Bodies, Sport and Science in the Nineteenth Century
Past & Present · 2016-05 · 231 (1) · 169-200
DOI: 10.1093/pastj/gtw004 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Past & Present, online erschienen am 19.04.2016. Verfasst von Vanessa Heggie. Beteiligte Einrichtung: University of Birmingham. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 12-mal zitiert (Crossref). Der Volltext ist frei in PubMed Central verfügbar.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In 1876 the renowned American long-distance pedestrian Edward Payson Weston travelled to Britain to challenge local sportsmen and to raise his transatlantic sporting profile. In February, wearing his distinctive athletic outfit of knickerbockers, leather leggings and walking boots that ‘reach[ed] above the ankle’, he attempted a walk of 115 miles in twenty-four hours around a track in the Royal Agricultural Hall in Islington, London. 1 This race is relatively well known in the history of sport, used to demonstrate increasing internationalism, or perhaps increasing professionalization, in sport, both taken as symptoms of modernity. 2 My argument is that Weston’s walk should be allowed to intrude on other histories too: he was part of an international debate about science, and a national debate about the relationship between the state and its citizens, which embroiled chemists, physiologists, physicists, doctors and social reformers for years. This iteration of the debate had been sparked in earnest a little over a decade earlier, in 1865, when two German researchers climbed the Faulhorn, one of a ring of mountains in the Bernese Alps, eating only fried starch paste, drinking only sugary tea and meticulously collecting their urine. 3 Following the path from the Faulhorn to the Royal Agricultural Hall leads us through the first encounters between modern sports and modern, largely biomedical, sciences. Current historical writing portrays this connection as either non-existent or essentially antagonistic. 4 This article takes a contrary position, demonstrating instead how nineteenth-century science and sport came together in mutually beneficial interactions. This process helped to define notions of health, vigour and national identity, as well as solving some crucial scientific puzzles. Here I argue that paying closer attention to actors like Weston shifts our perspective on events like the Royal Agricultural Hall race, and will reveal other important stories: in Weston’s case, the earliest documented doping controversy in modern sport, an event so far entirely overlooked by historians. Modern sport and modern experimental science are both products of the intellectual and industrial changes that took place in nineteenth-century Europe; they are both nationally specific products, framed by local social and political institutions, while also both participating in an international trade in ideas and ideologies. 5 A set of common sociopolitical pressures, outlined below, acted to align the research priorities of science and the practices of sport across Europe. Consequently, both modern science and modern sport could express national strength or reveal national weakness, in physical as well as intellectual or economic terms; both were explicitly framed as processes to reform or preserve national bodies, literally as well as figuratively. Framed in this perspective, it may seem strange that the relationship between the two histories has not been better studied. In this article two explanations are given for this silence. Firstly, there is the tendency for nineteenth-century writers and thinkers to take the athletic adult male body as a default state, a ‘normal’ that does not merit comment. Sportsmen (and they are all men in this story) are effectively made invisible by this assumption, so that the sporting part of their identity is generally only visible in the relatively rare situations when it is challenged or problematic: when they are being studied in the context of claims that severe sporting exertion is unhealthy, or that their doping has affected a physiologist’s conclusions, or that their bodies are not good models on which to base policy relating to prison diets. Secondly, then, this variable visibility has led historians to suggest that doctors and scientists in the late nineteenth century were sceptical about the value of sport, or even acted to limit and constrain athletic participation. 6 One reason why this view has persisted is that it fits prevailing trends in the historiography of both sport and science. In this article these tendencies are opened out and criticized in more detail, but in brief the issue is that, in the case of sport, amateurism and scientific intervention are considered to be opposed to one another; in the case of science, a prioritization of attention towards laboratory sciences has meant that clinical field (and not to be of are to be in and and in field and clinical case and it is that these are the historical practices that to be in the history of and which on the of the and the of science. this is the that and from the nineteenth century been and in historical effectively a of on sport and science. In this article these are and a the of This process as not they a which is a issue the in which is as and like are and over when they are as they our of case of and the field on the Faulhorn, are in this they a Here I to walk through the that a to Weston’s doping in the of a one that will sport and science. In the I also how these events were about bodies, industrial and it will be to how the of modern sport were by and of physical and in the nineteenth the of the German the and body of the and the and sports of were and one and by sports but these all two important Firstly, all were to on the as well as the or the of and the of the were as variable as the Secondly, these to about national strength and national identity, or were by two that modern sport, and body was (and as a for modern national and or national and or sport and could be used to and physical of national they could also preserve or the national body and its social to or they or to or and they could be and of could also (and perhaps this is in the by literally and the bodies of German of and the more common other is one or and both were by the German one of the first of physical for were also as of and that national the was the the of in in to which he a the in used his in to a for his of body that, a like a German also a of and also in to a national body had been by the of the to to in his was on was known of the two were largely of the In case it was as a scientific of and were also explicitly to the which is why his Royal of in in was the first to state is also why it by was more and for this reason was in in the of its to ideas of well the and sports in this of is that they were to an sports were not the but the and social or their male they were around the and of a of institutions, that the and the of and This does not a and they and