
Conclusion
GI is a more meaningful measure of pathogen intensity than TP, conveying population disease burden rather than relative prevalence among those tested. For non-seasonal pathogens such as COVID-19, TP can overstate intensity during low-ARI periods and obscure meaningful seasonal differences in impact. Incorporating GI into routine surveillance supports clearer risk communication and improved public health decision-making.
Zitieren
APA
Evans, D. J., McCabe, D. R., & Marsh, D. K. (2026). O-05 - WHEN TEST POSITIVITY MISLEADS: USE OF THE GOLDSTEIN INDEX AS A MEASURE OF RESPIRATORY PATHOGEN INTENSITY IN PRIMARY CARE IN SCOTLAND. Journal of Public Health, 48(Supplement_1), i3-i3. https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdag046.005
Vancouver
Evans DJ, McCabe DR, Marsh DK. O-05 - WHEN TEST POSITIVITY MISLEADS: USE OF THE GOLDSTEIN INDEX AS A MEASURE OF RESPIRATORY PATHOGEN INTENSITY IN PRIMARY CARE IN SCOTLAND. Journal of Public Health. 2026;48(Supplement_1):i3-i3. doi:10.1093/pubmed/fdag046.005
BibTeX
@article{Evans2026,
author = {Evans, Dr Josie and McCabe, Dr Ronan and Marsh, Dr Kimberly},
title = {O-05 - WHEN TEST POSITIVITY MISLEADS: USE OF THE GOLDSTEIN INDEX AS A MEASURE OF RESPIRATORY PATHOGEN INTENSITY IN PRIMARY CARE IN SCOTLAND},
journal = {Journal of Public Health},
year = {2026},
volume = {48},
number = {Supplement_1},
pages = {i3--i3},
doi = {10.1093/pubmed/fdag046.005}
}
EUVIMED