EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The Use and Interpretation of Race and Ethnicity in Research on Tobacco and Nicotine Products

Luisa N Borrell iD, Renee D Goodwin iD

Nicotine and Tobacco Research · 2023

DOI: 10.1093/ntr/ntad082 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Nicotine and Tobacco Research, 2023. Verfasst von Luisa N Borrell und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, Graduate School of Public Health & Health Policy, City University of New York (CUNY), New York, NY, USA. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Tobacco Products, Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 4-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 10 Literaturangaben.

AbstractSchlagwörterBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Several journals have recently published editorials and statements on the use of language around race and ethnicity.1,2 Such editorials call our attention to the need for a better, common understanding of what is meant when these terms are used in research, how the information on race and ethnicity is collected (self-identification by the individual vs assigned by the observer), when the terms can be used appropriately, and how to interpret findings related to race and ethnicity. This emphasis on specificity also helps us to reflect both on how the language we use affects the work we do, and on its impact as findings are translated into policies and practices. The use of common self-identifiers such as race, ethnicity, ancestry or origin, migration status, etc. can have substantial implications for public health and health policy. However, the way in which race and ethnicity are used in research is continually debated. This is especially the case when findings associated with race and ethnicity are interpreted as evidence of biological or genetic differences. As Nicotine & Tobacco Research (N&TR) receives biobehavioral, epidemiological and prevention research, and racial and ethnic inequities in tobacco/nicotine use and tobacco-related disease are increasing, we aim to provide context on the use of race and ethnicity in the field, and recommendations for the interpretation of findings related to race and ethnicity when used in research submitted for publication. From our ­perspective, discussion and clarification of specific terms is particularly relevant for the editors, authors, reviewers, and readership of N&TR. Race and ethnicity are social constructs shaped by socio-political and economic forces. Therefore, these constructs should not be used as proxies for biological or genetic differences. In fact, the racial and ethnic inequities observed in health outcomes and/or related behaviors reflect the embodiment of the cumulative biological effects of an individual’s social and environmental exposures across the lifecourse.3 This exposure may be captured by an individual’s race or ethnicity as identified in a particular society, but it is not equivalent to nor determined by their race and/or ethnicity, per se. Race is based on physical characteristics and skin color whereas ethnicity captures beliefs, norms, and shared culture by a group or population.4 Of note, individuals who identify with the only ethnic group for which data are collected in the United States, Hispanic/Latino, can be of any race. It is not ­unusual to see racial/ethnic inequity findings attributed to genetics or some inherited ­behavior differences among racial/ethnic groups.5 For example, over 80% of Black adults in the United States who smoke cigarette prefer menthol cigarette or with menthol filters.6 However, this preference is related to the tobacco companies targeted advertising to Black adults,7 and thus not related to the genetic make-up associated with Black race. Ancestry, another population descriptor, is associated with population origin, whether genealogic or geographic, and in some cases, may be used to reflect differences in genetic background.5 However, ancestry should not be equated or use interchangeably with race and/or ethnicity or vice versa. Calling attention to how language is employed in the ­scientific discourse in tobacco control around race and ethnicity, and how this may impact and/or inadvertently misrepresent the reasons for the existing inequities in tobacco use and tobacco-related diseases in many countries, is a key motivation. Widening inequities in tobacco use in some countries, such as the United States,8 underscore the need to examine differences by race and ethnicity to continue monitoring tobacco/nicotine use inequities in the field. For instance, a search in PubMed of articles published in the Journal between January 1, 2021 and May 11, 2023, yielded 799 articles with 10% (n = 80) of these articles including race and/or ethnicity somewhere in the article. These articles used race or ethnicity to refer to the study population, either as a characteristic that required adjustment in statistical analyses, or as stratification variable to identify group differences or inequities. Thus, how these population descriptors or identifiers are used impacts how findings are interpreted and used in policy making, resource allocation, treatment, public health practice, and research priorities. When using language around race and ethnicity, we need to