Accreditation Can Advance Excellence in Physical Therapist Education: A Call to Action
Physical Therapy · 2024
DOI: 10.1093/ptj/pzae051 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Physical Therapy, 2024. Verfasst von Terry Nordstrom und 7 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Department of Physical Therapy, Samuel Merritt University, Oakland, California, USA. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Accreditation, Physical Therapy Specialty. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 4-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 30 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Physical therapist education faces headwinds from many fronts, including faculty and leadership vacancies, declining applicant pool, rising student debt, and continued growth in the number of programs. In this climate, initiatives to advance excellence in professional education become vitally important to secure the profession’s long-term success. Dedicated efforts are underway to support a vision for excellence in physical therapist education. 1,2 Encouragingly, the Commission on Accreditation in Physical Therapy Education’s (CAPTE) vision of “transforming physical therapy education to empower innovation, ensure excellence, and advance the profession for populations served”3 exceeds the core intent of specialized accreditation to assure that programs both meet the profession’s minimal quality standards and engage in program improvement; it establishes a basis for the role of CAPTE in the profession’s initiatives to advance excellence. CAPTE has been the subject of an editorial by this journal’s emeritus editor-in-chief,4 and there have been actions from the American Council of Academic Physical Therapy (ACAPT)5 and recommendations from papers that urge action from CAPTE to address multiple concerns in physical therapist education.6,7 Since its inception in 2013, ACAPT has passed at least two motions that recommend CAPTE action, including motions on excellence in physical therapist education and the organizational structure of the physical therapist education program.5 Members of ACAPT also have debated and approved several other motions that have implications for CAPTE, including program resources and growth in programs.5 There has been a recent point of view article in this journal generating letters to the editor that raised the question of what role CAPTE needs to play to address perceived threats to the profession, particularly with the recent growth in new programs, expansion programs, and increased class size among existing programs.7–9 The national study of excellence in physical therapist education included the recommendation below that directly addressed CAPTE: Continually innovate and take risks to drive the shared vision for practice and education forward. This means that CAPTE standards should have the flexibility to recognize innovation in physical therapist education. The current CAPTE accreditation program standards also need to better reflect the resources and processes needed to achieve excellence.10(p878) The CAPTE Standards and Required Elements (SRE) for accreditation are an important component to support excellence in physical therapist education and CAPTE is nearing completion of a revision of the SRE. While improving the standards for accreditation is important, we believe there is another pathway through which CAPTE can simultaneously advance excellence in physical therapist education. The purpose of this paper is to recommend how CAPTE can join other stakeholders in the profession to foster innovation and advance excellence in physical therapist education. We assert that to achieve its vision, CAPTE must change its processes and structures, and that it can do so while continuing to meet its responsibilities to the public and fulfill its mission to “…foster continuous improvement (and)… further[ing] quality in physical therapy education and practice.”3 We propose that an equity framework that supports socially responsible leadership and academic action can serve as a foundation for this change. The United States has an accreditation system in post-secondary education that is a combination of private action by institutions of higher education and components of federal and state authority, without singular central control.11 The system includes seven commissions for accreditation at the institutional level for traditional colleges and universities and many national and specialized accrediting agencies, including over 60 focused on professional education.12 Universities and colleges must meet requirements of their institutional accreditor plus requirements of each separate accreditation agency for the institution’s specialized programs, including those in the health professions. Importantly, the federal government relies on institutional accreditation to assure legislative intents are met, including access to Title IV funds for student financial aid, and to protect the public, which invests significant resources in higher education. Thus, institutional accreditation, while nominally voluntary, is a high-stakes venture for institutions and students alike given they both rely on federal financial aid. A higher education institution’s very existence would be threatened if it were not accredited in the voluntary system. Similarly, specialized accreditation is 1 component of a tripartite system, along with licensure and continuing professional development, that serves to protect the public. In the health