Migrants’ kidney sales, Fortress Europe and the transplant community: a call for awareness
Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation · 2024
DOI: 10.1093/ndt/gfae100 ↗Kurz gefasst
Editorial in der Zeitschrift Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 2024. Verfasst von Zanna Ramaekers und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Department of Internal Medicine, Nephrology and Kidney Transplantation, Erasmus MC Transplant Institute, University Medical Center Rotterdam, Rotterd…. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Kidney Transplantation, Transients and Migrants. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 1-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 25 Literaturangaben. Gefördert von: NWO.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
It is widely reported that the socio-economically marginalized are vulnerable to organ sale [1]. The illicit trade is a response to severe shortages in legally sourced organs for transplantation, and is proliferating globally [2–4]. The World Health Organization estimated in 2007 that 5% of all transplants worldwide are performed illegally [5]. A 2017 report by a financial think-tank has estimated that the organ trade ranks in the top 10 of the most lucrative international organized crimes, with a projected annual profit of up to $1.7 billion [6]. At the time of writing, only 15 convictions involving payments for organs and/or human trafficking for the purpose of organ removal have been reported to the Case Law Database of the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. A study by the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe identified eight additional cases (Fig. 1) [7, 8]. The trade in living donor kidneys is the most commonly reported form of organ trade [1, 5, 7, 8]. Formally reported convictions. In total, 23 cases have been reported to the case law database of the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) [7, 8]. Some countries have reported multiple convictions. There is increasing evidence that particularly migrants without a legal basis for entering and residing in transit or host countries, also known as irregular or undocumented migrants, are vulnerable to kidney sale and forced organ removal. Recent pioneering research by Columb has revealed that in Egypt, undocumented migrants from Eritrea, Sudan, Somalia and Ethiopia are selling their kidneys. Many do so through human smuggling networks to facilitate their entry into Europe [9]. Columb explains how tighter migration controls across the Euro-Mediterranean border have multiplied the risk and vulnerability of undocumented migrants to kidney sale [9]. He further demonstrates how recruiters, brokers, smugglers, transplant doctors, and other personnel from hospitals, tissue-typing labs and embassies collaborate in organizing these illegal kidney transplant operations. Crucially, he corroborates earlier research findings from other parts of the world that suggest that the medical sector, among other legal service providers, is wittingly and unwittingly involved in facilitating, laundering and sustaining illegal organ transplantations [9–11]. In Egypt, undocumented migrants are lucrative and strategic targets because they are the least likely to report their kidney sale—or theft. Given that kidney sales are prohibited, kidney sellers risk prosecution if they were to report transplant abuses. Moreover, since they reside in the country illegally, undocumented migrants also risk detention and/or deportation if their presence in the country were to be exposed [9]. Egypt is not an isolated case, however. Reports of migrants selling, or being approached for the sale of their kidney during their journey, are now also sparsely emerging from other countries including the Netherlands [12], Greece [13], Italy [14] and Turkey [15]. To date, limited research has been conducted about the motives and pressures behind migrants’ kidney sales and the experiences transplant professionals may have with this issue. This has prompted us to conduct multi-sited ethnographic fieldwork in the aforementioned four countries [16]. Our aim is to understand the experiences and considerations of migrants vis-à-vis the sale of their kidneys, as well as the experiences and attitudes of transplant professionals towards kidney sale in a restrictive migration control context. Until the end of 2026, we will speak with migrants and transplant professionals in the Netherlands, Greece, Italy and Turkey, to understand what they say, hear and experience about kidney sales. Whilst our research is ongoing, we can confirm that in these countries, narratives about migrants selling their kidneys, and having their kidneys forcibly removed, are circulating. While law enforcement and law and policy-makers are tasked, in theory, with enforcing and regulating this problem, it also begs the question, what role do we, can we and should we, as a transplant community, assume in preventing and reporting migrants’ kidney sales? According to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, the number of people forced to flee their homes stands at its highest since records began, and continues to rise due to environmental crises, conflict and persecution. Current projections estimate that globally, 130 million will be displaced by the end of 2024 [17]. In Europe, registered irregular arrivals are steadily increasing but numbers are not nearly as high as the peak of the 2015 ‘migration crisis’ when ‘Fortress Europe’ arguably resurrected [18]. Attempts to halt irregular arrivals include tighter border controls, stricter asylum policies and debatable ‘third country’ agreements with for example Turkey, Tunisia, Albania and Egypt [19]. Nonetheless, in 2023, an estimated 355 300 people entered the European Union irregularly, which is the highest recorded number since 2016 [20]. Europe's tightening of legal pathways are thus—at least to some extent—ineffective in halting migration. Instead, it has triggered the criminalization and commercialization of irregular migration, turning human smuggling and organ trade into profitable businesses [5]. Given the continued exercising of Europe's exclusionary migration policies, the growing organ scarcity and predictions of forced migration, it can be expected that kidney sales by irregular migrants will persist or even grow. This raises difficult questions for the transplant community. Should we take a stance against irregular migrants selling their kidney? If we voice our objection and call for action to prevent and halt migrants’ kidney sales, can this be done without also responding critically to European migration governance? If we decide to respond to Europe's migration policy, how should this response take form? If we choose silence, what will be the implications? While addressing these questions may unwillingly nudge us into a polarizing migration debate, we have affirmed in the Declaration of Istanbul that ‘health professionals should assist in preventing and addressing organ trafficking’ [21]. Subsequent guidelines have highlighted that in order to effectively do so, means of reporting are crucial. These guidelines recommend, among others, that health professionals identify and report signs of purchased organs [22]. This information, in turn, can potentially support law enforcement in identifying and prosecuting those who facilitate illegal transplants [23, 24]. An increasing number of countries are now establishing ‘focal points’ that allow health professionals to report patients who travel for (dubious) transplantations [25]. However, current guidelines almost exclusively focus on patients who are suspected of organ purchase. Knowledge and awareness of identification, reporting and treatment of organ sellers, such as migrants who have sold a kidney, is largely non-existent. This information may be equally vital in supporting law enforcement to identify and prosecute those who exploit vulnerable persons for their organs. While more knowledge and understanding remains to be acquired on this issue, alertness to our positionality within this newly emerging debate is warranted and highly needed. Our research is funded by the Dutch Research Council (NWO) under the Veni Programme. Grant no. VI.Veni/201R.010 (2021-2026). Z.R. and F.A. wrote the article. M.R. and R.S. gave feedback to drafts. The authors have no conflict of interest to report.
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Department of Internal Medicine, Nephrology and Kidney Transplantation, Erasmus MC Transplant Institute, University Medical Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
- Criminology, Department of Law, Society, and Crime, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
- Bureau Beke, Arnhem, The Netherlands.
ORCID-Profile: Frederike Ambagtsheer
Förderung
- NWO
Zitieren
APA
Ramaekers, Z., Reinders, M. E. J., Staring, R., & Ambagtsheer, F. (2024). Migrants’ kidney sales, Fortress Europe and the transplant community: a call for awareness. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation. https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfae100
Vancouver
Ramaekers Z, Reinders MEJ, Staring R, Ambagtsheer F. Migrants’ kidney sales, Fortress Europe and the transplant community: a call for awareness. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation. 2024. doi:10.1093/ndt/gfae100
BibTeX
@article{Ramaekers2024,
author = {Ramaekers, Zanna and Reinders, Marlies E J and Staring, Richard and Ambagtsheer, Frederike},
title = {Migrants’ kidney sales, Fortress Europe and the transplant community: a call for awareness},
journal = {Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.1093/ndt/gfae100}
}
EUVIMED