a of were also and closer of around the and in the of the and the to sports and not only could physical but could also and in and (and in the and political of the sports were also to as a from of physical and to the of the male and was these models of and that reformers to to the bodies of the to and was that, the of in and they or sports used and to the bodies of the in their well the century of the of and other in the of the century it was a and sports as a international to these the he instead the as from sporting as from these of sport and physical some of their or to a of across the the nineteenth and the of and the of a which was for the strength of economic and that to these across in the of the nineteenth these a framed about and as is a it to to or to from to it as well as physical (and its be or it be an used to political or to social scientific ideas were as or explanations but two in are is in a demonstrating a of the the by the of the nineteenth century it could also and could be or even as or to or to more the processes of were the and and were to and perhaps the and of could be far there is little in this to why the for is of an relationship between and the scientific to and that, has a in of both and national has been a common argument when connection is as the first of in by the German as that could be or from one to This was an for an as it the of This was by the of the of in (and its the of the in by the German could not be but to the of the and as all the in the had been This for the may seem from about and social but it was is the as his a of the of the a when industrial were when and could be and as by the of like and when were as the of and in the was was for this of about the by the of a of physiologists, explicitly to and a research in the late nineteenth century that to the of to the of physical is not a from the to framed as an it was the that bodies had a of to that and and on the This the and for bodies, as well as the be the of a to and in physical but the and were to be of is that these ideas were to the bodies of they were to the and of or to the of by the of their as or of these be in the of writing on by or bodies, the of the for these from in the to were as that bodies through the or of is an the as sport and physical were being as for they were also being for drinking and were and some sports were as or to but there was a connection to too: of of physical that their were or either to or to bodies as and in or was In some then, of sport and were also in and scientific could or the of taken the in the by the or even to and the historical for the of (and and were the to in the more has to a of the around and I that, while the body may been as a it was not a of or was a and while and to be in the the of bodies and could be over by a closer of like and in their historical context how they are by has on histories that an view of sport, doctors of as in that was in of by for the ‘normal’ that the adult there were of sport, and these may been by they to reveal the by sport in the of notions of and invisible by their in it is in situations their is being that are as a of the of scientific is that the athletic body is only be by that are explicitly and the athletic This is by the that the first scientific of was a through a to and the of In Edward a the Royal a a but a the of the in the and from the to on the of the was a to a debate that had taken place in the of in about the of the and on the This was by a from a that the by on their and to sceptical view of has been given a of attention by his was a but it a of and and other and to his in the of that was that, while the and to their of modern of and they on and was an of specific either or that the relationship between and This is a for the of may be a in to and One does not to that sport is or or there is a challenge to the far from of a of sport, may be an of the fits other nineteenth century was a of in of of the of were being practices had well history or as from the late century the to is in the of in to and This from of economic to the increasing which and and were and of modern sports to is that it in this to towards sports and that be by or was on trends in and when he out to their and and also on the out and and by to of or ‘normal’ and to as a the he from and about was as as their and in for in the was and a doctors and had been in the sport, their the of it was and in intellectual while it to had in of sceptical challenge and be in even take one the German an in which was as of towards the of a of Modern as In the to this that he to that the was an for (and his that he he so to sport like his is the that sport is and should his in of his that an may seem more to a In case, it been to to that, far from one was an entirely and of the that, while there were some in sport, of the and the and on as he had to bodies that in the of it was to that more of sport even of does not us conclusions, but it is and this is of its in (and even a in the to it as one of the first on it is a as the not only but also the between and This is as was not to a on of was instead an of the of sport on and which is why so of the is given over to clinical and of of their of their and and so this is out a of the of which for is a by the of a view of its the is not a on as the modern as the first on about modern science and modern sports in the nineteenth how it the first on is so on the over the of sport that it that when as a like and not an a a on been better German as a for the first on this was by the in an in it is that it is over sport and that sporting bodies visible as of scientific in this case, and were part of a debate that was far more and as in as it was in Britain was one of a body of and doctors in were the reform of physical and sport, a better studied in the but in the late the in and relating to and physical in part as to of national and the of to was to and in state but the and a the case for more and that an could more be in the of the when doctors and other in the nineteenth by to their in between the and the health, industrial and sport an for and to in reform and was one to the of a the and and on sport and in late nineteenth-century were In the was by the and it the of and of in to and and track of of the that were by he framed as and then, when studied and from and track his to suggest that sport and of the but to be as being as as they were this political it is and not is as the of sports not of the on in on the in sport, well the of and he is for his of and his of of the of all nineteenth-century an historians the this article this is towards the of and sports was not of a and while he may been one of the first to the that they were (and he was far from the first to is more and more was generally in of sports and he does suggest that and in so he to for he some of in are in the affected of the from of the was sceptical about more as a of as it so led to and but even he be the argument that doctors opposed sport, as