professions, graduation from an accredited program is a requirement for graduates’ eligibility for licensure in many professions, including physical therapy. Thus, while specialized accreditation was once voluntary, it has become intertwined with law and regulation. The Figure illustrates the complex system that affects education and practice in the US, including CAPTE.13 United States system of accreditation in higher education. In a 2017 report on accreditation in health professions education, the National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine14 and a 2010 report from the Lancet Commission15 emphasized the importance of the relationship between the health professions and specialized accreditors to assure quality standards are met while driving excellence and innovation to ultimately improve patient outcomes. The report from the National Academies emphasized that, while specialized accreditation cannot and should not be at the leading edge of innovation in the profession, it can and should contribute to innovation and excellence through a collaborative relationship with the profession’s stakeholders.14 As outlined by Evans in 1978,16 and in more recent studies of accreditation in medical education,17–19 the challenges of specialized accreditation for institutions include accreditors’ differential emphasis on quality outcomes, processes and structures; varying levels of prescriptive standards; and different reporting mechanisms, resulting in increased administrative costs and burden on administrators, faculty and staff. In institutions that have multiple health professions these costs and burdens are compounded. Perhaps the only common requirement among the specialty accreditors is annual reporting, but even those reports do not share commonalities, adding to the administrative burden. There are also accreditation challenges for physical therapist education at the individual program level. The CAPTE approach to reaffirmation of accreditation rests on an implicit value of equality. That is, every program undergoes the same processes regardless of the past record. Even if a program has been continuously accredited for decades, with excellent student outcomes, highly productive faculty, strong administrative support, and stable finances, the same level of detailed attention to each standard is required as for new programs or those that have had challenges meeting standards or previous adverse actions. Although the self-reflection required by a self-study often results in quality improvement, this equality-focused, one-size-fits-all approach presents challenges and inefficiencies. In the authors’ experiences, the intense demands of a self-study require immense personnel resources over a multi-year period with possibly negative impacts on resource allocation for other initiatives, strategic planning, and innovation. Additionally, as stated in the National Academies report on accreditation in health professions education,14 planning and implementation of new, substantive initiatives often must often wait until the self-study process has ended, delaying important mission-driven improvements such as initiatives in diversity, equity and inclusion, curricular innovation, or new program development. With its emphasis on meeting minimal standards, accreditation processes may hinder the active pursuit of excellence for physical therapist programs with a history of meeting or exceeding quality standards. We believe that a new approach to reaffirmation of accreditation based on equity would allow programs to focus on initiatives to drive excellence and innovation while concurrently demonstrating adherence to CAPTE standards. While an equality framework would suggest that every person has shoes, an equity framework suggests that every person has shoes that fit. When applied to specialized accreditation, shoes that fit would mean that when seeking reaffirmation of accreditation, a high-performing program with a strong history could devote its resources to initiatives that advance excellence while still demonstrating they meet CAPTE standards. CAPTE would then be able to align its resources with the programs that most require assistance. Reviewers would devote their attention to assuring standards are met for all programs but focus on how high-performing programs are innovating for excellence. Two institutional accrediting bodies have successfully instituted models for reaffirmation of accreditation that provide examples for a pathway forward for CAPTE based on equity. The Higher Learning Commission (HLC) and Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC) have unique and innovative approaches to reaffirmation of accreditation. Both agencies use equity, as opposed to equality, as a guiding value in their work. WASC’s mission includes equity in its standards for its participating institutions and also incorporates equity into its work as an accrediting agency.20 CAPTE, which also includes equity in its mission, could take a similar path given there is a natural alignment of missions; therefore, comparison with these 2 exemplars is merited. Equitable approaches allow allocation of resources where they are most needed. For institutions and programs with a consistent history of strong outcomes, stability, and compliance, accreditation approaches based on equity allow institutions to leverage resources for innovation and excellence regarding strategic initiatives, curriculum design, and teaching and learning (as examples), while engaging in self-study processes that