be explicit about whether we are considering these constructs as exposures or moderators (ie, effect measure modifiers). Based on the use of these constructs, we recommend first that authors specifically clarify how information on race and/or ethnicity was collected (ie, self-identified with an open-ended question, self-reported with discrete choice options, or assigned/ascribed by an observer). Self-identification of race and ethnicity is preferred over assigned or ascribed by the observer. Specifically, it is our position that for individuals participating in such research, self-­identification is critical (vs. the researcher/other ascribing identity to an individual) because self-identification categories are used as predictor or stratification variables in statistical analyses. In addition, finer categories are encouraged for self-identification whenever is possible. Second, we suggest that authors communicate the rationale for their inclusion of information on race and ethnicity whenever used (eg, social exposure or proxy for racism, or as a measure of population stratification). Third, authors should streamline interpretation of results when reported by race and ethnicity by laying out the mechanism(s) or cause underlying any putative associations with tobacco use or a tobacco-related disease or behavior and the role of context (ie, being Black in the United States leads to very different exposures than being Black in Jamaica or Nigeria). While individuals in various countries may identify as Black, the experiences and exposures for these individuals may be very different: In the United States, being Black is not only plagued by the history of racism but also by being part of a minoritized group or a subordinated group impacted by the socio-political hierarchies and policies of a society related but not limited to low access to resources, power, and wealth. In addition, a large proportion of the Black population tend to live in segregated and below the poverty level communities. In contrast, being Black in Jamaica or Nigeria means being part of a larger community or population with a wide range of access to political and financial power, albeit in a country that may lack political and financial power relative to the Global North. We know that segregated communities in the United States are targeted by tobacco companies, and that poverty is a stressor linked with tobacco use. Interestingly, as market size in the United States and other countries in the Global North changes or dwindles, many tobacco companies may be looking at emerging markets in developing countries. Thus, explication of the mechanisms is critical as race or ethnicity meanings may change over time. Finally—and related to poverty—race and ethnicity are predecessors of socioeconomic indicators such as education and income. Race and ethnicity should not be used as a proxy for these indicators as racial and ethnic inequities remain even after adjustment because these indicators are incommensurable across racial and ethnic groups.9 Specifically, and consistent with the “Diminishing Returns Hypothesis,”10 minoritized groups such as Black people get fewer health benefit with increasing socioeconomic position than white people in the United States. Given the interest of addressing health inequities related to race and ethnicity, it is essential to consider these constructs in the context of the totality of their meaning for the place of individuals in a given society. Specifically, we, as researchers interested on population health, must account for the opportunities (or lack of) to resources associated with race and ethnicity that serve as fundamental causes of health and disease in society. Thus, if we are serious about eliminating racial and ethnic health inequities in tobacco use and tobacco-related disease, and extending to health outcomes in general, we must be explicit when using race and ethnicity with regards to their intended meanings and implications of research findings on public health and health care policy both, in the United States and around the world. None declared.

Schlagwörter

MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)

Tobacco ProductsElectronic Nicotine Delivery SystemsHumansNicotineEthnicitySmokingTobacco Use

Substanzen

Nicotine

Autor:innen und Institutionen

  • Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, Graduate School of Public Health & Health Policy, City University of New York (CUNY), New York, NY, USA.
  • Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA.

ORCID-Profile: Luisa N Borrell, Renee D Goodwin

Zitieren

APA

Borrell, L. N., & Goodwin, R. D. (2023). The Use and Interpretation of Race and Ethnicity in Research on Tobacco and Nicotine Products. Nicotine and Tobacco Research. https://doi.org/10.1093/ntr/ntad082

Vancouver

Borrell LN, Goodwin RD. The Use and Interpretation of Race and Ethnicity in Research on Tobacco and Nicotine Products. Nicotine and Tobacco Research. 2023. doi:10.1093/ntr/ntad082

BibTeX
@article{Borrell2023,
  author = {Borrell, Luisa N and Goodwin, Renee D},
  title = {The Use and Interpretation of Race and Ethnicity in Research on Tobacco and Nicotine Products},
  journal = {Nicotine and Tobacco Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1093/ntr/ntad082}
}
Kostenlos starten →