How the digital healthcare revolution leaves the most vulnerable behind
Journal of Public Health · 21.12.2023 · 45 (Supplement_1) · i2-i4
DOI: 10.1093/pubmed/fdad006 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Public Health, online erschienen am 21.12.2023. Verfasst von Omer Ali und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Delivery of Health Care, Employment. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 5-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 31 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, aspects of healthcare have been increasingly delivered online, emphasising the growing importance of digital skills for managing everyday life.1 While the digital revolution in health and social care has brought advantages for many, not everyone has been able to benefit equally from these developments.2 As health systems around the world strive to improve patient outcomes through technology, we discuss some of the practical and ethical considerations for digital inclusion and ask, who might this trend be leaving behind and what can we do about it?3 Ensuring the whole population has access to the internet is vital in the technological age and is a sustainable development goal.4 Despite significant progress in digital engagement during the pandemic, it remains deeply uneven in the UK. The biggest increase in digital engagement has been amongst the most engaged, whereas those on lower incomes were most likely to have reduced internet use during the pandemic.5 Currently, 4% of UK households do not have internet access, whereas 2.6 million people (5% of the population) have never used the internet (compared with 4.8 million or 8.4% of population in 2019).5,6 People living in areas of high deprivation are more likely to face barriers to getting online and not having the skills or confidence to use digital devices.7 There is also a global gender digital divide, with girls and women having less access to technology and the internet.8 Internet usage is also lower amongst those with disabilities.9,10 Digital inclusion can be enhanced by approaches which encourage local coordination, collaboration and community asset building. Such a model emerged through the NHS Widening Digital Participation Programme, which ran until 2020 as a collaboration between NHS Digital and the Good Things Foundation.11 Reintroducing and scaling up programmes such as this could potentially help towards reaching the estimated 20 million who have low or very low digital engagement.5 The Greater Manchester Digital Inclusion Taskforce is an example of this emerging on a locality level.12 Scotland and Wales have taken active approaches to digital inclusion that could also be replicated in other areas.13,14 We should also consider the ethical implications: could we be widening inequalities in healthcare access, and potentially health outcomes, by moving more of our health services online? Who owns or can utilise the data that are collected and how is individual and group privacy safeguarded? Will digitisation result in a better experience of care and better treatment or could it compromise patient safety?3 Healthcare accounts for the largest number of personal data breaches of all sectors, making up 19% of the total.15 Public awareness of health data privacy risks in the UK has risen since the extensive media and political scrutiny of care.data in 2013 and the General Practice Data for Research and Planning set-up to routinely extract primary care data for research and analytics.16 Questions have also arisen over the NHS Test and Trace app and the lax nature in which data is currently handle by some.3,17–19 Concerns have also been raised about a potential ‘inverse privacy law’, where the greatest amount of data is being captured of those who also have the fewest skills and opportunities to control its access by others.20 Examples include vulnerable citizens on the ‘shielding’ list during the pandemic and others interacting with the benefits or social care system.21 While digitisation could potentially help policymakers to understand and respond to inequalities, the extent to which this benefits individuals or communities can be hard to discern and also raises concerns about power and control.22 Digital literacy intersects with many other aspects of health literacy, as it does with other influences such as digital and financial literacy—and should not be viewed on its own.23 People with low health literacy are more likely to experience hospitalisation or premature death, more at risk of poverty and less likely to engage with preventative health.24 The pandemic has highlighted the gap in achieving equal access to education for children who do not have digital devices.25 Previous research has demonstrated the positive effect of education on health, which has been magnified in the digital era.26 Digital skills are now increasingly vital for accessing clinical information and advice, as well as economic and social resources affecting quality of life, such as online banking and opportunities for remote working.5,27 Given the ubiquity of digital services, there have been calls to include digital as a social determinant of health.11,28,29 Interventions to improve digital, health and financial literacy are therefore all needed if society is to help underserved communities breakout of a cycle of poverty and illness. Based on what is already known about some of the causes, features and consequences of digital health inequality, we suggest a number of practical and strategic measures that may be taken by NHS health and care bodies in the UK: Recommendations: When developing strategies for digitising patient-facing services, providers should strive to include digitally excluded groups, to ensure that health inequalities are not widened further. This should be accompanied by funding to support training, empowerment and access, as well as to preserve non-digital approaches for those to whom this not suited. The NHS should consider long-term revenue models that support and incentivise digital inclusion, rather than capital spending for short-term wins. Along with standards for interoperability and data protection rules, a strategy for digital inclusion should be a requirement in all digital health procurements.30 Efforts should be made to standardise the measurement and reporting of digital service access and its impacts on local health outcomes and inequalities.31 Communities and the wider public should be involved in the design of digital health initiatives, as well as patients already receiving care, in order to support preventive public health measures. Digital inclusion programmes should be appropriately tailored for individuals and communities to best support local needs. Opportunities should be taken to align such efforts with the work of trusted agencies and groups, such as public libraries and community organisations. Focus should be directed to areas of high deprivation. Initiatives aimed at capturing data for public health or medical research should balance the pro-social and pragmatic desire for richer and more useful information with the risks of excessively over-datafying individuals and communities in ways that could compromise their privacy or risk further inequality through discrimination and stigmatisation. Omer Ali, Internal Medicine Trainee, Honorary Lecturer Claudia Pagliari, Senior Lecturer Elizabeth Dalgarno, Lecturer in Healthcare Sciences Arpana Verma, Clinical Professor of Public Health and Epidemiology, Honorary Consultant in Public Health
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
- Global eHealth Group, Usher Institute, Edinburgh Global Health Academy & Centre for Population Health Sciences, The University of Edinburgh Medical School, Edinburgh, UK.
- Division of Population Health, Health Services Research and Primary Care, School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Biology, Medicine and Health, Stopford Building, The University of Manchester, Manchester Academic Health S…
ORCID-Profile: Omer Ali
Zitieren
APA
Ali, O., Pagliari, C., Dalgarno, E., & Verma, A. (2023). How the digital healthcare revolution leaves the most vulnerable behind. Journal of Public Health, 45(Supplement_1), i2-i4. https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdad006
Vancouver
Ali O, Pagliari C, Dalgarno E, Verma A. How the digital healthcare revolution leaves the most vulnerable behind. Journal of Public Health. 2023;45(Supplement_1):i2-i4. doi:10.1093/pubmed/fdad006
BibTeX
@article{Ali2023,
author = {Ali, Omer and Pagliari, Claudia and Dalgarno, Elizabeth and Verma, Arpana},
title = {How the digital healthcare revolution leaves the most vulnerable behind},
journal = {Journal of Public Health},
year = {2023},
volume = {45},
number = {Supplement_1},
pages = {i2--i4},
doi = {10.1093/pubmed/fdad006}
}
EUVIMED