assure they continue to meet minimal criteria. Using an equity-based approach also allows HLC and WASC to allocate resources to those programs with the greatest need for support to achieve quality standards. HLC has a track record of focused innovation and responsiveness to stakeholders, including the Partners for Transformation aimed at reconceptualizing accrediting practices to assure quality in higher education.21 HLC offers important examples in its 2-level pathway model (open and standard), its training programs for site visitors, and its decision-making processes. The Open Pathway is an example of an equity-based approach. An institution selected for the Open Pathway on a 10-year cycle completes a streamlined review at year 4 with required supporting evidence that it is meeting accreditation criteria. It then embarks on a pre-approved quality improvement project from years 5 to 9 that focuses on academic quality and outcomes. HLC requires extensive and ongoing training for all peer reviewers and team chairs.22 Training focuses extensively on reviewer responsibilities, interviewing strategies, and writing evidentiary statements for team reports. Teams are required to have at least 2 pre-visit meetings prior to the on-site visit to develop a coordinated approach for the visit. These can be contrasted with CAPTE procedures which require mandatory training only for new reviewers and when there are revisions to the standards. While high-stakes decisions, including adverse decisions and initial accreditation, are done by the HLC Board of Trustees, efficiencies are achieved by having the Institutional Actions Council, composed of experienced peer reviewers and public members, make decisions on reaffirmation, mid-cycle reviews, substantive change requests, and reviews of institutional responses to the team report and recommendations. WASC is a recognized leader for its rigorous, yet flexible, equity-driven approaches to accreditation and innovation in accreditation practices.23 WASC Senior College and University Commission (WSCUC) offers a second example of an equity-based approach to reaffirmation of accreditation with recognition that institutions function across a continuum of risk for being out of compliance with accreditation standards. The Thematic Pathway for Reaffirmation (TPR) is an alternative pathway for reaffirmation of accreditation available to select institutions in WSCUC’s region. TPR is available to institutions that received a 9- or 10-year reaffirmation of accreditation during their prior review, have a history of financial and organizational stability, and strong outcomes.24 The TPR allows high-performing institutions to devote institutional resources to developing a theme that they determine merits further effort to enhance education quality and outcomes using a more streamlined, focused process. Examples of TPR themes include student success, new strategic plans, or faculty development. Being granted a TPR enables institutions to direct resources towards meaningful change while also demonstrating they meet accreditation standards. It also allows the WASC Commission to devote its resources to institutions that require greater effort to meet quality standards. The TPR requires that institutions demonstrate they meet accreditation criteria, engage in continuous self-review and improvement, demonstrate how they are improving student learning and educational quality, and focus on what is important to the institution. Institutions participating in the TPR address 4 of 9 components of the WSCUC standard report. These institutions demonstrate how their selected theme has improved educational quality and outcomes, and what they plan to do in the future to continue improvement. They must also explicitly connect the content of the TPR report to WASC standards in the narrative. The models described above suggest possibilities for CAPTE to release the power of innovation in physical therapist education by adopting new options and pathways that drive educational excellence. The road towards the CAPTE vision requires new and creative thinking, adaptive mindsets, and willingness to confront traditional thinking. Working with a broad group of stakeholders to address the obstacles and facilitate changes is critical. Our exploration of the role of accreditation in health professions education, the challenges of current accreditation practices, and the possibilities of new models of accreditation lead us to believe the following approaches are needed for CAPTE to ensure and advance excellence in physical therapist education: (1) develop differential, equitable pathways for accreditation; (2) create systems, structures, and processes devoted to driving innovation and excellence; (3) develop and strengthen accreditation standards that emphasize important standardized graduate outcomes; (4) institute thorough, rigorous, regular, and ongoing training for site reviewers; and (5) streamline and improve data collection and reporting mechanisms. The Table includes specific actions that CAPTE can take for each of these five recommendations. This paper focuses on the first recommendation because it is a new proposal for how CAPTE can be a key partner to achieve excellence in physical therapist education. Achieving all five outcomes would have far-reaching benefits for the profession and CAPTE. We believe that CAPTE and the profession have the resources to pursue all these initiatives simultaneously. Achieving standardized program outcomes that go beyond licensure pass rates and