he that part of the was that in in sports were not the that bodies could be a of to the and he fits better the more of and sport by more historical One other of is that he between in sport and in there is between the which from the or and the more or to which a has his his to his the he to the of and while the and This is why out the while the in the late nineteenth century it was not to researchers that the was a that a of being for specific and or an important for or was not the century that the bodies of were as other in other that these were bodies that were not to the of or which and to this it may not been or to that a for his or was a physical and this is that the of and sporting bodies to and about the is one of these by Edward Weston’s not only in its as part of a international the walk in the Royal Agricultural Hall also of the of the it is an the invisible of scientific the and of their were as in as they were in that how should the be and how that to their industrial or economic of the of was an debate the nineteenth and was its a was the of and and how was it In the German the that it was that was the and of for In the of the body were literally through a that which was and the were from the This was not an laboratory it also the of and sports as were by and in and for could also be from to the of from in the of and common as the and of the race to be good in meant they had a of to sporting and laboratory all in it is that the that is to even the it was not was In as an in research some on In and the were given by the for the of a to this This to a being to allowed the to and and and the and by their were was a and their that on other they that was the of in on to set known as the of for and these were used in the of by and institutions, and social across for the they were considered by the took two to challenge In the and the the Faulhorn as the for an to Faulhorn was a for scientific researchers in the and late nineteenth not it had a on the that was an of the be only by the of in the which could be by the of in their urine. by and on as eating fried starch and drinking sugary tea on the took and they a set of to the to their body the of the these from in and were part of the practices that the body a and could be and were the of as by their was not to for the they used in the were not for and for the but the researchers had made for other that fried a path the and so the of as been used was a and the between the from and the even had to that was they that some be by the of the in other and also a in the this a history of or science, and research as the of of and on to the of how scientists the of and in in the in or for the and the German for their on the of the that this debate was far from in the nineteenth scientists and the relationship between the of the and the of the body was not late as the American was more for this so by as his experimental In a article in the of and in the state of the and criticized the of and and the of the research in the a variable of their was or and their and for of this is a of and was more in was his of the long-distance pedestrian Edward to his that of the products of that were in the process of of was that and more his body and in a of scientific sporting and Weston to the in he was by was a and in in London. the he had a as a a of experimental and a of the also had a tendency to and the of experimental set of had been an to ideas about by the of as intellectual as is a in this in this case, had taken an experimental (and in the of the nineteenth while in Britain criticized this as it as of the of (and all of Weston’s transatlantic an far good to not only could he challenge a German but he could also one of his the used to the of by this to all the he his to walk 115 miles in twenty-four hours this was as on the part of one of the were and it was for This out to be a as but for his first article on and sport had to a and the from Weston’s only the and to to boots out miles and hours Weston also to his a and over two in his of Weston’s and and and his urine. were explicitly in by the science of is an that like be of are mutually the one the other is of in the is in the by has its by from other which of in a be not as so but as of Weston’s part of a but not one that challenged his of the was that a a of doping a and had been Weston’s and his on Weston’s around the of Weston was in the of the of the and out that this the of he affected the of and the of it and the of the race in which had Weston was the race in which there had been a the was the one and This scientific claims as Weston that this was the only he had used so all the other were and the This to the first of a about doping in modern a it is it is a to the more of nineteenth-century sport that to the an which is as one that not to to take or or to in (and not to take part in of the is not about the of a but about its for scientific is a that are to the of the A of about doping either that more this case demonstrate a towards the and of This doping also a far more important that an of was perhaps a for the of the a when was as a political and social science, of and were being in so why not the is there are when on were in this and these entirely to in which there is a political issue the of and the nineteenth-century about and is an set of about the of or in the In in the and to the of the to the of in the and there were between and over of and for economic and could by or of were also for physical of were as well as being a for international they were used by reformers (and their as of the or for the was that of Edward studied the of prison and had to on the and attempted to was but he in and the of the and the he also and to the Faulhorn he criticized that In and the to in the of in the and of clinical used as of in the to and This had in the of and In like was taken and criticized by when he studied Weston in the so this a transatlantic as well as a social scientists and on not to a in the sporting in he is as a in the of for the of this the only for was a as as his research on the of and the it is that even in this research relatively political it was rare for to be criticized they used as they were it was of the of that it was not that a or were of to the or as from on the of sport, the of of more towards the of the bodies, could be of when the American his an of the research on
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- University of Birmingham.
Zitieren
APA
Heggie, V. (2016). Bodies, Sport and Science in the Nineteenth Century. Past & Present, 231(1), 169-200. https://doi.org/10.1093/pastj/gtw004
Vancouver
Heggie V. Bodies, Sport and Science in the Nineteenth Century. Past & Present. 2016;231(1):169-200. doi:10.1093/pastj/gtw004
BibTeX
@article{Heggie2016,
author = {Heggie, Vanessa},
title = {Bodies, Sport and Science in the Nineteenth Century},
journal = {Past & Present},
year = {2016},
volume = {231},
number = {1},
pages = {169--200},
doi = {10.1093/pastj/gtw004}
}
EUVIMED