graduation rates has been a long-standing topic of discussion in the profession.6 Most recently, the “Benchmarking in Academic Physical Therapy” study with its use of the Physical Therapist-Graduation Questionnaire (PT-GQ), is establishing student-reported benchmarks for comparison among participating programs.25 Additionally, ACAPT will soon be collecting data from both faculty and students regarding their programs’ quality based on engagement.26 The profession, through the American Physical Therapy Association, ACAPT, and the American Physical Therapy Association Academy of Education has a long-standing commitment to develop competencies in the profession that will in all likelihood be linked with entrustable professional activities.27–29 The process of achieving consensus and implementation will take several years if work in medicine in this area is any indication.20 Together, though, these initiatives have the potential to finally generate standardized graduate outcomes in physical therapist education. Meanwhile, CAPTE can look to WASC and HLC as models for implementing equitable approaches for accreditation that preserve the obligation to concurrently meet minimal standards and invite innovation that leads to excellence and change. Recommendations for the Commission on the Accreditation in Physical Therapya Allow programs with a strong track record of meeting accreditation standards and a history of financial stability, excellent outcomes, and effective program leadership to pursue and address initiatives that promote strategy-driven quality improvement as integral to seeking reaffirmation of accreditation. Develop mechanisms to facilitate sharing of successful new initiatives so they could be adopted and improved upon by other programs, thus fostering excellence across the educational enterprise. Develop a dedicated team within CAPTE that includes professional and other stakeholders that builds on existing structures, but is new and different from the existing structure, to develop new pathways emphasizing innovation.30 Create streamlined accreditation decision-making processes based on the type of review for reaffirmation of accreditation that the program is undergoing. Collaborate with ACAPT, the Federation of State Boards of Physical Therapy, and other specialized accreditors to reduce administrative burden, eliminate redundancies, and provide an accessible robust database for stakeholders. Facilitate the use of data for benchmarking and comparison, and dissemination of program outcomes. Collaborate with other specialized accreditors in the health professions to develop a common data collection platform, as recommended by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.14 Enhance training to improve competence of reviewers, efficiency of the review process, consistency across reviews, and transparency of reviewer processes. Apply processes not only for assuring reviewers’ competence and quality for standard reviews, but also to assure they are able to implement reaccreditation visits intended to drive excellence and innovation. Standards should emphasize: Standardized graduate outcomes that reflect societal needs; Programs’ application of evidence-based approaches in teaching, learning, curriculum design, and assessment; Programs’ efforts related to diversity, equity, inclusion, justice, and advocacy; Program autonomy and financial resources. ACAPT = American Council of Academic Physical Therapy; CAPTE = Commission on the Accreditation in Physical Therapy. While we respect important function of CAPTE to assure physical therapist programs meet minimum standards and protect the public, we stress the need for fundamental changes to realize its vision of advancing excellence and innovation. We believe the changes we have proposed would allow programs freedom to employ innovative models supported by contemporary best practice; improve the equitable use of resource
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Stichwörter der Autor:innen
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Department of Physical Therapy, Samuel Merritt University, Oakland, California, USA.
- Physical Therapy Department, MGH Institute of Health Professions, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
- Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
- Department of Physical Therapy, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
- Department of Physical Therapy, School of Pharmacy and Health Professions, Creighton University, Omaha, Nebraska, USA.
- College of Health Professions, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA.
ORCID-Profile: Laurita Hack
Zitieren
APA
Nordstrom, T., Jette, D. U., Deusinger, S. S., Hack, L., Jensen, G. M., Kapasi, Z., Kluding, P., & Royeen, C. (2024). Accreditation Can Advance Excellence in Physical Therapist Education: A Call to Action. Physical Therapy. https://doi.org/10.1093/ptj/pzae051
Vancouver
Nordstrom T, Jette DU, Deusinger SS, Hack L, Jensen GM, Kapasi Z, et al. Accreditation Can Advance Excellence in Physical Therapist Education: A Call to Action. Physical Therapy. 2024. doi:10.1093/ptj/pzae051
BibTeX
@article{Nordstrom2024,
author = {Nordstrom, Terry and Jette, Diane U and Deusinger, Susan S and Hack, Laurita and Jensen, Gail M and Kapasi, Zoher and Kluding, Patricia and Royeen, Charlotte},
title = {Accreditation Can Advance Excellence in Physical Therapist Education: A Call to Action},
journal = {Physical Therapy},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.1093/ptj/pzae051}
}
EUVIMED